Monthly Archives: November 2024

The King Loves

Standard

Disclaimer: this is a review, and as such it contains spoilers of the whole series. Please proceed to read at your own risk if you still plan on watching this show or if you haven’t finished it yet. You have been warned.

The King Loves
(왕은 사랑한다 / Wangeun Saranghanda)
MyDramaList rating: 7.0/10

Hello everyone! Just thought I’d close off the month November with another review. It’s a bit of a busy period for me as I’m in the final editing stages of my book translation – my deadline is next week, I can’t even believe it – but luckily I found more time in-between to watch another historical drama that had been on my list for a while. I wasn’t quite sure how long it would take me to finish it since it was quite lengthy, but I ended up getting pretty wrapped up in it and basically binged the final couple of episodes, so here we are! After watching Alchemy of Souls at the beginning of this year, it felt like a really long time since I watched a good old historical K-Drama, and despite some confusions within the story I’ll admit from the start that I enjoyed watching it a lot. It really kept me engaged and on my toes until the end and I’m excited to share my views on it.

The King Loves is an MBC historical K-Drama with 20 episodes of about an hour each. I saw on MyDramaList that you can also watch it as 40 episodes of 35 minutes, but I couldn’t find this back-to-back format anywhere, so I watched it on Dramacool in the 20-episode format.
Although many historical K-Dramas feature fictional kingdoms and rulers, this story is actually based on real historical events and people. I found this kind of cool and even did a little bit of research on the side to get a better grasp of the political context it was based on. According to the historical facts, the story takes place around the late 13th to early 14th century, during the reign of the 25th King of Goryeo, King Chungnyeol (played by Jung Bo Seok). During this time, the Goryeo dynasty was under the rule of the Mongol-founded Yuan dynasty, reigned by the Mongolian Emperor Kublai Khan. Around 1270, the King married Kublai Khan’s youngest daughter who then became Queen Wonseong (as a teen played by Kim Bo Ra). The King already had a son with his first wife Princess Jeonghwa, but Queen Wonseong had a nasty temper and couldn’t stand the competition. After giving birth to a son herself, the Queen managed to chase both Princess Jeonghwa and her son Prince Gangyang away and they were never seen again.
Because King Chungnyeol and Queen Wonseong’s son has both Korean and Yuan blood in him, this makes him a half-blood and therefore unworthy in the eyes of the pro-Goryeo/anti-Yuan movement. This half-blood Crown Prince, Wang Won (as a teen played by Nam Da Reum) grows up in solitude and confinement, dealing with the souring relationship between his parents. His only friend is the third son of the King’s Chancellor, Wang Rin (as a teen played by Yoon Chan Young). The reason they have the same family name is that Rin is actually a cousin of Princess Jeonghwa, and therefore a royal cousin to Won as well. Rin is the first person to introduce Won to life outside of the castle, and Won quickly starts preferring roaming uncharted territory to sitting inside the palace all day long.
One day, however, the two boys witness a horrible bandit attack on a carriage transporting the Minister of Finance’s wife and daughter. This event leaves Won with a crippling sense of guilt because he urged Rin not to call for help as he didn’t think the bandit attack would be serious. The attack costs the lives of the Minister’s wife and all of the guards protecting her. The reason the carriage wasn’t as well-guarded was because a few guards were accompanying the Minister’s daughter and her maid on a stroll outside the carriage. The daughter, Eun San (as a teen played by Lee Seo Yeon), only escaped because she happened to have lent her family’s cape to her maid Bi Yeon (as a teen played by Song Soo Hyun), after which the attackers mistook Bi Yeon for her because of her clothing. Bi Yeon gets struck in the face which leaves her with a horrible scar, but she fortunately survives the assault. In the chaos that unfolds after they return home, it’s decided that Bi Yeon will take San’s place and that she will hide the scar on her face with a veil. San herself will have to flee in order to avoid being sent to Yuan as a “tribute” – one of the deals between Goryeo and Yuan was that Goryeo would annually select a group of young women to be sent to Yuan as concubines. The scar would be enough to keep Bi Yeon from being selected and exposed, but San would have to disappear.
Right before she leaves, San encounters Won and Rin, who have come to deliver the dying message of her mother. Thinking that the girl in front of them is the maid, Won delivers the message San’s mother shared before she passed: that she hopes her daughter will not hate anyone and that she will keep prancing and smiling as she always has.
Time passes and it is now eight years later. Looking for counsel on his position as a shunned half-blood Crown Prince, Won (now played by Im Si Wan) has set out to Mount Duta with Rin (now played by Hong Jong Hyun) to visit the wise Master Lee Seung Hyu (played by Eom Hyo Seob). When they arrive there, both their gazes are immediately drawn to Master Lee’s favorite student, a young woman by the name of So Hwa (played by Yoona/Im Yoon Ah). Won immediately recognizes her as the girl from eight years ago.
As the three of them get acquainted and So Hwa/San eventually returns to Goryeo to visit her father and maid, tensions rise when both Won and Rin realize they’re falling for her, and this seriously strains their solid friendship. Besides this, an anti-Yuan conspiracy is set in motion by several royal officials to get rid of the Crown Prince and restore the pure Goryeo blood lineage to the kingdom.

Honestly, so much happens in this series that mentioning everything and everyone will be a nearly impossible task. Of course I don’t need to summarize the whole thing as this review is meant for people who’ve already watched it, but there’s just a lot of things I can’t skip over with regards to the points I wish to discuss in my review, so I’m going to try and write a summary of the main events as succinctly as I can.
As the relationship between Goryeo and Yuan remains strained, so does the one between the King and Queen (now played by Jang Young Nam). The King finds a new confidante in Song In (played by Oh Min Seok), the cousin of Royal Assistant Secretary Song Bang Yeong (Choi Jong Hwan). What he doesn’t know is that Song In is plotting to get rid of the Crown Prince and sever all ties with Yuan to purge Goryeo from its “barbaric” lineage. He gets help from different spies within the palace on both the King’s and Queen’s sides. As a final trump card, Song In brings in his own lover, Ok Boo Yong (played by Choo Soo Hyun) to seduce the King and intoxicate both him and the Queen. Won and Rin gradually become more aware of these changes in the palace, especially when the King takes Boo Yong as his next wife, which of course infuriates the Queen.
In the meantime, San has her hands full with her own family issues when her identity as the Minister of Finance’s daughter is exposed, including the fact that she managed to avoid being selected as a tribute for eight years. The Queen is not amused by this and keeps trying to cause trouble for both San’s and Rin’s families – in the latter’s case because she doesn’t trust his intentions as her son’s “best friend”. Ultimately, the Queen warms up to San and helps her get her former position back. Unfortunately, the anti-Yuan plot extends to the Queen as well, and it turns out Boo Yong has planted a poisonous object in the Queen’s chambers that’s making her more sick every day. By the time she finally sees what Song In and Boo Yong are doing to the King, Queen Wonseong is already too sick to stop the conspiracy, and she eventually succumbs to her illness. She passes away while the King remains unconscious from all the poisonous chemicals Boo Yong keeps around him. During all these dramatic developments in the palace, Won and Rin get caught up in their own personal rivalry when they both admit to their feelings for San. In their respective attempts to protect her they keep trying to keep her close to themselves and away from the other. While Song In initially intended to put Rin’s older brother Wang Jeon (Yoon Jong Hoon) on the throne as the new Crown Prince, he changes his mind to Rin and starts using San as a tool to get the two friends to fall out. He also uses Wang Dan (Park Hwan Hee), Rin’s younger sister who is in love with Won and eventually gets chosen as the new Crown Princess in an attempt to save her from also being sent to Yuan, to create even more friction between the two. San ultimately realizes her heart lies more with Rin than with Won, and after one final staged attack, the couple manages to flee away together under Won’s supervision.

To be honest, from the first episode onwards I was kind of worried that the story would focus predominantly on the love triangle between Won, Rin and San, and that it would end in a typical fight between two best friends over a girl. The opening sequence and the way their dynamic starts out would suggest that Won and San eventually end up together, leaving Rin as the sad second male lead watching them from a distance. However, I was very glad that they put a twist on that. It was very refreshing that the second male lead ended up with the girl for once. I also thought it was a clever twist that Won’s narration of “the person who I started loving more than myself” ended up referring to the fact that he loved San so much that he was ultimately able to let her go with his best friend, because that would make her the happiest.
I was very glad that the story didn’t turn out as one of those typical dramatic love triangle romances set in historical times. While the love triangle was definitely a big part of the story, it also contributed greatly to the characters’ personal development and relationships, and it never became a distraction to the plot because it was balanced out so well with the other pressing storylines.
In hindsight, I would say that this story can be seen as an ode to friendship in general. Amidst the turmoil of a kingdom full of conspiracies where you can never fully trust anyone, this series managed to take an unexpected twist by highlighting the (hidden) affections of its characters towards the people they cared about. I was repeatedly surprised by some characters’ reactions to a certain death because I initially didn’t think they cared about them that much, and this gave the story an unexpected layer of hope. I just can’t forget how distraught King Chungnyeol was after hearing about Queen Wonseong’s passing and how Song In actually lost his mind after losing Boo Yong. The tears in Jin Gwan and Jang Ui’s eyes when they had to shoot Rin at that cliff, the way Moo Seok shed a final regretful tear for not being able to get back to Bi Yeon, the way Dan hugged San when they reunited after the kidnapping… None of these feelings were spoken out loud, but the emotional response to realizing that something bad happened or would happen to a loved one added so much to each and every character. I thought that was really powerful. The fact that every character, good and bad, had a heart and was able to feel compassion and love for at least one other person made the story even more humane and realistic.

I really loved how the friendship between Won and Rin was portrayed. Not only did the actors have great chemistry, but I also think the writers did a very good job establishing the foundation of their friendship and then building on their bond throughout the story. You could really tell how long they’d been together and how strongly they relied on each other.
I liked how different the two were in personality, how Rin was kind of stoic and reserved while Won definitely had a bit of an edge to him, attributed to his “barbaric” Yuan blood. I guess Won was always a bit distrustful of the people in the palace, he even mentioned that the palace grounds always scared him. He was raised with the knowledge that a King can never have close friends, so even when he started warming up to Rin, he must have always kept the possibility in his mind that he might one day betray him. On the other hand, Rin was taught by his father that he should become a friend to the Crown Prince, but never a real friend, because there wouldn’t be a place for friendship once Won became King. Despite the fun they had when they were together, inside the palace Rin always kept his manners and had his restraints in the way he treated Won. The two of them really balanced each other out in that way: Won was very open about his feelings and would occasionally push Rin to be more direct with him while Rin preferred to keep certain ideas to himself in consideration of Won’s royal position. I really liked how well their characters were written and how much they complimented each other in the most subtle ways. Even when things got heated between them and Won’s paranoia regarding the circumstances of his mother’s death and his bitterness towards the growing romance between Rin and San, it was clear to see that he still couldn’t fully dismiss his best friend. I remember that scene where Won spotted Rin running away from the palace while he was banned from the grounds, and he actually ran after him with that slightly triumphant look on his face. Even though he was angry with Rin at the time, he just couldn’t help being excited to see and talk to his friend again.
When tensions started rising and Rin started acting a bit suspicious in keeping things from Won, it was incredibly comforting to get the confirmation that Rin was more than willing to step back in order to give Won everything and that he never had any grudgeful or jealous feelings towards him. I liked that it wasn’t a “fake” friendship where Rin was actually secretly pining for Won’s position and took the first chance he got to overthrow him. He never wanted any of that. When he fell in love with San and felt himself become greedy, he wrote in his final letter to Won that he deserved punishment for even falling for the same girl as him. Rin literally did everything for Won. Even if he sometimes kept quiet and tried to solve things by himself without informing Won, the truth would always come out that he wasn’t acting against him, but always in his favor. And he didn’t just act like that towards Won, either. When his sister Dan was put on the tribute list, he actually pleaded with the Queen to become a hostage at Yuan in her place so she could be safe. He always took it upon himself to protect those he loved, even if that meant actually sacrificing himself or erasing himself from the narrative.
Admittedly, it would’ve been nice if Rin could’ve kept Won informed of what was going on when the latter was getting a bit paranoid. Rin basically became a spy amongst the anti-Yuan people and he could’ve at least hushed Won in his suspicions towards his own father and himself. Still, I guess that friction between them was necessary because it would lead to the face-off between them. But again, this just confirmed that Rin would’ve rather gotten himself killed than betray Won, which was heart-wrenching. I didn’t believe for a second that Rin would actually harm Won. When he said that his friendship with Won was like a stone pulling on his ankle that he had to get rid of, my first thought was that he’d do something to himself before he’d ever do something to Won. It was clear as day how much it killed him to even draw his sword against Won in their face-off. Honestly, I have no bad words for either Won or Rin, the portrayal of their friendship touched me to the core.

