Monthly Archives: November 2022

3-nen A-gumi

Standard

Disclaimer: this is a review, and as such it contains spoilers of the whole series. Please proceed to read at your own risk if you still plan on watching this show or if you haven’t finished it yet. You have been warned.

3-nen A-gumi
(3年A組: 今から皆さんは、人質です/Sannen A-gumi: Ima kara minasan ha, hitoshiji desu / Class 3-A: From now on, you are all hostages)
MyDramaList rating: 8.0/10

Hello everybody! Winter is already upon us, it’s getting colder and wetter and I personally try to keep myself as warm and cozy as possible. It’s almost the end of the year, which means I’m doing my best to finish some final watch list items within 2022! This one had been on my list for a while too; I guess I saw Suda Masaki was in it and thought it would be worth it. And let me tell you, it was. Big-time. I’ll try my best to write this review as watching this show was a rollercoaster journey for me and there’s so much to unravel that halfway through I was already thinking, ‘how the heck am I going to write this review?!’ But I’ll give it my best shot. You may notice already that I rated this show higher than any drama I’ve watched this year. It’s without a doubt one of the best Japanese dramas I’ve seen in a very long time. So let’s go and “Let’s think!”

3-nen A-gumi is a 10-episode Japanese drama series that focusses on Class 3-A of Kaiou High School. On the first of March, ten days before the third years graduate, 3-A’s homeroom (and art) teacher Hiiragi Ibuki, nicknamed ‘Bukki/Bookie’ (played by Suda Masaki) locks his classroom and announces to his students that for the next ten days, they will be his hostages. Thinking that it’s some weird joke, the students laugh it off, but then Hiiragi actually sets off a bomb that barricades the exit of the third floor. The rest of the students and teachers are able to evacuate the building immediately, but class 3-A is stuck.
As the 3-A students are now properly alarmed, Hiiragi tells them that now he will start ‘his final lesson’, starting with the question, ‘What makes this class different from other classes?’ As it happens, about half a year earlier, one of the students from 3-A, a popular girl named Kageyama Reina (played by Kamishiraishi Moka) committed suicide. As the best member of the school swimming club, she was caught in a scandal that claimed she had used doping during one of the tournaments, and a video was uploaded online to prove this. From this point on, she was shunned at school and everyone just assumed that this was what drove her over the edge. However, Hiiragi seems convinced that this wasn’t the real reason for Reina’s suicide and he urges his students to work and think together in order to realize what has truly happened.
With a class full of initially reluctant students, including several with lingering attachments to Reina and others who have other secret/indirect involvements in the case, Hiiragi starts out quite aggressively, using serious threats and force to snap his students out of their negligent way of thinking. He even starts out by saying that if they don’t give a correct answer by 8 PM every day, he will kill one of the students, and it initially seems like he means it, as he indeed ‘stabs’ one of them at the end of the first day and drags the body away to the art supply room, after which it isn’t seen again. Whenever the students try to overpower him, he sets off another bomb or makes another threat to keep them at bay.
However, as the days progress and they peel off layer after layer to Reina’s suicide case, it becomes more and more clear to the students what exactly Hiiragi is doing, what his motives are, and what the true meaning behind his actions is and they start acknowledging and respecting their teacher. After all, as it turns out, he is only trying to protect them and open their eyes to the reality of the society they live in. His ‘final lesson’ is designed to teach them the most important lesson of all before they graduate.

As I mentioned in my intro, I consider this drama to be one of the best Japanese dramas I’ve seen so far. I went into it without any expectations in particular, but when I came out I found myself being deeply moved. I even cried at some point. Even though I’ve only spent maybe two weeks finishing this show and the special, it really feels like I’ve been on the entire journey with the characters. I think that’s a very good aspect of it, it really made me feel like I was in that classroom with them and went through the same emotional rollercoaster as the students.

Besides the classroom scenes, we also follow some storylines happening outside of the school, such as the police team that is in charge of the case. One detective in particular, Gunji Masato (played by Shiina Kippei) is determined to take action. As a former teacher himself, he has experienced the loss of a promising student and that’s why he feels connected to this case.
On the other hand, there’s the other teachers, who set up camp in the school gymnasium as they have to deal with some practical issues such as soothing the students’ parents. Teacher Takechi Yamato (Tanabe Seiichi) uses the situation to his advantage to make appearances on TV shows and even manages to obtain a certain degree of popularity and fame – the TV items he appears in soon no longer have anything to do with the hostage case and he’s just starting to build a franchise.

Another very important aspect of this series is the app ‘Mind Voice’ which is being used as a kind of online platform in which everyone can anonymously post comments. Even though on the one hand it’s a fun way to get to know more like-minded people, on the other hand it can also become a viciously aggressive platform, especially when it comes to spreading rumors.
This app played a big part in Reina’s case as well, as the video of her taking doping was posted there and as a result, everyone started bashing Reina for it online.

Let me start by giving some more information about Hiiragi, and then go through the ‘assignments’ one by one. I will already reveal the whole plot from the start, otherwise it’ll take way too long to analyze everything.
When we meet Hiiragi in the first episode, on the day he decides to execute his hostage plan, we still don’t know anything about him. He sometimes mentions something about himself, or what he used to do, but he never reveals anything specific about his past, which leads one to quickly believe that he might actually be a crazy or dangerous person. He doesn’t seem to have any real sentiment towards his students when he starts his ‘lesson’, and this disconnection just makes him feel all the more unpredictable and scary. One minute he might seem nice enough, but then the next he’ll still tell the students that he’ll kill another one of them if they don’t get the assignment right.
So, what’s Hiiragi’s real story? Hiiragi only started being a teacher a couple of years before the whole thing went down. Before teaching, he used to be a suit actor in a tokusatsu superhero franchise. I think the best known example of this is the Kamen Rider series (look it up if you’re interested). Anyways, basically he played a villain character who’s catchphrase was ‘Let’s think!’ At the time, he was dating the daughter of his studio’s director. His girlfriend, Sagara Fumika (Tsuchimura Kaho) also used to be a teacher, but she quit after a fake video was spread about her on Mind Voice and the online comments mentally scarred her. She is currently sitting at home, trying to recuperate. Her father, Hiiragi’s former studio boss, Sagara Takahiko (Yajima Kenichi), is taking care of her. When the hostage situation is featured on the news, he tries to keep Fumika from watching it, as he knows that she’ll feel responsible – what happened to Reina is similar to what happened to her before.
Hiiragi’s past with the superhero franchise is teased and revealed bit by bit throughout the story. First and foremost, he still uses the catchphrase ‘Let’s think!’ in every single lesson. He also at some point mentions that he used to dream about becoming a superhero actor. And then we also get to see short scenes of the franchised show as a kind of foreshadowing for tricks he uses during the hostage situation. For example, some time after he has ‘killed’ the first student, there’s a snippet from the show in which the villain’s hand is severed (all special effects, of course). Not long after, a couple of students confront Hiiragi to prove that he actually killed their classmate, and Hiiragi throws them a severed hand, claiming it’s their classmate’s. Of course, this is a fake hand. He pulls a similar trick later, when he takes away five students to allegedly kill, and causes another explosion, leaving some severed arms and legs among the debris. These arms and legs too turn out to be fake. As it happens, Sagara Takahiko is one of the people who helped Hiiragi to prepare for this big plan – he provided him with a lot of props from the show itself.

Just in-between, I didn’t believe it for a second when Hiiragi started saying he would kill the students. Even when he ‘stabbed’ that one student on the first day, I just didn’t believe it was real. First of all, practically, from the teasers of this show there was nothing about any of the students dying and I’d only ever seen really positive reviews so I just didn’t expect it to be ‘that kind of show’. Secondly, from the start it just didn’t make sense to kill the students, as the whole purpose was to have the class work and think together. It would be purely for shock value to kill them, and it just didn’t make sense why he’d do that. So I didn’t buy it from the start. I did waver after the first episode though, because it did make me go like, ‘…. no way, right?’, but then when the thing happened with the severed hand etc I was like, ‘yeah, right’. That really confirmed to me that it had be fake. No matter how crazy Hiiragi may have appeared, he also acted way too relaxed for someone who just killed a kid. Also, even after telling the police that there were now 28 students left, he still asked them to bring a total of 30 rice balls to the school because the kids were starting to get hungry. In the end, it was just another way to spread a rumor on Mind Voice and make the people believe different things.

Anyways, as he was working as a suit actor, his girlfriend confided in him that this one other teacher at her school kept trying to bribe her. This teacher, none other than Takechi Yamato, was known for recommending students for a sports scholarship to this specific sports college, Gosho University. He was after one of Fumika’s students, and asked her if he could take care of that student, but she knew something was up and kept refusing, even after he started offering her money. When she told him she would sue him, he threatened her and not much later, a fake video popped up on Mind Voice featuring her and a student of hers going somewhere together. I don’t even really know what was suggested through the video, maybe that she was meeting her student in private or something, but in any case, it completely ruined her. The online hate comments made her resign. Hiiragi heard about this, and that Takechi was behind it, and a few years later he applied for a job at the school that Takechi was working at, Kaiou.
It was around this time that Hiiragi was diagnosed with pancreatic cancer. Despite his initial intention to keep an eye on Takechi, this diagnose spun Hiiragi’s life upside down and he started to live his life indifferently, not really caring about his revenge anymore. That is, until Reina came to him with her problem. He discovered that Takechi had been doing the same thing all over again, he wanted to recommend Reina to Gosho University, but she knew about his suspicious connections and refused, threatening to sue him. Takechi couldn’t have this and again, not much later, a fake video popped up about Reina using doping, and again, it blew up on Mind Voice.
Fully realizing that Takechi was the culprit of this, and that he was doing it repeatedly, ruining people’s lives with posting fake videos, Hiiragi decided that he had to take action before this would happen again, starting with his own class, the students that abandoned Reina in her darkest moments because of their own negligence. It’s not only to get back at Takechi and make him go through the same thing, but also to teach his students to become more aware of the consequences of their actions, to become more responsible and open-minded. Even though it wasn’t any of the student’s personal fault that this happened to Reina, their negligence did help to get the situation where it ended, it did lead Reina to commit suicide.