And then there’s San, or So Hwa as she’s occasionally called. I loved that the name So Hwa was a reference to her mother’s dying wish – it means ‘small flower’ and referred to her promise of remaining a tiny flower on a battlefield that would keep blooming no matter what. When Won and Rin meet her at Mount Duta, her spunky and outspoken personality – in combination with her undying love for liquor – immediately makes a big impression on the two guys.
I initially thought she’d cut herself off from her past and family for good, but it seemed like she actually kept in touch and even occasionally visited them. It was really nice to see her reunite with her father, the Minister of Finance Eun Yeong Baek (played by Lee Gi Young) and Bi Yeon (now played by Park Ji Hyun) and that she was still on such good terms with them. The hug she and her father shared when she came back indefinitely was really sweet. They had to keep their interactions under wraps though, because none of the servants that currently worked at their household actually knew about the mix-up between San and Bi Yeon – all the staff that had known San from when she was a child had been sent away so they wouldn’t be able to blow Bi Yeon’s cover. For good reason, when you look at how Song In was able to confirm So Hwa’s true identity by bringing in her old nanny to identify her.
While San keeps being pressured by both Song In and the Queen, there is one figure that keeps popping up to save her. San eventually finds out that this is Rin, and I think that’s when her feelings for him start changing from the ones she has for Won. I honestly felt that, while there were moments in which she was definitely flustered by Won’s advances, the tension between her and Rin was of a different caliber. If he’d just been the second male lead who didn’t stand a chance from the start, they wouldn’t have made the scenes between them so tender and they definitely wouldn’t have played that super romantic background music! The way in which their friendship gradually changed was so subtle that I barely even noticed from which moment onwards I started shipping Rin and San more than Won and San. There was just something really sweet and tender between them, even though it was never put into words. The only kiss between them happens as a kind of provocative action from Rin’s side when he knows Won is watching. I would’ve liked to actually see Rin and San share an intimate moment at a later point when they officially acknowledged their mutual feelings for each other. Then again, I think my ship was already confirmed several times, when she sank into his kiss instead of pushing him away, and when she crumbled after finding out his family had been involved in the attack on her mother.
One thing that I did find a pity regarding San’s character is that her spunky personality from the beginning started fading away throughout the series. I’ve seen this happen in many dramas before, that the female lead starts out with a super quirky personality and then just becomes more and more passive as the series progresses (from the top of my head I believe Radio Romance and Clean With Passion For Now are examples of this). Don’t get me wrong, it’s not that I blamed San for becoming increasingly despondent throughout all the events involving her and her family and the revelations regarding the attack on her mother. Shortly after learning about Rin’s family’s involvement in her mother’s death, her father also suddenly passes away from a heart attack – another heartless action by Boo Yong The Witch (honestly, I was impatient to see her demise). In any case, as San became more paralyzed and powerless against the people who were manipulating her, I could understand why she became less and less cheery. Still, there were some moments where I couldn’t really gauge what she was thinking. Before she started showing clearer signs that she was leaning towards Rin more than Won, I had no idea how she truly felt about either of them, because she never put her feelings into words. When she suddenly appeared as a candidate to become Won’s new Crown Princess, I honestly had no idea what she was doing there. I had no idea what she was thinking showing up there all of a sudden, or if she even hoped that he would pick her even though he’d already promised to save Dan. I was kind of relieved when he still picked Dan, because it would’ve been too cruel if he suddenly bailed on that promise.
Anyways, there were a couple of moments where San had to make an appearance for an important cause, like that matchmaking session or the interrogation of Rin’s family, where she just kept quiet and stared at people and that made it really hard for me to gauge what was going through her head. Those were the moments where I really missed how outspoken she used to be, and that character trait just seemed to elude her completely. I know that part of that spunk was pretense, as she later admits to Rin that she put up an act to appear careless and brave, but she just became a totally different person from how she started out. Again, I understand the developments that her character went through during all the shit that went down, but I kind of wished there’d be some spunk left in her during moments where she had to face up to the royal officials that were trying to ruin her life. Other than that I liked how her character was written, and there were also several moments where her choices really touched me, for example when she decided not to out Wang Jeon for his contribution in her mother’s attack because it would affect Rin’s life as well. The way her tears came out as she made the decision to protect Rin, even if that meant renouncing her revenge on her mother’s attackers, was built up incredibly well. That scene actually gave me goosebumps, also because it again incorporated the feelings that were just starting to grow between her and Rin. The way he calmly nodded and smiled at her to tell her it was okay for her to condemn him was legit heart-wrenching to watch.

San’s only lead to the guy who attacked her eight years ago is that he has a snake tattoo on his forearm, and when she suddenly bumps into this guy in town, the part inside of her that’s still pining for revenge awakens. We gradually come to learn more about the snake tattoo man after San spots him as well. He is eventually identified as Moo Seok (played by Park Young Woon), a young man who was taken under Song In’s wing after his father died in a battle against the Yuan dynasty. I still don’t really understand how he looked exactly the same as he did during the bandit attack eight years earlier, but Moo Seok is definitely the same guy that San saw who slashed Bi Yeon’s face.
Despite him being an assassin for Song In, he doesn’t actually seem to be that bad of a person. This is revealed when he comes across Bi Yeon, and recognizes her as the girl he mangled eight years ago – she still has the scar on her face. I’m guessing he must have felt bad about it, because he keeps showing up for her after that and they even become (suggestedly) romantically involved. At least his feelings for Bi Yeon are confirmed when he refuses to accept Song In’s order to kill her. Honestly, I was really disappointed with how they did Moo Seok in. He should’ve just shot Song In where he stood, why did he have to miss and get stabbed to death like that? Despite my confusion regarding their age gap, I actually thought he and Bi Yeon made a really cute couple, and it was sweet how he started taking care of her as if he wanted to make up for what he did to her face. It’s sad that he had to die. ☹️
Speaking of Bi Yeon’s face, was I the only one who thought they could’ve made her scar a bit more gruesome? Like, the talk was that her face was damaged so badly she could never show it in public again or even get married because of it, but honestly I could only make it out from a certain angle or in a certain light. If they were going to make a big deal about the scar, they could’ve at least made it a bit bigger. I’m just saying, in most scenes where she had the veil off I needed a magnifying glass to spot it.🧐

Returning to the theme of family relations, I’d like to discuss Rin’s relations with his family members a bit more elaborately. His father, the Chancellor, Wang Yeong (played by Kim Ho Jin) is a good man who only sees the good in his children. His wife must have passed away because it’s only him, Jeon, Rin and Dan. Jeon and Rin are consistently referred to as the Chancellor’s Second and Third sons, respectively, and although there are mentions of the First son, he doesn’t appear in the story.
With his older brother out of the picture, Wang Jeon probably thought being the new oldest Chancellor’s son made him better than anyone else. I can only imagine him jumping with joy when Song In approached him with the plan to make him the new Crown Prince as he was the next available heir from Princess Jeonghwa’s lineage. Despite this newfound ambition, Jeon keeps wasting his time on partying and women. It’s actually kind of funny that the Royal family was in fact well aware of the plan to put Wang Jeon on the throne – they just never took it seriously. I can’t blame them, I mean, look at the guy. He was a despicable man that only ended up as a laughing stock. He was actively involved in the bandit attack on San’s mother, yet during the interrogation he kept yelling at his father and Rin that they needed to do something. Like, brother didn’t even seem to realize that he himself was to blame for getting his entire family arrested. I also really hated how he kept claiming he’d been waiting for San to come of age so he could marry her – yikes forever. The fact that he and San would’ve actually gotten married if Won hadn’t stepped in, even when he didn’t know it was San at the time. By the way, I found it kind of curious that Won didn’t recognize San with her face veil on. He’d seen her wear it before at the Queen’s masqued party and then he was able to recognize her immediately… or was that because Rin was with her? I don’t know, from the way Won was always observing her, I just expected him to at least recognize her eyes when he looked into them, but I guess not. Anyways, I’m really glad Wang Jeon gradually disappeared from the picture as even Song In and his gang were like, “you know what, we can find someone better”, lol. During the final times he appeared on screen he just became such a tragic, almost comical character who was pissed off that he didn’t get his piece of the pie. I loved the part where people started obeying Rin more than him and he started yelling at him and Rin was like, “can someone please remove this man, he is being too loud”. 😂
In contrast to Wang Jeon, I was actually really taken with Dan. Honestly, I felt so bad for her throughout the series. She was just a pure and innocent girl who was so in love with Won that she didn’t even mind that he didn’t love her back or that he only married her in order to save her from being sent to Yuan. I hated how everyone tried to bring her into everything, how the Queen suddenly threatened to send her to Yuan and how she then got kidnapped by Song In in the end to play poison roulette with San – the poor girl didn’t even know a thing about what was happening in the palace and must have constantly been worried out of her mind. I really loved the dynamic between Rin and Dan, and how he would always come to see and talk to her whenever she was sick or confined to the house. Rin was such a sweet brother to her, and he really went to great lengths to secure her safety.
I also liked the friendship that bloomed between Dan and San. Despite the fact that Dan was very aware that Won fancied San and she also expressed that she didn’t like seeing San in Won’s quarters, she still couldn’t bring herself to hate her. When Song In ultimately kidnaps the two girls and forces one of them to drink poisoned tea, she’s utterly shocked when San switches their cups and drinks the poison herself. It was really heartwarming to see how close they became after San returned and recovered from the poison, and how relieved Dan was to see her back alive.
Although I initially thought it was very chivalrous of Won to offer to marry Dan in order to save her from being sent away as a tribute, I couldn’t help but think that he could’ve been a bit more respectful towards her. He literally walked away the second the wedding ceremony ended, like, at least see it through for her. He must’ve known that not showing up to greet the King and Queen at her side would also impact her badly as the new Crown Princess. I thought he was nice enough to her at first, but there were definitely some moments where I was like, okay, I know you don’t have feelings for her, but at least just do this for her, she’s been through enough already.

In terms of family relations, let me finally discuss Won’s relationship with his parents for a bit. As the only remaining child in the palace – unlike the actual historical facts Won didn’t have any siblings in this story – it seemed like Won’s relationship with his dad was kind of tense from the start. It was clear that he respected his father and that he would never plan anything to overthrow him as the rumors suggested. The King, however, seemed to be slightly paranoid that this might one day happen. As soon as the first plan was set in motion to make him doubt his son’s intentions, he didn’t hesitate for a second to accuse Won of attacking him, falling right into Song In’s trap. He must’ve been a fairly easy target for the anti-Yuan movement, since they could play on the existing suspicions he had towards his son. Like all the relationship developments in this series, I really liked how the bond between Won and his father played out, and how in the final episode they finally managed to see eye to eye. Losing Queen Wonseong heavily impacted them both, and it seemed like talking about her finally softened things between them a little bit.
Despite Queen Wonseong’s demanding personality, I did like that she at least had genuine love for her son. They didn’t have that many scenes together at first, but once she got involved in his affairs with San, it became crystal clear how much she really cared about him. It was nice that she taught him how to play chess and just enjoyed spending time with him. Won’s reaction to her passing was also heartbreaking – honestly, I can’t wait to rant about Im Si Wan’s performance in my cast comments later, his emotional acting was phenomenal. I’m glad we got to see a sincere motherly side from her towards Won. I actually found myself warming up to her throughout the series, something I hadn’t expected to happen initially.