As Hiiragi reveals in the end, he had three main objectives.
The first one was to make Takechi realize his own crime by making him go through the same pain that he had inflicted on Fumika and Reina. Hiiragi actually made a fake video in which Takechi was seen entering a building with Reina on the day she committed suicide and uploaded it on Mind Voice, before revealing that it had been edited. However, because of that fake video, everyone on Mind Voice turned their target on Takechi and started bashing him online, causing Takechi to become just as paranoid as Reina before she decided to end her life.
By the way, this was depicted quite cleverly by suddenly showing some scenes literally through the eyes of Takechi. I first didn’t fully understand what this meant, but it was just to show that, ever since Hiiragi diverted the public’s attention to him, he was starting to become more and more paranoid and started hallucinating. He started imagining everyone looking at him as if he was an enemy, he heard the Mind Voice comments out loud as if they were being said by everyone around him. In the flashback of Reina’s suicide we see that Reina was suffering from the exact same mental symptoms.
The second objective was to inform the world about the violence on social media. By using fake videos and changing the situation a couple of times, Hiiragi wanted to make everyone realize how easy it was to get people online excited with only uncertain information. He announces Mind Voice to be the true murderer of Reina. She ended up taking her own life because of the cyber bullying she had to endure after the fake video was uploaded. Even though these commenters didn’t even know her and just mindlessly went along with the hype, they were actually oil to the fire that drove Reina over the edge.
The final reason was that Hiiragi wanted to teach his students the importance of individual and critical thinking. He didn’t want them to become adults who turned a blind eye when people around them were hurting, because that’s what happens in current society – we turn a blind eye because people hurt all over the world, it’s become a normal thing. He wanted to teach his students to be responsible for their own words and actions, to hold back and think, to first make sure whether it’s really the correct thing to do before making a decision that could influence someone’s life. As I mentioned before, even though they weren’t personally responsible, there were definitely some students who could’ve done something before it was too late.
On the final day, Hiiragi holds a livestream on Mind Voice in which he confronts all the SNS users of their contribution to Reina’s death. It’s additionally painful as you can see that even throughout Hiiragi’s passionate speech, the mindless and hurtful comments just keep coming. It doesn’t seem like anyone is taking him seriously and they keep telling him to die and stop blaming everything on them as ‘this is just a safe online space where we can say what we want, don’t put all your accusations on us’, bla bla bla.
The only thing that Hiiragi wanted in the end was to make people aware of their harmful behavior online, how just mindlessly going along with any kind of information, even without actual sources or truth, just for their own entertainment, could lead to a young and promising person like Reina taking her own life.

Let’s go about the 10 days of the hostage plan one by one.
On the first day, the assignment that Hiiragi gives his students is to come up with the reason why Reina killed herself. He also assigns one student in particular to answer him by 8 PM. If that student can’t tell him the correct reason by then, he’ll kill one of the students. The student he points out to answer him is Kayano Sakura (played by Nagano Mei).
Sakura was Reina’s closest friend. She was obsessed with her, as were a lot of people, to the point that she was actually secretly taking pictures of her. Her fascination with her might have seemed a little weird at first, but Reina actually thought it was interesting and asked Sakura if she wanted to be friends. They got along great, up until the point where the fake video was uploaded and Sakura was kind of cornered by her classmates to stay away from Reina, as this rumor would harm her too. However, until the end, Sakura wanted to stay by Reina’s side. She regrets now more than ever the period when she briefly left Reina’s side. Even though she knows there is more at play than just the fake video, Sakura goes along with her classmates’ pushes and tells Hiiragi that the reason is purely the doping accusation. That’s the wrong answer, and even after Sakura comes clean about her true feelings and regrets towards Reina, Hiiragi doesn’t go back on his word that he will kill someone. A very tense situation occurs when someone mentions then that he should just kill Sakura then, and Hiiragi snaps as he’s so frustrated with everyone’s negligence, even after Sakura basically had a mental breakdown in front of them minutes before. He then proceeds to seemingly stab one of the male students, and this is caught on an audio broadcast to the police, as Hiiragi has them listen in every evening.
The rumor that Hiiragi killed a student starts spreading on Mind Voice, and its users start attacking him online by calling him a murderer.
On the second day, Hiiragi specifies that it was someone in Class 3-A who posted the fake video of Reina on Mind Voice, someone who had also been posting really nasty and even intrusive comments about her online. Their assignment of the day is to figure out who this person is, or more ideally, for that person to come clean about it. During the day, there is a collision between Sakura and Usami Kaho (played by Kawaei Rina). Kaho, who used to be Reina’s best friend before she started hanging out with Sakura, still holds resentment towards Sakura for ‘taking away her best friend’. Even though, as we see through flashbacks, it’s clear that Kaho was only posing Reina around as her friend to make herself seem better. This made Reina feel like Kaho wasn’t sincerely being her friend because she cared about her, but more because her popularity rates would go up by being friends with the most popular girl in school. All Reina wanted was just to have a genuine friend who wasn’t idealizing her, and who didn’t care if she wasn’t as perfect or strong as everyone seemed to think. But she was let down, first by Kaho and then by Sakura, who also seemed to see her for this super strong person, which she wasn’t. At the end of the day, the real culprit doesn’t turn themselves in and just when Hiiragi makes a move to kill another student, Sakura steps forward to take the blame. She’s quickly interruped by Kaho, who then confesses to be the person who uploaded the fake video and finds a kind of redemption in her confession. However, despite uploading the video, she claims she wasn’t the person who actually made the video, she just found it as a DVD file in her bag one day and decided to upload it out of spite. As this was the right answer, no one was killed that day.
On the third day, the assignment becomes similar to the previous day: who made the fake video? This time, he also asks the police to cooperate by providing them with the fake video in question. See if they can figure it out. In this episode, some more information is revealed about Reina’s swimming team. Two students who were also from the swimming team are highlighted. Kumazawa Karen (Hotta Mayu) and Makabe Kakeru (Kamio Fuju). They got along fine, although Karen was a bit envious of Reina’s skills as she never managed to beat her. She also had a crush on Kakeru, but Kakeru liked Reina (and probably the other way around). One day, Kakeru got himself beaten up by a gang that was after Reina for pretending to be her boyfriend and his legs got messed up so bad he had to give up swimming. Karen blamed Reina for this, although deep down she knew this wasn’t completely true but she just needed someone to blame. Anyways, the fake video was taken in the swimming club’s locker room. We see Reina taking a pill from a pill bottle and after she leaves the camera person goes to check out the bottle by themselves to reveal it has a doping label on it. It’s visible that the person taking the bottle out of the locker is wearing a jacket that belongs to the swimming club and it has some stains on it. The police try to figure out where the stain came from by inquiring about what each of the swimming club members had for lunch that particular day, and come to the final conclusion that it has to be Karen. However, she denies it. And that’s when Satomi Kaito (Suzuki Jin) comes into light. As the most popular guy in class, Kaito has a fan club of girls in Class 3-A, but he actually also had a crush on Reina. He was rejected by her, and this instilled a grudgeful feeling within him – men are fragile when it comes to their pride. Think about it, Kakeru literally lost his physical ability to swim but Kaito just couldn’t handle a rejection. During the confrontation, Kaito admits to filming the video (he borrowed Kakeru’s jacket), but he wasn’t the person who edited it or put it in Kaho’s bag. Even though Kaito confessed, since the police’s answer was wrong, this time Hiiragi’s selects five students that he will kill, Kaito being one of them. This is when he fakes blowing five students up using those fake severed arms and legs.
On the fourth day, the assignment is to identify who suggested Kaito to make a fake video, as that’s what he previously confessed. A fellow student put the idea in his head to make the video. This time, the culprit confesses immediately. It’s Kai Hayato (Katayose Ryota), the alleged delinquent of 3-A. He easily announces that he was the one who edited the video, but Hiiragi doesn’t believe him. Yes, he was the one who told Kaito to take the video, but he wasn’t the one who actually edited it. After this day, an even bigger plot is revealed, namely the involvement of a dangerous gang called Berumuzu. It turns out that Kai was being threatened by the leader of this gang and made to do errands for him as he was financially struggling at home. With a sick mother and two younger siblings to take care of, Hayato had to give up his own dream of dancing to take care of his family. One time, a former dance crew member asked him to arrange a meeting between Reina and this ‘senpai’ of his, who was a big fan of hers, and he would get paid for it. When he brought Reina to the meeting point, it turned out to be kidnapping situation, but Hayato helped Reina escape. Despite being jealous of her as she was able to do what she loved to do while he couldn’t continue dancing, he didn’t mean for her to get actually hurt like that. In any case, to make up for that, the Berumuzu leader asked him to get him a video of Reina, and he did it, but he’s too scared to expose the gang because they would hurt his family if he told on them. The day ends in a heartful talk between Hayato and his best friend Ishikura Kota (Sakumoto Takara), urging him to confide in his friends when he’s struggling as he always has people around him who will help and support him.
While this was going on during days 2, 3 and 4, the Mind Voice users started getting excited and turned Hiiragi into a criminal online based on the leaked information about the increasing murder victims.
From here on, Hiiragi’s health starts deteriorating fast and he starts passing out more frequently. While he’s unconscious, the other students, now convinced their classmates are still alive, start searching for them, but when they find them, the six students refuse to even leave the school anymore as they are now in the loop of Hiiragi’s intentions. Another student, Aizawa Hiroki (Hagiwara Riku) turns out to have been acting as a spy for Hiiragi, as he was instructed to secretly post updates about what was happening inside on Mind Voice to stir up the public. Hiroki was making a documentary about Reina while she was still alive, and Hiiragi asked him to assist him in the whole plan and use all the footage he’d shot so far. Hiroki was the only one who knew about the hostage plan in advance. During a conflict between the students whether they should or shouldn’t stay in the school, it is also revealed that Suwa Yuzuki (Imada Mio) was actually dating Berumuzu’s leader. She wanted to become a model, and he became sort of like a sponsor figure to her, enabling her to get certain modelling jobs etc. After learning about her boyfriend’s involvement in Reina’s case, Yuzuki comes clean about this relationship and hands over a pendant belonging to her boyfriend, which contains a USB file with a list of all the fake video requests Berumuzu has received. From that file, they learn that it was one of their teachers that requested the fake video on Reina.