At first glance, the Queen seemed like a pretty nasty person. Her words were sharp, she wasn’t friendly to anyone, and she just seemed to be full of bitterness. Then again, I really liked her wickedness when Boo Yong first caught her attention. The way she literally stuck her nail into Boo Yong’s chin to push her face upwards to look at her was CHILLING but SO COOL. I think that may have been when my perspective of her started to change, because it was a very good instinct of her to immediately dislike Boo Yong, even though it started as mere jealousy. After she eventually warmed up to San, I started liking her more and more and then it became more and more dreading to see her slowly get more and more sick. The way she eventually died, after witnessing what Song In and Boo Yong were doing and watching her most loyal guard be slaughtered right in front of her was so tragic. I felt so bad for her that she died there and then, knowing that her husband wasn’t even aware of what was happening to them both. I honestly think she would be very comforted to see how the King responded to her death, especially after he first completely dismissed what had happened to Boo Yong. He must have really loved the Queen, and it would’ve been so nice if they could’ve shared those sentiments one more time before they had to part ways.
The loyal guard that was slain by Song In was called Murathai (played by Lee Jae Woon). I’d wondered before why he looked different, with the shaven hairstyle etcetera, but it wasn’t until I heard his name that I realized he must’ve come with her from Yuan. Actually, in the flashback of the young Wonseong, you can see someone behind her who could very well be a younger version of him, seen from his hair and the way he’s dressed. I only realized this when I heard the name “Murathai” and realized that he must’ve been with her ever since she came there from Yuan. That only made his demise even sadder, to be honest. The way Song In stabbed him too, from the back where Murathai couldn’t see him coming. It was awful and so cowardly as well.
Among all the suspicious people around her, at least Murathai had been always on her side. The same went for Court Lady Cho (played by Min Young Won). It was so sad that she was dragged away for interrogation and wasn’t even able to tend to the Queen in her final moments. These two were the only people around the Queen that were loyal to her until the very end and never gave in to the anti-Yuan movement to spy on her. The only one to betray her was eunuch Choi (played by Kim Byung Chun), who was secretly helping out Song In. It was very satisfying when the Queen started suspecting him and eventually made him spill the truth by threatening his family. Sorry family, but the guy was a snake. I kept calling him “the snaky eunuch” whenever he made an appearance. 🐍

Before I move on to the villain section of my character analysis, I just want to say something about Won’s loyal trustees, Jin Gwan (Seo Jae Woo) and Jang Ui (Ki Do Hoon). I loved these two so much. They were always there for Won and Rin, to the point where they also felt more like friends than guards at some moments. They were both a bit younger, and usually appeared together. At some point they kind of split up and Jin Gwan stayed mostly at Rin’s house while Jang Ui stuck with Won. I loved how they always just happened to be exactly where they needed to be to catch some vital piece of information or spot something. I also thought it was super cute that Jin Gwan was crushing on Dan and chose to stay with her at all times. Honestly, if it weren’t for his status I would have urged Dan to get with him because he was obviously smitten with her and she deserved some genuine affection. I can’t deny that I was scared that either of them might get killed at some point. Whenever they ran out by themselves in pursuit of some bandits or suspicious people I was like PLEASE STAY ALIVE PLEASE, but luckily nothing happened to them.
I think the scene that proved best how much they truly cared about both Won and Rin was in the final episode, when they had Won’s order to corner Rin and kill him for taking the King’s gold seal. This turned out to be a staged death, because it was just meant to create a getaway for Rin and San, but I guess Jin Gwan and Jang Ui weren’t aware of that. The PAIN on their faces as they aimed their arrows at Rin physically hurt me. It killed them to attack Rin like that and if that wasn’t enough proof that they honestly cared about him, I don’t know what was. I just loved how humane they were, and that despite being Won’s loyal guards, there were also moments when they actually hesitated when he gave them an order. They obeyed, of course, but you could clearly see that they had a proper conscience.

Going on a little segue here, but this was actually something that I really liked about this series. Every single character was relevant. From the guards and the servants to the dumpling lady (I can’t find her in the cast list but she was awesome!) and Gae Won and Yeom Bok. I loved that these two clowns were written as more than just comic relief characters; they were actually super smart and observant and provided a lot of useful information. It’s been a while since I’ve applauded a series for creating so many characters and storylines without wasting even one of them. This series had such good writing and character-building, I just can’t seem to shut up about it. 😌

Well then, it’s time for the anti-Yuan movement. One thing I’ll say in advance is that I also liked how this series played with perspective. After hearing Song In’s story, I could honestly see a valid reason for wanting to get rid of the Yuan influence, especially considering how the annual tribute deal was literally tearing families apart. I honestly didn’t even think their goal was all that bad. It’s just that the way they went about it, killing a bunch of innocent people just to drive a wedge between the King and his wife and son, was so, so wrong.
Besides being related to the Royal Assistant Secretary, I honestly still don’t know much about Song In. I’ll talk a bit more about this later, but I still don’t actually know for sure what the relation was between him and the RAS, or how he managed to wriggle his way into the palace when both the Queen and Won found him suspicious from the start. At first I thought he was working for Wang Jeon, but it turns out that he was pulling all the strings. Song In had something genuinely threatening about him, all the more because he always remained so calm. I kept calling him Mr. Smugface because he always had that little smile on his lips. It really seemed like nothing would be able to shake his confidence, so I was very surprised when it turned out that he did have a weak spot – Boo Yong. I mentioned before that some characters’ reactions to a certain death surprised me, and this was also the case for Song In. In his earlier scenes with Boo Yong, he kind of seemed to be playing with her when she got jealous of him expressing interest in San. I felt like he was the kind of guy who’d keep a woman hooked but would never tell her he loved her. Imagine my surprise when I saw his response to Boo Yong’s death – he witnessed it first-hand through a small window in a screen. Even though he’d always been just about the plan, after she died the only thing that seemed to matter to him was that he avenged her – heck, he even started hallucinating that she was there and kept talking to her. I honestly had no idea he actually loved Boo Yong that much from how he treated her when she was alive, I lowkey thought he was just playing her, seeing as that he actually encouraged her to get intimate with the King and all that. That really surprised me, and I’m honestly not sure how I feel about the way he just abandoned the anti-Yuan plan and just set his mind to taking away Won’s most loved person from him as well.
I guess this relates to what I mentioned earlier, that every character at least seemed to have a heart, because even after all he did, I still couldn’t help but be happy for him that he at least got to be reunited with Boo Yong when he died. I actually thought it was sweet how she appeared before him as he was dying, as if she was coming to get him. The fact that I was actually able to feel that kind of sentiment for these two characters was wild even to me, but I guess it really comes down to how well their characters were written. They were a match made in Hell, so at least they got to see each other there. Aww.

I realize I haven’t talked much about the Royal Assistant Secretary himself that much yet. Song Bang Yeong is the only spy from the anti-Yuan movement who actually manages to avoid persecution and is even able to keep his position, which kind of pissed me off. I honestly didn’t really understand what his part was in all of it, because he definitely helped in poisoning the King against his son, but then he still seemed to care for the King to remain in power. I guess some of his motives were revealed in his conversation with Master Lee towards the end, when he asked him which side he should choose to remain unscathed in the aftermath. I guess he really just cared about that. I’m also still not sure how he felt about Song In and Boo Yong. He always acted like some kind of court jester with his exaggerated way of speaking and comical facial expressions, but even when they announced that Song In had died, his face just went 😯 – he didn’t even seem genuinely shocked by it. In hindsight I would’ve liked to see a bit more of him without his mask. We do get a couple of smug grins from him here and there but I was actually curious to learn more about his concrete motivations to go against the Queen and Crown Prince. I mean, after everything was said and done, he still remained in his RAS position to serve the Crown Prince, so he can’t have hated him that much.

If there’s one consistent question mark that I have regarding all the members of the anti-Yuan movement, it’s that it wasn’t clear to me where any of them came from. If Song In’s background was already vague to me, Boo Yong’s was simply unknown. I wish they would have revealed a bit more about how Song In and Boo Yong met at least, or how they both got so wrapped up in this plan together that she started brewing potions and poisons. Despite the fact that she was an absolute witch, and I didn’t mind it too much when she got bodied, I still found her quite an interesting character. I would’ve liked a bit more insight into her relationship with Song In and what she was thinking about everything they were doing. She was a very engaging villain character, and she definitely played her role well because she legit set my teeth on edge whenever she came on-screen, lol. I guess they were just really lucky that the King was such an easy target and she could just slither her way into his arms without ever raising suspicion. Which made it even more thrilling when the King would occasionally become lucid, because then it seemed as if he was actually suspicious of her. I got goosebumps when he suddenly asked her if the rumor about Won wanting to attack him wasn’t just something she’d whispered into his ear. Those moments contributed greatly to what made this series so exciting for me. You kept hoping that the right people would realize what was happening, but every single time they seemed to get close, the villains did something to shut them up again. It was a very thrilling cat and mouse game, all the way through.

Lastly, I just need to devote one paragraph to Master Lee, because he was undoubtedly one of my favorite characters. I don’t know what it is with Master Lees, because the sage from Alchemy of Souls was called the same and he was also one of my favorite characters. I guess Master Lees are just collectively awesome. It was established that Master Lee used to be a court official, but that he was banned for being insolent towards the King or something. This seemed to be confirmed when he and the King talked at the end and the King told him that he was the only one who wasn’t scared to throw the dirty truth at him, and it even felt like he respected him for that. In any case, Master Lee is eventually summoned to the palace and it’s thanks to him that Won manages to stay ahead of the anti-Yuan people for a while. I loved that whenever someone expressed surprise about how Master Lee was so well aware of everything going on in the palace, he’d just point at his ear and go, “I have very good ears 😀”, lol. The way he saw through everyone’s BS was so satisfying. He had so many funny one-liners, I hate that I can’t remember them now, but he was the only character that consistently made me laugh out loud. It was just so great to have at least one reliable wise person around who saw through all the shady business and actually managed to help the good side in restoring justice. I really loved Master Lee’s character, he was the best.

I think that’s it for my character analysis, and again it took me more than one day to finish it. I don’t know what it is these days that I can’t seem to finish a review in a single day anymore. Anyways, if it takes a bit longer to produce a better and more elaborate review, so be it.

In terms of criticisms, there are a few things that I may have already mentioned throughout my analysis which I’d like to elaborate on. For starters, as much as I came to enjoy the series in general, I have to admit that it took me some time to get into it at first. Besides the fact that it started off with a salvo of many different names, places and titles, I also had some trouble determining from the start who everyone was, who they were related to and how.
Let me give some examples. Firstly, after just being introduced to “Master Lee” by that name, back in the palace they started referring to him by his full name “Lee Seung Hyu”, which I didn’t know yet at the time. I didn’t immediately make the connection with him, which already caused a confusion.
It also took me a while to figure out who the current Queen actually was. This confusion was caused by the fact that, whenever someone started talking about the King’s first wife Princess Jeonghwa, they showed the flashback of young Queen Wonseong. I distinctly remember that the opening shot of young Queen Wonseong entering the palace for the first time was accompanied by the on-screen text “Princess Jeonghwa, demoted from Crown Princess to Princess”. This text didn’t appear when the first wife was depicted, she didn’t even get a proper introduction, only that “the King already had a wife and a son”. As Princess Jeonghwa was established to be Rin’s aunt, the Chancellor’s sister, I didn’t think the current Queen was her because of the way she treated Rin. Also, it was said that Princess Jeonghwa disappeared somewhere and was never seen again, so it wouldn’t make sense if the current Queen was her. It would’ve been clearer if they’d just introduced the current Queen by her name from the start and shown the text about Princess Jeonghwa in a shot featuring the King’s first wife. If they’d just introduced the current Queen with an on-screen text saying “Queen Wonseong” at her first appearance, that would’ve solved it, but the flashback confused me every time. In the end, I only got the official confirmation when the Queen died, because then everyone suddenly started calling her by her name, Wonseong. This happened with several people, as I mentioned this was the case with Murathai as well. I didn’t catch his name even once before they mentioned it after he died, and that stopped me from making the earlier connection that he’d been the Queen’s only present guard from Yuan and that I shouldn’t have doubted his loyalty to her because he was a part of her home.
Another thing that remained ambiguous to me was how exactly Song In and Song Bang Yeong were related. It may have been just bad subtitling, but in the version I watched their relation changed at least three times. I believe he was referred to as the Royal Assistant Secretary’s cousin, son and brother throughout the series. Looking at the age difference between them, I can only assume they must’ve been either brothers or cousins, but even if that was the case they couldn’t have been that close. I mean, if they had been, I would’ve at least expected Song Bang Yeong to respond a little bit more emotionally to the news of Song In’s death. There’s a chance that I missed this detail, but I just thought it was a bit wishy-washy that they couldn’t even clarify how the main villain was actually connected to the royal family. There must have been a reason that he was able to get such close access to the King, right?
Finally, because of the lack of clarification on several elements from the start, the real reason behind the anti-Yuan conspiracy also took a very long time to land. I ended up filling in the reason behind the tribute deal mostly by myself as that it must have been a agreement between Goryeo and Yuan through the merging of their dynasties, but even this was never actually explained in the story. While it’s not a bad thing to have to figure things out by myself in a story, it would have definitely helped me to have certain things clarified a bit more by the narrative.