After this information and the fact that Hiiragi didn’t actually kill any of the students is revealed, the Mind Voice users start praising Hiiragi and even call him a hero.
After it’s revealed that one of the teachers is behind the fake video, the students are left to speculate who it could be. Which teacher would do something like this? Here, Minakoshi Suzune (Fukuhara Haruka) speaks up. As a former member of the swimming club, she was allegedly forced to quit by coach Tsuboi (Kamio Yu). It seemed like he didn’t approve of her dating as it interfered with her swimming practice and he quite harshly kicked her off the team. Suzune has always had lingering resentments about this, and is quick to point her finger at Tsuboi for ‘probably doing something similar to Reina’. She asks one girl who managed to keep her cellphone even though they were supposed to hand them all in to take a video of her accusing Mr. Tsuboi and post it on Mind Voice. During the final confrontation of the day, Suzune is cornered as Mr. Tsuboi’s innocence is revealed. Her mom had called him in on the results from a checkup she’d gotten at the hospital. The hospital informed him that Suzune was suffering from a serious heart condition triggered by excessive physical exercise. This is why Tsuboi, although unnecessarily harshly, had to throw her off the team, only because he knew she would be harmed if she continued swimming. As Suzune was not aware of this she immediately regrets making the confession video, only to be relieved when Hiiragi tells her he stopped the other girl from posting the video just in time. He doesn’t let her off easy though, because this is exactly the lesson he means to teach: to think and find true proof before posting something online that could be extremely harmful to someone’s life and reputation.
I personally found this one of the most intense confrontations, when Hiiragi nearly assaulted Suzune and pushed her up against the wall in order to get it through to her what her video could have caused. Even though I get the importance of that lesson, he did really manage to get it across in a very forceful way. Again, I guess it was the only way to make his students become truly aware.
At the end of the day, on Hiiragi’s order, Sagara Takahiko uploads a video on Mind Voice that shows a man guiding a student looking a lot like Reina from the back inside a building on the day she committed suicide. Hiiragi announces to the others outside that he has now cornered the teacher who ordered the fake video, and identifies Takechi Yamato as that teacher.
As soon as Hiiragi reveals that Takechi is the teacher responsible, the Mind Voice users turn their suspicion toward him.
From the moment Takechi is being accused of being the culprit, there are two students who refuse to believe his involvement. These students are Seo Yudai (Mochizuki Ayumu) and Uoyama Hana (Tomita Miu). The reason why they defend him is because they too were benefitting from Takechi’s generosity to recommend them to Gosho University. As two students with limited opportunities, this recommendation means the world to them, as they’re finally being given a chance they otherwise would never get. While Hiiragi urges them to then try and prove Takechi’s innocence by themselves, we get to see how Takechi slowly starts crumbling under the comments that are starting to spread about him. The truth about Fumika’s experience with Takechi is also revealed and Yudai and Hana are forced to come to terms with the fact that despite his ‘benevolence’ towards them, Takechi truly meant no good. They may just as well have become the next victims of his shady recommendation scheme.
Even though Takechi is first under suspicion because of the outfit the person in the video is wearing, as it matches something Takechi has worn on TV before, but at the end of this day, a picture is released that zoomed in on a reflective mirror near the entrance of the building and shows that it’s Takechi coming out of that building.
When this is revealed to be actually Takechi, the Mind Voice users start cornering and attacking Takechi online.
I have to say that I was personally still suspicious, because even though Takechi seemed to be guilty of something at this point, I was still interested why he reacted so confused and why he kept saying that wasn’t him in the video, even though there was now ‘proof’ that it was him. I kept thinking there was still something not totally right. Either that or he had an evil twin.
On the eighth day, while Takechi was becoming more and more paranoid as his confession to ordering the video with Berumuzu was broadcasted online, two students belonging to the video editing club (or something similar) realize something is up with the video. Horibe Runa (Mori Nana) and Nishizaki Soma (Imai Yuki) discover that the video was edited, and are able to peel off the layer that was placed over Takechi’s face – revealing it to be actually Hiiragi himself.
In a flasback, it is revealed that Runa and Soma had previously discovered that Reina’s video was fake, that the bottle label – which actually contained regular vitamin supplements – was edited with a label that suggested doping meds. However, Soma urged Runa to keep it quiet and leave it at that as the rumors had already run their course. Truthfully, Soma was actually the person who contributed to the spreading of the doping rumors on Mind Voice. Publicizing that it was fake would just harm his own credibility. However, now both of them felt equally bad about not stopping the rumors or revealing that the video was fake before and are determined to not make the same mistake again after realizing the true repercussions. Runa stops Soma before he posts the video revealing Hiiragi to be the true culprit and this is when the whole class finally starts doing what Hiiragi had wanted all along: they start discussing the whole thing together, they think together critically and carefully, and use their imagination to come to a conclusion on what to do. At the end of the day, Hiiragi is cornered by Detective Gunji, but is surprisingly saved by his former suit actor collegue, who actually dressed up as the superhero character Garm Phoenix to save Hiiragi and help him to now take Gunji as his hostage.
In the meantime, the Mind Voice users are still relentlessly criticizing Takechi online despite there being no real evidence.
Even though the students decided not to post the fake video, Sagara Takahiko does. The video revealing it’s Hiiragi, not Takechi, coming out of the building spreads on Mind Voice and guides everyone into a new direction. At the end of this day, Hiiragi reveals all his main objectives to his students and promises to set them free the next day. He needed to make himself the enemy of the nation before he could step out to reveal himself to his main audience: Mind Voice.
As soon as they see it’s Hiiragi in the video instead of Takechi, the Mind Voice users immediately switch their target to him again and resume attacking Hiiragi online.
During the night of March 9, Hiiragi tells his entire story to Gunji, and the next morning he goes up to the roof to finally confront the true culprit: the Mind Voice users. He reveals that the video in which he appears was, in fact, also a fake video that he made and he used this as yet another example to tell the Mind Voice users that they go along so easily with unreliable information. He gives an overview of all the tricks he used to sway them throughout those ten days (I mentioned these observations in bold in the above paragraphs) and urges them to realize how many times in the past few days they actually changed their opinions. Just by relying on unreliable information, how many cruel things have they posted, how many people have they insulted? The whole reason he started this incident was because he wanted to bring to light this brainless behavior of the people online.
While he’s giving his speech, with the help of Gunji the students manage to break their way out of the bombarded obstruction in their hallway and make it just in time to save Hiiragi when he nearly throws himself off the school roof. This final action of his is partly to show Sakura that she needs to let go of her guilt. In fact, Sakura was there when Reina jumped off the building. She witnessed for herself how Reina couldn’t take it anymore but she grabbed her hand when her friend jumped. She grabbed her hand, but Reina urged her to let go. Sakura didn’t want to let go, but after it happened she made herself believe that she let go of Reina’s hand because she truly believed it would put her friend at ease. Anyways, by doing the same thing with Hiiragi, grabbing his hand after he’d jumped, and getting help from her classmates in pulling him back up, Hiiragi convinces her that she was never at fault for anything, as she truly wanted both Reina and him to live. Hiiragi is consequently arrested and the students are finally able to get out of the school.

A few years later, Class 3-A has a reunion in their old classroom to watch the documentary about Reina that Hiroki finished. It is revealed that by then, Hiiragi has already passed away, despite making it through one more year before succumbing to his cancer.

I think I was able to go through all major events, because there was so much happening in just those 10 episodes. I haven’t even gotten to all the stuff that was happening in the police department, but I think these were the most important things. The one final thing I want to mention was that Hiiragi had not been planning this whole event alone. I mentioned he’d gotten help from Sagara Takahiko before, and that Hiroki was also an insider to the plan, but Hiiragi also had help from an insider at the police station, Officer Igarashi Toru (played by Otomo Kohei). Igarashi is revealed to be Fumika’s biological father, even though she herself doesn’t know that because Sagara Takahiko has always cared for her and raised her as his own daughter. In any case, he agrees to help out with the plan after Hiiragi emphasizes that this is not simply a revenge action against Takechi – it’s to make sure something like this never happens again.

So all in all, yeah, a lot happens. There’s a lot of intense events and collisions between students in the classroom, as well as many funny and heartwarming moments. I personally lived for Hana’s infatuation with Sunaga Ken (Furukawa Tsuyoshi) and the bonds that were formed between all the students. As said before, even though several students were highlighted throughout the assignments, every single student had a distinct role and personality. Everyone was mentioned by name at least once and it was very clear who stood by who, who was friends with whom, this was given value at any given moment. I’m talking about simple things like the Kaito fangirls sticking up for him, students running to their friends after finding them safe and alive and how there were regular romantic tensions as well, and also at least one couple. It was really well-structured and it was also very clear how every single student changed from episode 1 to 10. I genuinely feel like I have to watch the whole thing again after finishing it, to see even more clearly what Hiiragi was doing from the start. But comparing how negligent and careless the students’ way of thinking was in the beginning to the final episodes when they finally truly understood what Hiiragi was trying to teach them, that in itself was already a really powerful message. Hiiragi managed to open the minds of 29 people within 10 days, and all he wanted was for the Mind Voice users to come to their senses in less time. If only it worked like that.
But I really liked the ending. Even though, as Sakura also points out during that reunion, nothing has really changed in society, and nothing has really changed on Mind Voice, we are shown one single person, someone who had been appearing as a Mind Voice user several times before, excitedly adding to the harsh comments. We see that, under the narration of Sakura wishing that Hiiragi’s message may have at least reached one single person, this person changes his mind. We see him typing out a hate comment on Mind Voice but then deciding not to post it. And I think that was a very powerful way to end the series, because it just concluded Hiiragi’s objective. He did manage to at least reach one person with his message. And you know what they say, it all starts with a single lit candle.

So besides all the drama that happened within the classroom itself and the police office, we also see how the other teachers are coping with the situation. In the beginning, I wasn’t really sure what to think as Takechi’s behavior was so ridiculous. From the start I didn’t fully trust him as he was the first person to avert his gaze and smile to himself while muttering ‘This is starting to look interesting’ when the whole hostage thing just started. He immediately jumped on the opportunity to promote himself as being the most representative teacher of this age, which was on the one hand amusing but on the other hand it really made me go, ‘Is this guy for real?’ Like, it was crazy how an opportunist would arise in this situation, especially when word got around that Hiiragi was actually killing the students. But in the end, it did explain a part of his character. He was conspiring with the principal of Gosho University to get as many recommended students as possible, but most of his recommended students would quit after a year or so because they couldn’t take it. When people started finding out about his connections and openly obstructed him from gaining more recommendations, he started conspiring with Berumuzu, asking them to help him corner certain people for going against him. He was living his life entirely on his own terms, treating students as mere commodities. As long as he could get money out of recommending students, he didn’t care if they actually made it or not and for that he definitely deserved to be locked up. The other teachers, despite not being very useful in the whole solving of the case at all, are positioned to be the spectators that exist outside of Mind Voice. Even though Mind Voice is everywhere and it’s being used as the main outlet of information from the classroom, the other teachers have more practical things to deal with, such as the students’ parents and they also have to cooperate with the police when they’re there. There are a few moments when they are involved in the assignments, and in the assignment of figuring out which teacher requested the video of Reina, they are also highlighted, especially Mr. Tsuboi. Even though the teachers mostly attributed to the more comical side of the show, it was definitely expressed that they cared sincerely about the school and the students. The principal showed great compassion to Takechi, even after discovering what he’d done, and he also helped Suzune realize that Mr. Tsuboi had always been thinking about her wellbeing. Honestly, all the characters were highlighted in their own way without it becoming too much, and that was a really strong aspect of this show.