Before I go onto my cast comments, I’d just like to point out something about the series’ title. I noticed that there are two English titles for this series, The King Loves and The King in Love. I personally think that the first one is more grammatically accurate to the Korean title, and to be honest I also prefer that one because it resonates much more with the overarching theme of Won coming to terms with his love for his two best friends. It’s interesting that it says “The King” though, because Won only ascends the throne in the very final episode when all of this has already happened. The Korean word used in the title is “Wang”, which means “King” but can also refer to the royal family name that both Won and Rin share. In any case, it felt more natural to me to use the title The King Loves in this review because I feel like that connects better to Won’s emotional development.

By the way, I know I’ve mentioned the opening sequence before and how it kind of tricks us into believing that Won and San are endgame, but what was that actually about? I’m actually kind of curious why they decided to go with this misleading opening sequence of Won kissing San while Rin sadly watches on. What was the thought behind it? I’m just saying, I could actually appreciate it if it was purely meant to troll the viewer into getting the wrong expectations, but looking at the tone of the series I doubt they’d pull a prank like that. Seriously, if anyone has a theory I’d love to hear it, because I’m genuinely curious.

We have reached the segment we (mostly me) have all been waiting for! It’s cast comment time! I know this review is already quite lengthy but I couldn’t skip the cast comments because I found a lot of surprising new sides to actors I already thought I knew, and I just want to give everyone a shoutout for performing so well.

Until now, I’ve only seen Im Si Wan in introverted, gentle and mild character roles – I’m thinking mainly about his roles in Run On and Summer Strike. As such, it was delightful to see him in the role of Won. I thoroughly enjoyed his performance. It was clear that he understood the role so well, and he really went beyond the script and added so much to Won’s character that I couldn’t help but love him. His facial expressions and the way he portrayed Won’s darker and edgier sides really surprised me, as did his emotional acting in for example the scene where the Queen passed away. He was incredible, I’m so glad I got to see this side of him. This series has proven to me what a great actor he truly is. Bravo!

I’m not gonna lie, this series actually reignited my love for Hong Jong Hyun. It just confirmed what I’ve been saying for so long while I defended him for always getting cast as angsty, creepy or ill-mannered guys (looking mainly at Wild Romance, White Christmas, Moon Lovers: Scarlet Heart Ryeo, My Absolute Boyfriend). I always knew there was a soft and gentle side in him, and I’m so freaking happy that it came out in this series. It was such a comfort seeing him portray such a genuinely kind and caring character for a change. I was genuinely psyched that he got the girl, because my heart was already breaking at his sad puppy face watching Won and San together from afar in the opening sequence. I’m crushing on him all over again, I can’t help it. I’m even more happy I saw this drama now. 😭🙏🏻

I’ll keep repeating it, but I loved the chemistry between the two male leads so much. Their friendship seemed so natural and they expressed their unspoken dedication to each other so effortlessly. Seriously, friendship goals. They were amazing together.

I never actually saw Im Yoon Ah act in anything before, although that’s definitely going to change since King the Land is also still on my list. I’m curious to see her portray a different variety of roles now. I really liked the energy that she put into her performance of San. I know I commented on how I thought she kind of lost her spunk throughout the show, but I did like seeing how she switched between different layers of her character – in a way it was actually admirable how she was able to become a completely different person once she transformed back into Eun San. Maybe it’s better to view So Hwa and San as two different people: So Hwa the carefree and fearless and San the fragile and delicate. Maybe Won fell in love with So Hwa and Rin fell in love with San, and she chose Rin because he loved her for the real her. I don’t know, I’m probably thinking about it too much. In any case, I really liked the chemistry between her and the two male leads as well, the scenes where the three of them frolicked around were really sweet. I also really loved the sequence where she was walking while balancing on a fence and the shot shifted from Rin behind her to Won who caught her as she almost fell while following the course of a flower petal. I think that shot on its own depicted their dynamic very well, or at least how they started out with Won being more straightforward in showing his interest while Rin was still holding back.
Anyways, I liked Yoon Ah’s performance and I’m really excited to see more of her!

I can’t go on to the next characters before mentioning the once again incredible performances by the younger versions of the main leads. Nam Da Reum, Yoon Chan Young and Lee Seo Yeon are all bright stars of the future. I’d never seen Lee Seo Yeon before but I thought she did an incredible job as young San in the flashback of the bandit attack and the scene where Won passed her mother’s dying wish onto her. I’ve seen both Nam Da Reum and Yoon Chan Young in several younger version roles before, and they are such consistently talented young actors. Honestly, the talent of Korean child and teen actors never ceases to amaze me.

I’ve seen Park Hwan Hee in a couple of shows like Who Are You: School 2015, Descendants of the Sun, Jealousy Incarnate and Are You Human Too?. I barely remember her appearances apart from the last one since I wrote a review on that. I remember her playing such a brat in that series, lol. It was nice to see her as the sweet and delicate Dan, the role fitted her very well. I love how she retained strength in her pureness – I never once felt like she became weak or pathetic. Since Dan was such a naive and powerless girl who was as much shoved around by the higher ups as the main leads were, it would be an easy choice to make her like a passive puppet, but I’m glad they managed to write her as such a significant character. It was really nice to see her in a role that I hadn’t seen of her yet. I’ll definitely remember her portrayal of Dan, she was such a cinnamon roll.

I honestly think this is the first time I’ve seen Jang Young Nam portray an innately good person! 😂 She’s somehow always cast as evil people (like in It’s Okay to Not Be Okay and Crash Course in Romance). In the beginning I feared that she might have been cast as another nasty lady, a Queen even this time, but it was a really nice surprise to see her thaw towards San. I started feeling for her more and more as the anti-Yuan people’s plan started bearing fruits, and the way she ultimately met her end was genuinely sad. I really liked seeing a new side to her acting, and I thought her chemistry with her on-screen son Im Si Wan was really touching. The Queen was such a great character, honestly. I’m still sad about what happened to her and how she was incapacitated to do anything about it. Truly a great performance from Jang Young Nam, her performance really managed to make me feel for her and touch me throughout the series.

I didn’t exactly recognize Oh Min Seok as I was watching the show, but apparently he was the jerk cousin in Kill Me, Heal Me. I’ve yet to see more sympathetic performances of him, but I guess he’s a good casting choice for a smug villain. I have to admit he played the role of Song In very well. The ones that remain calm and smiling under all the circumstances are the ones to be truly feared. In a way it’s a shame he lost his cool after Boo Yong died, because he was a very intimidating villain. I think it made him even more scary because he was actually fighting for a valid cause, but he just went overboard in his methods to achieve that goal. In hindsight, you can’t deny that there must have been something good in him. He was actively trying to stop the tribute deal, which was indeed horrible. I just wished there would’ve been a bit more background information on him, where he came from and how he grew up, that would explain why he became as twisted as he did. But yeah, I think he did a great job. I thought it was very clever to gradually make him a bigger and bigger threat throughout the series, it really helped build up the tension.

I thought I recognized Choo Soo Hyun from somewhere, but I see she’s only done five dramas up until 2018 and the only one of them I’ve seen is Pinocchio, and I don’t think I remember her from there. In any case, speaking of another good villain role: I think we can all agree that Boo Yong – I purposely didn’t refer to her as Queen Moo Bi in my review since she doesn’t deserve that title – was a nasty piece of work. Yet again, just like with Song In, there was a part inside of her that was loving and good and genuinely cared about her lover. I really would’ve liked to get a bit more background information on her as well, especially about how she and Song In met and started their rebellion against the Crown Prince together. The fact that I hated her character with a passion is only thanks to her acting, it just means she did a great job. The expression on her face when she lulled the King back to sleep as he was about to wake up when the Queen busted them was ENRAGING but SO COOL. I have to admit that the energy and ferve with which she played her character was very satisfying to watch.

The way my mouth fell open when I realized Choi Jong Hwan also played that stoic guy from Birth of a Beauty! What a world of difference! Song Bang Yeong was probably the most animated character out of everyone. His acting made me think of a jester in a traditional stage play, with his exaggerated expressions and way of speaking. I couldn’t find it irritating even if I wanted to, because he still made it work and he was genuinely immersed in his role. This goes for all the more comical characters in this series, by the way, the way they acted proved my point that if an actor takes his character seriously, he doesn’t have to try to be funny to be amusing. The same went for Song Bang Yeong, because his comical acting amongst the gradually increasing turmoil in the palace actually did bring a deeper layer to his character as well. I liked that he stood out against the others in that way, he kept you thinking that there was more to him but even in conversations where he didn’t need to pretend he kept up the act, and that was a very interesting choice. He was an interesting character for sure, and the actor definitely surprised me.

Apparently they only take ballet classes together, but I keep thinking that Park Ji Hyun and Park Gyu Young are sisters because they look SO much alike! Seriously, I feel like every time I see Park Ji Hyun I first mistake her for Park Gyu Young and then look up if they’re related every single time, lol.
It actually took me a moment to realize that Bi Yeon’s actress was the second female lead in Rookie Historian Goo Hae Ryung. This was actually only her second drama, and I see that she’s done a couple more historical ones – she does look natural in the genre. It was cool seeing her in a different role, and I’m looking forward to seeing more of her acting. She did a really good job as Bi Yeon, I really loved her and San’s friendship even though she was “just” her maid. Even after what happened to her, she kept caring so much about her lady and knowingly went along with the mix-up in order to protect her. Her emotional acting game was really strong in this one, even more so when you look at the stoic personality of her character in Rookie.

When Moo Seok made his first appearance in the story, he reminded me of Yang Cha from Arthdal Chronicles. I felt like he resembled him a lot, with the black attire and the mask and the stoicness. I guess that’s why he immediately felt familiar to me, even though I haven’t seen him in anything else so far. I can’t deny that I was bummed out that he and Bi Yeon couldn’t end up living happily ever after together. I had the feeling it was going to happen as soon as he hesitated at Song In’s order, but it was still sad that he actually had to die. Sadness forever. But I liked the duality in his performance as well – I happen to have a weak spot for dangerous men who turn out to be very gentle and caring on the inside. I see on MDL that this was actually his first drama and he’s still going, so I hope to encounter him in a different role in the future – I’m really curious to see him in a modern-day role now.

Imagine my surprise when, right after thinking that Moo Seok reminded me of Yang Cha, I found out that Yang Cha’s actor was actually in this series himself. What a crazy coincidence! I thought Ki Do Hoon looked vaguely familiar but he mostly just reminded me of Sung Joon, haha. Too many associations here, I’ll keep it simple. I guess I didn’t make the connection right away because he’s a lot younger in this series; it was actually his second drama as well. It’s probably just that he looks more grown-up in Arthdal Chronicles and Love Alarm and that’s why I didn’t recognize him right away. 😌 Anyways, he received a new medal of honor on my list because I really liked his portrayal of Jang Ui. The same went for Seo Jae Woo, who played Jin Gwan. Even as royal guards who were just following orders, there was so much more to their characters. I keep mentioning the scene where they both cried when they had to shoot Rin off that cliff, but I can’t help it. It just hit differently to see these young men, who were always so steadfast, shed tears for their friend like that. They really managed to touch me with their performances.