If people only knew what was really going on. That was one of Hiiragi’s main arguments. If only people had known about what was fake and what wasn’t. Despite not blaming his students personally or directly for Reina’s death, it wasn’t strange that Hiiragi felt the need to be forceful with them, as they really did need to be taught a lesson, and this was the only way to make them fully realize what they had done and what they should have done. Sure, his approaches were very intense and I still don’t fully see the need of him pretending to kill people in order to get their attention, but it also proved how desperate he was in gaining the attention that was needed to face this problem head-on. His harsh lessons every single day were what was needed for the students, for ALL students, to fully realize what kind of consequences their mindless words and actions could have on the people around them.

Before going on to my cast comments, I want to briefly talk about the special, which I watched right after the main show. I just wasn’t ready to say goodbye to the characters yet, that’s how much impact this show had on me. The special is called ‘Class 3-A: From now on, this is everyone’s special graduation ceremony’ (3年A組: 今から皆さんだけの、卒業式です/3 Nen A Gumi: Ima kara minasan dake no, Sotsugyoshiki desu). It takes place on March 10, right after Hiiragi has been taken away by the police. The students are all back in the classroom and Hiroki suddenly discovers a video file on Hiiragi’s laptop that remained after all the other files were deleted. It’s called ‘Graduation Ceremony’ and it’s a video that Hiiragi recorded somewhere during the past ten days. Through the video, he orders Hiroki to take out the box of graduation certificates under his desk and he orders Sakura to go to the art room to start preparing some things. Then, he starts calling out all students’ names one by one, in alphabetical order, to comment on their personality during the past ten days and to ask them to tell him their dreams for the future.
In-between, they move to the art room which Sakura has been instructed to decorate just so that it seems like an actual graduation ceremony and they also find drawings that Hiiragi has made of each and every one of them, every single student’s smiling portrait.
Can I just say that I nearly bawled my eyes out during this special? It’s only two episodes, but the way every single student is given one last moment in the spotlight, one last chance to remark on their experiences and to voice their ambitions for the future was just so wonderful. It really highlighted how much attention Hiiragi had paid to each single student during those ten days, in-between all the dramatic events. He remarked something about every single person’s character and behavior and it was immensely emotional.
Despite it being a special, and while I believe that some people may have chosen not to watch it, it really felt like an important point of closure to the whole series, because graduation was something that it had all led up to. In any case, I’m very glad I watched it, because it just made me love every single student more, even the people who hadn’t been featured that much before. I thought it just showed so much respect to each actor, as well, it give them all equality and didn’t make one character seem more important than the other.

Okay, so let’s move on to the cast comments now! For the students, I’m not going to mention every single one of them but just some that jumped out to me in particular. That’s not to say that they all performed really well! I was very impressed with the overall acting skills in this drama, it never once became annoying for me.

If Suda Masaki was one of the main reasons why I started this show, he definitely proved me right. This man is PHENOMENAL. I’ve loved him in every single thing I’ve seen him in (and he is in a LOT of things), but here he really blew me away. Things I’ve seen him in include Rich Man Poor Woman, Shinigami-kun, Mondai no Aru Restaurant, Tamiou, Love Song, Jimi ni Sugoi! and Todome no Kiss. His versatility, his acting range is almost scary good. Because even when he legit freaked me the heck out a couple of times, I never stopped smiling behind my screen because I was enjoying his acting so much. The most amazing thing, and I’d really have to rewatch this show to make sure of that, was that he was so good at hiding Hiiragi’s true feelings. For example, at certain moments his eyes would shoot fire, while later it’d be revealed that in those moments he felt really bad for scaring his students so much. And the look in his eyes when he saw Fumika as soon as he came out of the school building, the way he looked at her truly broke my heart. Struggling to see his plan through to the end while simultaneously gradually succumbing to his disease made him so fanatic, so desperate, and he may have come across as a crazy person at times, but this was the first time we actually saw him look into the eyes of someone he loved so much. Seriously, his performance gave me goosebumps. Suda Masaki is incredible and he proved that one more time in this show.

I’ve seen Nagano Mei before in Itsuka Kono Koi wo Omoidashite Kitto Naiteshimau and Koe Koi. She looked really familiar to me, although it’s been too long since I watched these shows for me to really remember her performance there. Anyways, as she was the only student being featured in the poster I kind of assumed from the start that she would be a prominent character, maybe even the person that it all came down to. Much to my surprise, her involvement was already dealt with in the first episode, and from then on she just remained the most loyal student to Hiiragi, as she was convinced of his good intentions. She was also the only one to see through his facade during one assignment. At the beginning of the day he had said that they would play a game called ‘Believe it or Don’t Believe it’, and had explained that whenever he had his glasses on, he was speaking the truth, and when he had them off, he was lying. After going through a whole dramatic episode which left everyone completely distraught, she was the only one who remarked that he’d done exactly as he’d announced: he’d spoken the truth when he was wearing his glasses, and he’d lied when he wasn’t wearing them. The rest of the class just forgot about the game as Hiiragi’s acting was so believable, but because Sakura kept this in mind, she was able to see the truth in his behavior. I’d imagined Sakura to maybe be one of the influential or popular girls in class, but she was actually kind of an underdog. Until she became friends with Reina, even though she wasn’t bullied or anything, she seemed kind of a loner, also with her fascination with pro-wrestling and stuff that usually put people off. I thought it was really interesting how Sakura’s character gradually developed throughout the ten days. Her character also makes me want to watch the whole thing all over again, as I want to pay more attention to her behavior after understanding all that she’s been through. She was always soft spoken and introvert, but she never became a pushover and she never became annoying or anything like that. I think she performed really well.