I’ve seen Eom Hyo Seob in many a series before this (like School 2013, My Love From Another Star, Doctors, Shopping King Louie, While You Were Sleeping, I’m Not a Robot, He is Psychometric, Extraordinary You and Start-Up) and he always delivers, whether he plays a jerk or a good guy. This is definitely my favorite role of him so far. He had just the right balance between wise and goofy and I lived for it. I can still hear his quirky “Aha 😀” and I’m thinking of adapting that phrase whenever I hear someone talk BS, lol. Honestly, this will be one of his more memorable performances for me, I really, really enjoyed what he brought to this series.

As always, I never skip a mention of Ahn Se Ha whenever he appears in a series. Honestly, this man is the manifestation of being funny without trying to be. I absolutely loved him as Gae Won. His comical timing is just effortlessly perfect. I love how he always gets so immersed in his characters, even when it’s just a guest appearance or a cameo. In this case again, as I already mentioned in my analysis, he managed to make Gae Won so much more than just a funny-looking thief. While there was definitely a Mr. Smart and Mr. Dumb dynamic between him and Yeom Bok, they never took it too far and their involvement and contributions to the story were always relevant to the plot. I loved how Won actually ended up recruiting them for his team because he acknowledged how useful they were.
In any case, another great performance from Ahn Se Ha, this man never disappoints.

To sum up this lengthy review: I liked this series a lot. Admittedly, it took me a couple of episodes to get into it, and whenever I took some time in-between episodes I always needed some time to get back into the story as well, but then it still always managed to grab me. This definitely isn’t the type of show that you can just put on in the background while you’re doing something else; I did this a couple of times and I just know I missed some details here and there because of it. As I mentioned, there were some minor confusions and a lack of clarity here and there that I had to fill in by myself, but I can’t say that ruined my watching experience. There were a lot of moments that genuinely touched me, and I stand by my point that I think it was very well-written. The characters and the story were fleshed out really well, the acting was great, the cinematography was stunning, the music was good… I really liked it. It’s been a while since I felt myself feeling so much for almost every single character and managed to see something redeemable in everyone – I think the last time might have actually been Alchemy of Souls. I love it when historical dramas manage to literally sweep me away to that world and time, and I also thought it was really cool that this story was actually based on historical facts and people that really existed. Lastly, I really loved the twist that San and Rin ended up together, and it just made me so happy to see new acting styles of all these familiar actors. It was a really exciting series and I’m glad I finally got to watch it.

And with that, I have finally reached the end of this lengthy review! There’s one more month until the end of the year and I’m really curious what drama my Wheel of Fortune will pick out next.

Until then, bye-bee! x

Oh! Master

Standard

Disclaimer: this is a review, and as such it contains spoilers of the whole series. Please proceed to read at your own risk if you still plan on watching this show or if you haven’t finished it yet. You have been warned.

Oh! Master
(오! 주인님 / Oh! Jooinnim)
MyDramaList rating: 6.5/10

Hello hello! Welcome to another review! I’m glad I was able to finish this a lot sooner than the previous one. It was nice to watch another good ol’ romantic comedy whilst my translation work is nearing its final phase. I honestly didn’t remember putting this one on my list, but it probably had to do with the fact that Lee Min Gi played the male lead, since he’s one of my favorite Korean actors. I saw from the get-go that it didn’t have a lot of positive reviews on MDL, but I still wanted to see for myself. In hindsight, my fourteenth watch of this year had a lot of enjoyable parts as well as parts that I absolutely hated. I’m excited to share my thoughts, so let’s get to it!

Oh! Master is an iQiyi/MBC K-Drama with 16 episodes of about 1 hour and 20 minutes. It tells the love story of renowned script writer Han Bi Soo (played by Lee Min Gi) and famous actress Oh Joo In (played by Nana/Im Jin Ah).
Han Bi Soo is introduced as a cold and selfish guy who doesn’t care about other people as long as he is free to do what he wants. Although he is a successful script writer that keeps producing one hit crime drama after another, he causes his agency and the people around him a lot of anxiety because of his personality. Although he has plenty of people around him that actually care about him and not just the work he delivers, he doesn’t let anyone in emotionally and tends to get very crabby even in a professional environment. The only person he ever treats warmly is his mother, Kang Hae Jin (played by Lee Hwi Hyang); she can do nothing wrong. He even treats his own father coldly, although it is soon established that this has to do with something Bi Soo found out about his father when he was still in high school. He apparently saw his dad do something bad and got estranged from him ever since. Besides that, he’s also become very fussy about keeping his house clean and he absolutely can’t stand it when doors or drawers are ajar. He claims it’s because he gets distracted by “what could be behind it”.
At work, Bi Soo’s team consists of Director Yoo Dae Young (played by Kim Kwang Shik) and assistant writer Jung Jae Hwan (played by Song Yoo Taek).
Apart from work, Bi Soo can often be found at a vintage record shop called Just Record, where he occasionally helps out the owner Kim Chang Gyu (played by Kim Chang Wan) by looking after the shop.
On the other hand we have Oh Joo In, a very popular actress who’s mostly famous for her appearances in romantic comedies and being the spokesmodel for KT Cosmetics. Despite the fact that her agency wants her to maintain her current image, Joo In is drawn to Bi Soo’s newest drama script about a female killer. Even after she’s already been rejected by him three times and gets rejected again when she personally comes to ask him for this particular role, Joo In remains adamant on joining his drama.
Behind her glamorous celebrity life, Joo In is quite an easygoing person who likes to relax and have a beer when she gets home. In contrast to Bi Soo, she is very close with her team, consisting of director Kim Yi Na (played by Woo Hee Jin) and her road manager Bae Gwang Ja (played by Lee Hyun Jung).
Joo In’s best friend is Jung Yoo Jin (played by Kang Min Hyuk), who is actually a shareholder of KT Cosmetics – it’s his older sister’s company. Yoo Jin went to study in Paris to become a visual designer after graduating high school. While he has always secretly been in love with Joo In, she’s only ever considered him as a friend. In order to make his move on Joo In as more than friends, Yoo Jin comes back to Korea halfway through the story and becomes the second male lead.
The only thing Joo In seems to have in common with Bi Soo is that she has a really close relationship with her mother, Yoon Jung Hwa (played by Kim Ho Jung). After losing her father when she was still a teen, it’s been her and her mom against the world. After her mother got admitted to a nursing home because of advancing Alzheimer’s, Joo In has been trying to buy back their old family home so she can live there with her mother again.
Fate has it, Joo In’s old family home is the same house that Bi Soo is currently living in. She eventually manages to buy it back from Bi Soo’s mother, the current owner, who in turn wants Bi Soo to come back home. Even after Bi Soo is faced with the truth that the house no longer belongs to him, he’s such a creature of habit that he finds himself unable to work on his scripts in any other room than his study at the house. As such, the two opposites eventually strike up a deal: Joo In will become his new drama’s female lead, and in return Bi Soo can keep using his study room at the house for the scriptwriting 24/7.
While the story progresses as a typical “enemies to lovers that end up sharing a house” romantic comedy in which two polar opposites gradually grow fond of each other, there is a second major plotline where Bi Soo is brought back to life by a mysterious angel figure (played by Kang Seung Ho) after getting into a serious car accident. This figure tells Bi Soo that he gave him a life extension, but that he will still die/disappear within a short period of time.

I have to admit the “life extension” plotline immediately threw me off a little. I wasn’t expecting a supernatural element in the story, so that immediately had me shifting my expectations. Also, even though they introduced this bizarre event quite early on, within the first episode even, it took them quite a while to get back to it. I even occasionally forgot about it until suddenly the angel figure appeared again to remind Bi Soo that he didn’t have much time left. In hindsight I still don’t really understand the meaning or relevance of adding this plotline to the story when it could’ve been just an enjoyable romcom without it. Maybe I’m just biased because this plotline contributed largely to my most hated part of the story.

I’d first like to analyze the lead characters a bit and talk about the build-up in their relationship, including the love triangle with Yoo Jin.
As I mentioned before, Han Bi Soo is introduced to us as a rude and selfish guy. From his very first appearance, we see how he openly disrespects and dismisses people in order to get what he wants. He only ever trusts himself and isn’t even open to the suggestion of leaning on others for help or advice. He creates a lot of fuss for his employers as well since he keeps rejecting potential actors for his dramas. I think it was very characteristic of him to not even care about the actors as people at all – they just existed to fill in his roles. This was also reflected in how he didn’t even remember Joo In’s name after he rejected her for a role three times before. He didn’t even care to remember people he didn’t find worthy, not even when they were successful and well-known from other shows. He only ever cared about his own work.
On the other hand, Joo In is a genuinely open and warm person. Despite the fact that she got rejected by Bi Soo several times before, she follows her instinct as an actor and keeps respecting him despite his personality. I really liked her entrance at their one-on-one meeting and how her face fell as soon as she realized he was anything but impressed. In fact I liked it so much I made a gif out of it.

You could see she was really just trying her best to make a good impression because she respected his writing, and how offended she was when he treated her so disrespectfully in return. Joo In always tried to remain civilized and mature, even when others didn’t treat her the same way. I thought she was well-written as an actress because she seemed to handle things very professionally, even after what happened with that obsessive and spiteful stylist. I also liked that she wasn’t the typical “full-of-herself” kind of actress. Sure, she was confident in her looks and skills, but she remained genuinely friendly and laid-back to everyone she worked with, and that made her a very sympathetic character in my opinion.
In most of the synopses on drama source websites and even on the above poster, there’s a slogan that describes the couple as “a man who won’t date and a woman who can’t date”. However, as the story started, I was relieved to find that they weren’t actually defined by the fact that they chose not to date. I guess the slogan just refers to the fact that Bi Soo was too self-righteous for a relationship and Joo In had never dated despite her image as a romcom actress, but they both seemed perfectly happy with themselves the way they were, even without a romantic partner.
I really loved how close they both were to their moms. In hindsight I’d say their respective bonds with their mothers touched me more than their romantic relationship. I thought it was really sweet how Bi Soo started warming up to Joo In after witnessing the state her mother was in. At some point, Jung Hwa has an Alzheimer episode in which she mistakes Bi Soo for her late husband and he is thoughtful enough to play along for an entire day until she becomes lucid again. I really loved the part where he ended up dancing with Joo In’s mom and how he kept playing his part even after Jung Hwa realized she’d been having an episode. It was really nice that Bi Soo initially softened towards Joo In out of empathy with regards to what she was going through with her mother.
While it started with a respectful gesture towards her mother, I really liked the gradual build-up and development of the romance between Bi Soo and Joo In, despite the occasional cheesiness. I also liked that Bi Soo caught feelings first, since that was such a rare thing to happen. Although I did find the way he suddenly accepted his feelings for her a bit abrupt (he went from slapping himself for dreaming about her to confessing his undying love to her within the same episode), I did like the way things progressed and how the romantic tension slowly built between them. Yes, he could get slightly childish and petty, especially after Yoo Jin turned up as a love rival, but I honestly found it quite endearing how he started showing affection to her. Joo In’s feelings also developed very naturally, and I liked that she genuinely considered his love confession even when it surprised her and she couldn’t reciprocate it on the spot. All in all it was a solid example of a typical “enemies to lovers” trope drama.

I really enjoyed their relationship leading up to Bi Soo’s love confession, since it brought out the subtle chemistry between the main actors and it felt like they were drawn to each other very naturally. It seemed so self-evident that they were both mutually attracted to each other that it actually threw me off when Yoo Jin suddenly came into the picture.
Yoo Jin had been able to intercept a snooping journalist who was about to release an article on how Bi Soo and Joo In were living together, and he’d come up with the (for him) very convenient solution to distract the attention from those “rumors” by announcing that he and Joo In were dating instead – they were close friends and she was the spokesperson for his family’s cosmetic brand after all.
Yoo Jin prompts this suggestion RIGHT AFTER Joo In tells Bi Soo that she will consider his confession, and for some reason, she IMMEDIATELY agrees to go along with Yoo Jin’s plan to “fake date” him, RIGHT IN FRONT of Bi Soo. Honestly, that was kind of a dick move on Joo In’s part. I just couldn’t understand how she wasn’t able to deduct that that was a super insensitive thing to do in front of the person who just confessed his true feelings for her. When Bi Soo silently walked off after that she literally went, “huh, did I upset him in some way?🤔”. I honestly didn’t understand why she did that. The only possible reason I could think of was that she genuinely didn’t consider Yoo Jin as more than a friend and she just went along with it as an, “oh yeah, that’s a good plan, thanks for helping me out, bestie” without even linking it to what she felt for Bi Soo. Still, the fact that she didn’t even consider how that would make Bi Soo feel was kind of unrealistic to me, because she’d seemed so clearly attracted to him and offered to genuinely consider his confession just before that. Also, if she really didn’t feel anything for Yoo Jin at that point, it was also inconsistent with what happened next.
Shortly after she starts “fake dating” Yoo Jin, she SOMEHOW SUDDENLY develops feelings for him anyway, even after reassuring Bi Soo that wouldn’t happen. I actually hated that. It was super weird because in my opinion the tension she already had with Bi Soo at that point was NOWHERE to be found in her interactions with Yoo Jin. I honestly still don’t understand why they wrote this in. Why was it necessary to give Yoo Jin false hope, when it would just end with Joo In rejecting him because she only felt comfortable with him as a friend? I didn’t think it was necessary to create this extra drama by suddenly including Yoo Jin as an actual potential love rival when Joo In had never considered him as such up to that point. Why now, suddenly? They could’ve just let Yoo Jin exist as the second male lead who never actually stood a chance but kept making a move until Joo In officially drew the line, without giving him temporary false hope.
When she actually sat the two of them down and admitted she had feelings for both of them, I was like “nah man”. It felt so out of character for her, the way she dropped that on them and then just walked off, leaving them to fight it out amongst themselves while SHE was the one who had to sort out her feelings. It suddenly turned into some kind of Single’s Inferno competition between two guys trying to win over the same girl. Honestly, that would’ve given me the ick. I’d be like, girl, if you can’t be sure about me, then I deserve better, bye. But the fact that the guys actually starting competing over her, trying to trump each other by getting her to choose whose self-made food she liked better? Seriously? Why did it suddenly have to become so shallow? It took ALL the romance away for me. She was going to pick Bi Soo anyway, and when they officially got together they just reverted back to their initial cute dynamic, so I honestly didn’t think it was necessary to include this weird intermission.
As a matter of fact, the competition didn’t even end after Bi Soo and Joo In started dating. Yoo Jin kept trying to worm his way in and grasp any opportunity he could to get Joo In to spend time with him. On the other hand, whenever Yoo Jin came over to the house, Bi Soo would consistently rub it in his face that “he won”. It got pretty petty and childish at some point. Even after Joo In had already made up her mind about who she was romantically attracted to, it still felt as if they continued the competition behind her back.
In addition to that, and this will link to my most hated part of the story which I’ll elaborate on later, I didn’t see the point of Bi Soo gloating so much about his and Joo In’s relationship to Yoo Jin if he was just going to ask him to “take care of her” after he had to leave anyway. Like, why rub it in his face and be so petty in showing him how happy you are with Joo In when you’re going to appoint him as your back-up man all the same? I generally don’t like it when the male leads start talking about the female lead behind her back to discuss “who will make her the happiest” or “who will take care of her best”. As if that’s up to them to decide! Why did neither of them even ask Joo In what she wanted? In that aspect they were both pretty selfish in their feelings for her, because they just followed their own intentions. Yoo Jin still planned on proposing to her even after she already rejected him I mean, come on!
I really didn’t like how opportunistic Yoo Jin became when it came to sliding back into Joo In’s life whenever she had a falling out with Bi Soo. It was like he was waiting for a chance to get Joo In back at his side. In fact, he actually said this to his secretary when Joo In came to him after taking distance from Bi Soo, that “at least I’ve got her at my side again”.
It’s not that I truly disliked the male leads and it was clear that they were both genuine about their feelings for Joo In, but some things about the way they talked about her and tried to win her over were pretty toxic. Having said that, again I did really like the way the relationship between Bi Soo and Joo In started and built up in the first half of the show. It brought me back to old school romcom K-Dramas and I enjoyed those scenes a lot.

Now that I’ve discussed the main love triangle, I’d like to talk a bit more about the leads’ family members. Starting with Bi Soo’s family, as I mentioned in the beginning he got estranged from his father when he was eighteen and he busted him doing something unforgiveable. It’s eventually revealed that he witnessed his father having an affair through an ajar door, and this led him to become so neurotic about always closing doors. He’s never forgiven his father and it has only strengthened his love for his mother.
I found the detail of him calling his mother by her first name a nice little quirk, by the way. The subtitles I watched missed the relevance of this – I remember a scene where they were literally talking about how he always called her “Hae Jin-ssi” instead of “Mom” while in the subtitles it was consistently translated as “Mom”😅.
Kang Hae Jin is the director of Sein Hospital where she works with her husband. She’s been a doctor for a very long time but suddenly finds herself on the receiving end of healthcare when she is diagnosed with stage 4 pancreatic cancer. While she keeps this a secret from her husband and son, Hae Jin sets out to reconnect with some old friends: her first love Kim Chang Gyu (the record shop owner) and her old friend Yoon Jung Hwa (Joo In’s mother). These reconnections are all successful and the three of them start meeting up again, often at the record shop. As her illness progresses, Hae Jin ultimately retires from the hospital and gets herself admitted to the same nursing home as Jung Hwa so they can spend their remaining time together like roommates.
Honestly, I lived for this friendship. It was so full of genuine love and care for one another that it actually warmed my heart. I know I often say that I prefer it when supporting storylines don’t distract too much from the main storyline, but this was such a wholesome and beautiful addition to the main story that I actually ended up liking it more than the main leads’ romance.
I really loved Kang Hae Jin. She was such a beautiful and strong woman, and so genuinely kind to everyone. In the beginning I kind of feared that she might become an evil mother-in-law, but I’m really glad she got on so well with Joo In from the start and immediately knew she’d be a great match for her son. She remained so solid and strong throughout the story, even when she started succumbing to her illness. I don’t remember the last time I got so attached to a lead character’s mother, haha.
The same went for Jung Hwa, by the way. She was such a lovely mother to Joo In and I loved her warm smile. The flashbacks and information about how she and her late husband would spend time and dance together was so sweet. They managed to establish the mother-daughter relationship between her and Joo In so well that it actually hurt when she suddenly couldn’t recognize Joo In anymore. From how she reacted, both when she became lucid after mistaking Bi Soo for her husband and after she found out she forgot about her daughter for a moment, it was clear to see what kind of person she was. That’s why I found it so sweet of Bi Soo to play along with it in order to cover for Jung Hwa’s embarassment. The shock and terror on Jung Hwa’s face when Hae Jin told her she forgot about Joo In for a moment was physically painful. They really did such a good job in establishing the true love and care between the mothers and their children, I think this might be the most touching depiction of a mother-child bond I’ve seen in a K-Drama so far.
The friendship between Hae Jin and Jung Hwa was also delightful, it was so heartwarming to see them welcome each other back into their lives, and how they started thinking of each other and shipping their children together, lol.
I also really liked Kim Chang Gyu, he was such a goofball. It was really nice to have a slightly eccentric and fun energy in-between all the serious and dramatic topics. It was established that Chang Gyu and Hae Jin had a crush on each other back in the day, but that neither of them acted on it. Honestly, I would’ve found it cute if they still got together after reuniting, even if they didn’t put an official label on it. Their platonic friendship was really endearing to watch.
I also liked the friendship between Bi Soo and Chang Gyu. They’d met when Bi Soo came into the record shop and cried to a record after just witnessing his father’s affair, and after that he found himself coming to visit the shop more often. It became a safe and familiar place for him. It was nice that they kept coming back to the shop and listen to records in the listening room, that was a nice recurring element. It was also funny when Chang Gyu and Hae Jin established that Bi Soo might’ve even been Chang Gyu’s son and he called him up like, “Hey son, you know I could’ve been your dad!” The playfulness with which Chang Gyu interacted with both Hae Jin and Bi Soo was really endearing.
Another relation to Hae Jin that I liked was the nurse lady, Jung Sang Eun (played by Bae Hae Seon). There was a part where I actually feared she might’ve been the person her husband cheated on back in the day because of how awkwardly they acted when Hae Jin told them she was going to recommend both of them to become the next hospital director, but I’m really glad that turned out not to be the case. It was cool that Sang Eun ended up successing Hae Jin, the husband was a douche anyway. He actually blamed Hae Jin for not choosing him while the choice wasn’t even up to her, she recommended them both and the board decided. I’m glad she divorced him. The part where she confronted him and got mad at him, not only for cheating on her in the past but also for threatening Bi Soo into keeping silent about it was really satisfying. That guy needed to GO. She was much better off with her new old friends.
Even in her friendship with Sang Eun it was clear that Hae Jin was a genuinely kind person. Apparently she’d helped Sang Eun out when the latter started out as a nurse, and I also really liked the story of how she was the first person to properly comfort Sang Eun after her husband suddenly passed away. She was the first person who didn’t swamp her with worried questions about how she was doing, but who took her out for dinner and a drink. When Sang Eun told her that and Hae Jin admitted that she actually didn’t really know how to comfort her at the time, this honestly struck a chord with me. I’ve been hearing some stories from my friends lately about how they worry about and struggle with some things. I always try to be supportive and provide my own experiences with similar situations in order to relate to them and make them feel understood. Whenever I admit that I’m not sure if my words are helpful, they always tell me that they don’t need me to give advice; having someone listen to their story and relate to it is enough. I honestly felt like Hae Jin was that kind of friend as well, she just tried to comfort her friends by spending some time with them and distracting them with something fun rather than keep confronting them with what happened. Every aspect that was revealed about Hae Jin made me love her more. She was such a wholesome character, and the same went for Jung Hwa and Chang Gyu. I also thought it was nice that Sang Eun became kind of a supporting character in Hae Jin’s and Bi Soo’s story, how she comforted both of them and related to their experiences by reflecting on how it had been for her after she lost her husband. She was a really a caring person and it was heartwarming to watch her friendship with Hae Jin.

Hae Jin’s deteriorating illness also influences Bi Soo’s life, not only because he wants his drama to premiere while she is still alive, but also because he himself still gets visits from the mysterious angel figure that keeps telling him that he is also going to die soon. Hae Jin eventually passes away before the drama airs, and when Bi Soo goes through her things, he finds something very interesting: a little picture of a man – the mysterious angel figure. It had already been established before that his father – the one who cheated – wasn’t his biological father, and that his real father passed away in a car accident before Bi Soo was born. While Hae Jin was already pregnant at the time, his dad got into the accident as he was on his way to propose to her (a heartbreaking detail, OF COURSE he was on his way to propose 😭💔). In any case, the mysterious angel figure turns out to be Bi Soo’s biological father, Lee Gwang Chul (if I remember correctly – MDL only lists him as “man in white” but I know for sure that Hae Jin told Bi Soo his name in the show). Since Bi Soo got into a car accident, just like his dad, Gwang Chul managed to get him a life extention so he could at least be with his mom before she died. He also wanted Bi Soo to experience love, as he himself died with the regret that he never got to propose to Hae Jin and live out a happy and loving life with her.
I know I probably could’ve seen it coming from miles away as they kept talking about Bi Soo’s biological father and it would’ve been random if he was just a completely unrelated mystery angel. Still, when they found his picture in Hae Jin’s things I was like, “WAIT IT’S HIS DAD?!?! 🤯🤯🤯”. I actually really liked that plot twist. It was also a nice revelation that the angel had good intentions with Bi Soo from the start and that he’d done everything he could to help him even though he couldn’t completely save him from death. It would’ve been really nice to see some flashbacks of Gwang Chul and Hae Jin, or to see Hae Jin reunite with him in Heaven or something. Still, I thought it was really nice that they added him as a caring figure that watched over the son that he never got to raise.

Just to make an in-between comment: something I really appreciated about this show was that, as I already mentioned in the above sections, it did a really good job at establishing and explaining a lot of aspects to the characters’ personalities that made them very credible and realistic. For example, the fact that Bi Soo’s neurotic habit of closing all the doors resulted from his trauma of witnessing his father having an affair through an open door. They revealed that explanation quite early into the story, before it became clear what he’d seen his father do, but it immediately made me go, “Oh, so that’s why he does that, I get it.” I’m glad they put in the effort to address details like that, even with a simple and logical explanation. I was also happy that they ultimately established who the angel figure was and what the life extension deal was about. I was kind of worried that they would never explain it and leave the figure as a random unnamed angel, but the revelation of his identity and the reason why he made sure Bi Soo’s life was extended for at least that long put me at ease, so I welcomed that.
I also liked little details like that they actually referred back to elements from Joo In and Yoo Jin’s shared past, like the unicorn and that they had pictures together from when they were still in high school and stuff like that. They might seem like little things, but I’ve seen enough dramas where they don’t even bother being consistent with small details like that, so I do see it as a sign that it was well-written and thought out. They added a lot of small elements that kept coming back throughout the story in unexpected ways, and I liked that attention to detail.

Before moving on to my most hated part of the story, I want to talk about two more love story plotlines that were included in this drama. The first one is the romance between Bi Soo’s assistant writer Jung Jae Hwan and Joo In’s road manager Bae Gwang Ja. Gwang Ja falls for Jae Hwan at first sight when he accompanies Bi Soo as he settles into the study room for the first time after moving out of the house. Funnily enough it immediately seems to be mutual, and the two make a very light and lovey-dovey couple throughout the show.
While I will admit that it was sometimes nice to have a little breather from the drama that occasionally occurred between Bi Soo and Joo In, I think this was probably the most shallow romance storyline in the whole show. It was all exterior, the cheesiness, the openly affectionate gestures, the way they talked to each other. It was all laid on so thick, but it didn’t actually make me feel anything on the inside. Their scenes also became repetitive when they took different sides in the conflict between Bi Soo and Joo In. There was actually one scene that they pretty much replicated, I distinctly remember seeing the second scene and going, “this was literally the same conversation they had in their previous scene together”. Gwang Ja complained about Bi Soo to Jae Hwan, Jae Hwan took Bi Soo’s side, Gwang Ja got mad at Jae Hwan and left the room pouting, “I’m disappointed in you”. This repetitive element in turn caused their scenes to become almost filler-like, like they stopped contributing anything to the main story. I mean, they could’ve at least had some in-between scenes where they put their heads together to think of a way to help Bi Soo and Joo In make up or something. Instead their scenes just became empty farces of Gwang Ja calling Jae Hwan “My Jae Hwan” and telling him how sexy he was. Whenever they discussed Bi Soo and Joo In they always ended up parting ways because they both took the side of their own employer. I think as a couple they definitely had their cute moments, but the writers could’ve definitely fleshed them out way more and have them contribute to the main story much better. They did get Bi Soo to ask Gwang Ja for help in order to soften Joo In when she was mad at him one time, so why didn’t they do more with that? I honestly think Gwang Ja and Jae Hwan could’ve contributed way more to the story if they’d been written as a slightly more mature couple that acknowledged their employers’ respective flaws.

The other supporting romance storyline that I actually did like was the one between Bi Soo’s director Yoo Dae Young and Joo In’s director Kim Yi Na. They actually paired up both teams as couples, which was kind of funny. In contrast to Gwang Ja and Jae Hyun, this couple was maybe a bit too mature, haha. I thought it was really cute how Yi Na started warming up to Dae Young while he was constantly telling himself that she was way out of his league. I loved how he went out of his comfort zone to make a move on her, and how he simultaneously remained respectful when she asked for distance. I thought it brought a very mature layer to their relationship when Yi Na told him that she was hesitant because she’d experienced living together with a lover before which went wrong. His face when she told him he could get find a better woman than her 😭. You could see hear him think, “No I won’t”, because he was so insecure about his looks 😭. It was really cute how she gradually started allowing herself to adore him and how happy he was when she finally agreed to let him in. Their relationship just existed on its own, it didn’t affect the main story or anything, but it was still a nice addition and a nice example of two grown adults with their respective insecurities and restraints who could still properly communicate their feelings to each other.

Which brings me to the part I’ve been waiting to vent about – my main criticism of this show and the part that partially ruined the story for me. It actually almost ruined Lee Min Gi for me, and I will never forgive them for that.
As we know from the start, Bi Soo has been getting visits from a mysterious angel figure that tells him he will soon disappear from the face of the earth. As a matter of fact, Bi Soo actually starts disappearing for short periods of time. This started about halfway through the show, after he and Joo In finally got together. I remember that at that point I was JUST thinking, “now that the romance has been established, I wonder what they’ll fill the second half of the show with”, and that’s when he disappeared for the first time. The angel tells him that in 49 days, he will disappear forever, and Bi Soo is made to believe this when he later disappears again at the exact moment the angel told him. Shortly after finding out about this, Bi Soo finds out about his mom’s illness. He doesn’t tell anyone about his own issue. Admittedly, it would be kind of hard to explain that he was brought back to life by an angel and it was understandable that he didn’t want to bother his mother with that news. In any case, it happens somewhere around the time that Hae Jin moves into the nursing home and Joo In is being a super supportive girlfriend that regularly visits her. I don’t remember what exactly caused the switch, but somehow the realization that he will soon disappear and leave his loved ones behind leads Bi Soo to the sudden decision that he doesn’t want to put Joo In through that.
People who have read more reviews from me will know that one of my most hated tropes is the one where one main lead pushes the other away in order to “protect” them. Apparently for some people it’s easier to break someone’s heart than tell them a painful truth which they can then face together. Much to my disdain, this drama was no exception to that trope, but that wasn’t all. Not only did Bi Soo suddenly start pushing Joo In away without a single explanation, he actually took it to the next level and became the most horrible, hurtful and gaslighting person ever. Besides the fact that he didn’t even acknowledge that his sudden change in behavior came completely out of the blue and would of course be very hard for Joo In to understand, he actively started gaslighting her that SHE wasn’t able to let go of HIM, while HE was the one who couldn’t bring himself to tell her the truth. He literally started treating her like trash one day after he told her he loved her. What made it even worse was that, besides the fact that he suddenly told her that it wasn’t any of her business to get involved with his mom anymore, he actually took their conflict to the work floor. During a meeting with her he literally says that he’s been stressed out lately because “someone can’t take no for an answer”. That was so passive agressive, not to mention it was a business meeting and there were actually people in the room with them. When Joo In gets carried away during the first script reading – because he literally used their romantic endeavors as inspiration!! – he openly criticizes her for being unprofessional with the ENTIRE CAST present.
It just went from bad to worse. As if it wasn’t bad enough that he told her he only used her as inspiration for his female character and that he didn’t have any feelings for her. Every single time he pulled something like that or walked away from the problem I just went, “how is it actually getting WORSE AND WORSE?!” It just made it all the more frustrating because HE was the problem. HE suddenly selfishly decided their relationship was over and started telling other people that while Joo In was still unable to process what the hell he was even doing. I couldn’t believe he actually went as far as to invite her and Yoo Jin to a bar and just went, “There you go, you two can get together now” and that he even invited his childhood crush to a dinner with Joo In just to make her jealous. Like, he even started involving other people’s feelings as well. Luckily Joo In (as well as everyone else he got involved) saw exactly what he was trying to do, but it just sucked that he was so persistent on not telling anyone what his true reason was. To be fair, it didn’t even matter if he felt bad about it – if he was going to agonize by himself in his room after leaving Joo In hurt like that time and time again, why inflict that pain on her in the first place? When he finds her crying in her room one night after she’s finally agreed to break up with him, he actually goes over to her to tell her to take her crying outside because she’s being too loud. Honestly, it didn’t even look like he was faking it, he looked way too unconcerned throughout the whole thing. After all the effort he went through to make Joo In fall for him, it was incomprehensible to me that he was able to return to his room and go, “well, at least now she won’t get hurt”. It was plain unrealistic how he apparently couldn’t get it through his thick skull that he was hurting her way more than he would’ve if he’d just told her the truth. Even after she literally ended up hospitalized because of the stress he caused her, he STILL wouldn’t open up about it. It really took the trope I already hated the most to a legit UNBEARABLE level. Within three episodes, I lost ALL my respect and sympathy for Bi Soo. Even after they eventually made up again, their romance just wasn’t the same for me. I couldn’t even watch their passionate kisses after that because his character was ruined for me completely and “kissing it better” didn’t help to redeem him at all. I honestly cannot put into words how frustrated and angry this part made me. I just found it unfathomable how he didn’t realize that he was unnecessarily making everything worse. He wasted so much time that he could’ve spent happily with Joo In as they anticipated his final moments together. Honestly, this part actually ruined their romance for me.

I saw a lot of comments from people about how they also hated Joo In for putting up with the whole ordeal, but I honestly stood by her. The way she responded to his change in behavior was very realistic to me. It made sense how she initially thought he was pulling a weird joke and then got increasingly confused and frustrated as he kept going. While I personally would’ve made use of my landlady rights and kicked him out on at least five occasions, I do think it was characteristic of her to hold on to him. She loved him so much and it was clear that he was trying to push her away for a reason. I thought it was really mature of her that she just KNEW he had to be hiding something and she didn’t just accept that he apparently stopped loving her overnight.
I do have to admit that it bothered me when she found his notes about dying in 49 days and all she did was tilt her head and go, “huh, I wonder if he’s depressed or something” and just left it at that 🥲. Like, that was a fairly concerning factor that she could’ve asked him about, as it was something he wrote and wouldn’t be able to dismiss as easily.
Anyways, despite the fact that I admired how she tried to hold on to her love for him as long as she could, it did come as quite a relief when she finally took some distance and started letting go of him. At that point I was like, no matter how much you love someone, if this is how they deal with their shit you know that’s not okay. He just became a major red flag. I was lowkey reminded of the couple from Douse Mou Nigerarenai, although I felt much more empathy for the female lead in this case. I can’t believe Bi Soo kept it up even after Joo In witnessed him disappear right in front of her, he literally kept gaslighting her that she was imagining things. He only admitted that he “didn’t want her to get hurt” after she had to pull it out of him with everything she had, it was unbelievable.
As I said, that whole ordeal just ruined their relationship for me. I wasn’t even able to enjoy it when they reverted back to their initial dynamic after they finally made up and Bi Soo told her the truth. At least they were finally able to do what they could’ve done all this time, anticipate his final moments and enjoy the time they had left together to the fullest. But by that point it had lost all meaning to me.
What bothered me the most wasn’t just the exaggerated “pushing her away” trope, but the fact that it completely ruined the main couple for me. Honestly at some point I didn’t even want them to get back together, I even started thinking that Yoo Jin might be a better boyfriend for Joo In after all, because at least he would never do anything to hurt her.
Similar to what happened with the love triangle intermission, I just ended up feeling that it was unnecessary to create this immense exaggerated drama only to have them end up right where they started and just dismiss all the hurt that had been done. I didn’t agree with Joo In for forgiving him so easily, he literally only said sorry ONCE and she was like “you don’t need to be sorry”. EXCUSE ME? He absolutely needed to be sorry! Sorry was the very least he needed to be!

One thing I appreciated about the ending was that it actually did end with Bi Soo disappearing. I have to admit I got confused for a second when they showed that story he told her about how he didn’t disappear and ended up living happily ever after, but that was on me for missing the transition, lol. It would’ve honestly ruined it for me even more if they ended up finding some sort of loophole to bring him back, like they did in My Demon. I thought it was better that he did end up disappearing, because through that they at least stayed true to the inevitability of his death and the deal his father was able to strike for him. I found it much more powerful that it ended with Joo In moving on with her life whilst holding on to her fond memories of him. It was touching that she could keep holding on to little things that reminded her of him. I have to admit that at first I found his suggestion to use her mother’s forgetful episodes as an opportunity to practice different roles a bit problematic, but I did like that they brought that back in the end when her mother started forgetting her more often, as it did help Joo In to deal with it better. This also traced back to my earlier point that I liked the attention to detail in this show, they kept bringing certain elements and things they’d shared back in a touching way.

I think I’ve covered most of what I wanted to share about the content of this series. Before I move on to my cast comments I’d like to make a final note on the series’ title. The Korean title of the show is “Oh! Jooinnnim”, which refers directly to Joo In’s full name and the main leads’ house sharing deal. As part of the agreement, Joo In has to call Bi Soo “jakganim” (“writer”) while Bi Soo has to call Joo In “jooinnim”, which is a formal address (like “Ms. Joo In”) and also refers to the fact that she is the “master” of the house.
I know that the more well-known English title for this series is “Oh My Ladylord”, but since it’s established in the series that “jooinnim” means “master” and Bi Soo also addresses her as “master” rather than “my ladylord” (“master” is formal enough), I decided to use the title “Oh! Master” here to retain that reference.

Like last time, I wrote this review in parts in-between my translation work and course assignments, and I have to admit it actually feels nice to divide my time to finish it. I’ve gotten so used to writing reviews in a single day that I started pushing myself a bit to keep doing that. However, it’s happening more often that I just can’t get in the mood or find the right concentration to go at it, so I’ve allowed myself to spend some more time establishing my arguments and making sure I include everything I want to share. I might take this approach more often in the future, as it helps take away the pressure of finishing a review within a single day (a pressure which I’m putting on myself, of course).

Let’s get on with the cast comments shall we? 🤗

I’ve only seen Nana/Im Jin Ah before in Mask Girl, where she was the final evolution of Kim Mo Mi. Back then I already thought she was gorgeous, and seeing her as a glamorous actress/model in this only confirmed that for me. Her smile is so dazzling 🌟 I have to say I really enjoyed her acting. Her expressions were amazing and made me laugh from the get-go. Throughout the show I think she did a really good job balancing out the different layers of her character, from the celebrity to the worried daughter. Both her expressions and her bubbly acting reminded me of two of my favorite Japanese actresses, Ayase Haruka and Ishihara Satomi. The way she exuded a natural sense of confidence without coming across as arrogant really helped build sympathy for her, she didn’t seem like someone who’d be caught off guard or swept off her feet that easily. I also really liked her chemistry with Lee Min Gi in the first half of the show when the romance between the main leads was building up. I really hope I’ll get to see more of her acting, because now I’ve already seen her in two completely different roles and I really enjoyed both.

As much as I love Lee Min Gi, part of me still can’t believe he accepted this role 😅. I usually love seeing him in romantic comedies because he always manages to steal my heart with his cute awkwardness. I do feel like he tends to be cast as the same kind of guy in romcoms though, he’s usually the awkward, robotic, apathetic guy who finds himself suddenly lightened up by the female lead. My favorite romcom with him is still Because This is My First Life. Besides that I’ve also seen him in Shut Up Flower Boy Band (I got major flashbacks when Bi Soo got hit by that car in the first episode 😭), What’s Wrong With Secretary Kim? (everyone loved that BTiMFL reunion), The Beauty Inside (admittedly not a favorite), My Liberation Notes (🫶🏻), and an old movie called Quick. I know there are still some shows with him on my watchlist, so I’m excited for that.
All in all, although his character was ultimately ruined for me because of the stupid avoidance trope, Lee Min Gi did do a very good job. He really went the extra mile to make his character as unsympathetic as possible. One thing I like about him is how he can portray such rude and unapologetic characters because I can imagine how hard it must be to portray a character that you yourself find insufferable. I remember I also didn’t find his character in MLN sympathetic but I was still able to enjoy the fervor with which he played him. Oh! Master will probably be categorized alongside my lesser favorites like TBI, but I’m glad to say the show didn’t ruin him for me completely – I’m still really excited to see him appear in more shows.

I know Kang Min Hyuk from CNBLUE (he used to be my friend’s bias), and I’ve seen him before in a couple of shows, like Heartstrings and The Heirs, in which I liked him a lot. This was the first time I’ve seen him portray a second male lead in a love triangle. While Yoo Jin seemed like a friendly enough person, one thing that did bother me was that they tied him to Joo In so much that he didn’t really seem to have a personality outside of that. Like, his feelings for Joo In were what defined him, literally, and all his appearances in the show were linked to his love for her. In hindsight there wasn’t really anything remarkable that I can say about his personality, and that’s a pity because Kang Min Hyuk is a fine actor and he could’ve brought way more to the character if it had been fleshed out a bit better. He did a good job nonetheless, this was just a comment on the writing. I’m curious to see him in more different roles, because I’ve definitely seen enough variation from him to know he is able of much more than just a persistent second lead character.

While Lee Hwi Hyang has been appearing in dramas since the 70s, I honestly believe this is the first time I’ve seen her in anything. I really loved her performance as Kang Hae Jin, she brought such a wholesome and lovely energy to her character. She had great chemistry with all the other actors and she exuded an unyielding spark of joy that warmed my heart. I loved that the parts about her past that were revealed all contributed equally to her character, how she’d lost the love of her life and still was able to give so much warmth and care to the people around her. I think she was a very well-written and established character. As I mentioned in my analysis I can’t remember the last time I felt so taken with a lead character’s mother, she did such a great job. I just couldn’t help but feel drawn to the warmth she exuded through her portrayal of Kang Hae Jin.

I thought Kim Ho Jung looked familiar and I have indeed seen her in some shows before, but this role of hers will probably stick with me the most. She also appeared in Age of Youth Season 2 and That Man Oh Soo and I remember her character from Arthdal Chronicles as well. Kim Ho Jung has such a beautifully loving smile, it warmed me every single time. I really loved her chemistry with Nana, and as I said they did a really good job establishing the strong bond between them. If it weren’t for that, the scenes where she would suddenly not recognize her daughter anymore probably wouldn’t have made as much of an impact, so that was great. I loved that, while her Alzheimer’s was gradually getting worse, she was still able to contribute so much to the story while being lucid, and it was bittersweet to see her forgetfulness increase in the ending. I think the relationship between Joo In and Jung Hwa was also very relevant to Joo In’s individual character building, so it was nice to see how she contributed to that as well. I really hope to see her portray more varying characters in the future!

Kim Chang Wan is one of those actors that I’m always happy to see even if he plays a bad guy, lol. He just has such a quirky energy about him. I’ve seen him before in Coffee Prince, My Love From Another Star, Hwarang, 20th Century Boy and Girl, Jugglers, Something in the Rain and It’s Okay Not to Be Okay. He always brings an unexpected energy to his characters, there is always this joyous glint in his eye that makes his performances become so endearing to watch. In this show as well, Chang Gyu was such a goofball, how he would just slump over the cashier and stare at Hae Jin or triumphantly get his guitar to play her a song. I really liked the energy that he brought, and also that he was a bit of a rock to Bi Soo. I didn’t know he would be in this show so it was a nice surprise to suddenly see him appear like that. Here’s to spotting him many more times in many more dramas to come!

Another familiar face that I always like to see is Bae Hae Seon. I’ve seen her in a bunch of things, also often as a guest appearance, like Jealousy Incarnate, While You Were Sleeping, Wok of Love, Come and Hug Me, The Secret Life of My Secretary, Hotel del Luna, It’s Okay to Not Be Okay, SF8: Baby It’s Over Outside, Start-Up, Hometown Cha-Cha-Cha and Crash Course in Romance. I like how she also always manages to bring something new to her characters and she never shies away from being a little quirky. I honestly feel like she’s a very intelligent actress that is able to tap into a lot of different perspectives and emotions, and I would like to see her in more main or recurring roles rather than just guest appearances because she’s really good. I liked that she appeared in this, she was great (as always).

I guess it’s not strange that I haven’t seen Lee Hyun Jung in anything because she’s only done two dramas so far. I feel like she may be a bit of a comical TV personality or something, because she was definitely cast as the comedy sidekick. As I mentioned in my analysis of Gwang Ja, I would’ve personally liked it if she’d acted a bit more from the heart and less from the face and voice. There were more than enough opportunities to be funny, and also more than enough opportunities to show a slightly more mature side, both towards the situation between Bi Soo and Joo In and towards Jae Hwan. I won’t deny that she brought a nice energy and it was nice that besides a road manager she was also a close friend to Joo In. I’m curious if she’ll appear in more shows in the future, I hope I can see a bit more serious acting from her!

Song Yoo Taek also only has three dramas to his name. He didn’t immediately look familiar to me, but apparently he was also in Arthdal Chronicles. I actually thought he was way younger than Lee Hyun Jung as they made a deal about her being his “noona” (and I think she also looks much older than him 🫢) but he’s actually just one year younger than her. I really liked Jae Hwan, he had a really endearing energy about him. I actually think he was better able to channel a more serious side, but he was often snowed under by Gwang Ja’s exuberance. A part of me found it a pity that he went along with her energy rather than remain a bit more serious to balance her out. Anyways, he delivered a nice performance and it was nice to see how he actually became the writer for the second season of Bi Soo’s drama. I hope to see more of him as well, he had a really nice screen presence.

It was such a nice change to see Kim Kwang Shik in a role that wasn’t a mean or grumpy ahjussi! I’ve seen him in a couple of shows before, like Andante, 20th Century Boy and Girl and The Light in Your Eyes, and I think he often appears in cameos or guest appearances as well. I really loved that they gave Director Yoon a romance storyline of his own, because characters like him usually just exist on the business side of things. He brought a really nice element to the story and I enjoyed his performance a lot. I’m not much of an aegyo person but it was funny to see a buff man like him channel a cute side of himself. In terms of acting variety his performance in this show definitely made him rise in my esteem.

Woo Hee Jin was another familiar face. I’ve seen her in Healer, Moon Lovers: Scarlet Heart Ryeo, Dali and the Cocky Prince and My Demon. There’s a couple more of her dramas on my list, so I’m definitely going to see her again. It was nice to see her in a more comical role than usual, I really liked how Yi Na found herself drawn to Dae Young, almost in spite of herself. I always like to see familiar faces portray a kind of role that I haven’t seen them in before, but it seemed to come quite natural to her. As I mentioned before, I liked how she gradually decided to let Dae Young in and eventually told him why she was hesitating – if only the male lead could have communicated as clearly as that 🙄. In hindsight, I think the dynamic and relationship between Yi Na and Dae Young was probably the most interesting and engaging one in the show for me, and that was all because of the chemistry between Woo Hee Jin and Kim Kwang Shik, so well done!

Finally, I just want to give a final shoutout to Kang Seung Ho, who played the mysterious angel/Bi Soo’s biological father. Funny how you suddenly discover a new actor and then you go on to see them in other stuff even though you’d never seen them in anything before. Kang Seung Ho played Noh Do Kyung in My Demon, which I watched very recently. He made such a big impression on me there, also because I’d never seen him before, and now he suddenly appeared as such a mild and gentle angel father! That was really unexpected but it was a nice surprise to see him appear. As I said, I would’ve liked to see some more flashbacks of him and when he and Hae Jin were happy together. The flashback scene of him running across the street with that bouquet of flowers before he died was heartbreaking, and I wished I could remember him by more than that. But all in all I think he did a nice job and I liked the final revelation that he turned out to be Bi Soo’s father watching him from Heaven, that was a really nice twist.

All in all, I think this could have been a perfectly enjoyable romcom without the addition of the life extension plot and the male lead turning into the biggest jerk ever. I honestly liked the simple preset of Joo In buying the house and Bi Soo using it for his writing – that was the only element necessary to instigate their feelings for each other. The added drama of the out-of-the-blue second male lead competition was unnecessary and the trope of Bi Soo pushing Joo In away completely killed the vibe for me. Of course there will always be annoying tropes in dramas, but this one really took it to the next level and resulted in me completely losing my connection to the main leads. Which is a pity, because their kissing scenes after that were really passionate and I would’ve liked to enjoy those without constantly being reminded of what Bi Soo did and how he was forgiven and redeemed way too easily.
On the other hand I really loved the side stories about the main leads’ mothers and as I said I also really liked the attention to detail and the acting, especially Nana’s. There were many factors that still enabled me to enjoy it, so it’s still going to get a pass. I typically really like romcoms like this, so I hope I’ll be able to watch more that don’t have too many unnecessarily frustrating tropes. Sometimes less is more, writers!

I will be finishing my translation by the end of this month, which is very exciting. In the meantime I hope I can still finish a review or two, but no pressure from myself this time. I’m very excited to see what I’ll be watching next.

Until next time! x