I really thought I recognized Katayose Ryota from something, but it turns out that I don’t. I guess he just looks like someone then? He hasn’t even done that many dramas yet, according to DramaWiki. Also, he’s a member of J-Pop group which… I can’t say I’m surprised. Kai (I’ve been calling him Hayato during my review so as not to break the consistency of addressing everyone by their first name, but he’s mainly called ‘Kai’ in the show) first seemed to be this typical delinquent student, chilling in the back of the class with his buddies, goofing around. It’s mentioned in the first episode that he’d once gotten involved with the police before. At the time it just seemed like a remark to emphasize his reputation at school but later of course we find out it’s because he got involved in that almost-kidnapping case in which he saved Reina. I loved how there were all these tiny references and foreshadowing elements before you even knew that it would come back to be properly explained. Anyways, Kai was definitely a good guy. It didn’t take him very long to acknowledge the seriousness of what Hiiragi was doing and he just went along with it at some point. Also when he immediately confessed to being the person who came with the idea of making the video about Reina, he must have been so done with another excruciating day of discussions, poor guy. But I think it was a very major element for his character development that he was confronted with the fact that his buddies really wanted him to rely on them. All in all, I loved the fact that there were so many guys crying in this show, it gave me hope for humanity. Kai really learned his lesson and even though it definitely softened him, it still didn’t change who he was and I think it’s really great that he kept that consistency in his acting performance.

I need to mention Tomita Miu because I’ve analyzed her performance before in Switched. She was one of the few actresses that I’d seen in a drama before. I LOVED Hana. She was such a funny, lovable and relatable character and I was so happy that for once, there wasn’t ever a single mention of her being ‘bigger’. Honestly, in Asian dramas, when someone is ‘bigger’, it’s always pointed out at some point. But in Hana’s case, that was not important. She also wasn’t an underdog, she wasn’t bullied, she had enough friends and was liked by everyone. It was a very big contrast to her original character in Switched, and I really loved seeing this side of her. As I mentioned before, her infatuation with Sunaga threw me every single time, and also how they ended up together and during the reunion it was revealed that she’d confessed 12 times before he finally caved. I really loved her character and think she also got more than enough opportunity to show different sides to her acting. Go Tomita Miu!

I didn’t know Kamishiraishi Moka, but what I found so interesting in this show was that, even though all her scenes were flashbacks, it still felt like she was there. She was still a part of the class, her empty desk an eternal reminder of that. She still very much felt like an active part of the show, even during the hostage situation when she wasn’t even physically there.
I couldn’t help but feel that Reina was really lonely. Everyone at school looked at her as some sort of perfect human being, and when she tried to make friends with someone they’d also put her on a pedestal. I think Karen and Kakeru might have been the only people that didn’t act like that, especially Kakeru, who really liked her for who she was and not for her skills and reputation at school and swimming. It was painful to see how she kept being let down by her friends, she really just wanted a genuine friend who liked her for who she was and didn’t have so many expectations of her based on her reputation. She knew herself that she wasn’t a perfect and strong person, and she wanted people to acknowledge that. It was heartbreaking to see her break free of Sakura’s grasp as she was trying to save her – she had really reached her limit. On the other hand, although she was hurt by her classmates, she never truly blamed anyone for what happened to her. Heck, she even blamed herself for neglecting Kaho and writing to Sakura that they shouldn’t be friends anymore. It was scary that so many shady people had their marks on her, too. Like, that gang that just came to seek her out and beat up Kakeru just because they thought he was her boyfriend? She really became a victim of something beyond her power, even involving a gang leader that she didn’t even know of. I think it was really powerful when Hiiragi urged his students to understand that what happened to Reina could have happened to any one of them.

I’ve only seen Imada Mio before in Hana Nochi Hare, that’s probably why she seemed familiar to me. I liked Yuzuki’s character because she wasn’t a stereotypical kind of female character. On the one hand, I believe she was considered to be quite popular, she had many friends and she was aiming to become a model. On the other hand, she was also someone you shouldn’t mess with. She spoke up against the guys many times, not scared of anything. This was only confirmed after the revelation that she was actually dating Berumuzu’s leader, but she was still brave enough to sell him out, because she saw that it was not right what was done to Reina. Even though she didn’t even specifically like Reina, she wouldn’t wish that upon her and that made her a very humane character. I loved the scene where Hiiragi told her that she didn’t do anything wrong. I thought her character made a real impact in this show, as it didn’t just make her the scary popular girl, but you could also see her bonding with her friends throughout the whole thing.

The thing is, up until now I’ve always had a bit of an aversion against Fukuhara Haruka. I only know her from Good Morning Call but she kind of annoyed me there, to be honest. I think it’s mostly her voice and the fact that I can always see that she’s acting. Of course they’re all acting, but she just has it plasted on her a bit more obviously. And in the beginning, I also felt that from her in this show. She was initially highlighted because she was part of a couple and her boyfriend was the first person to get ‘killed’ by Hiiragi, but after they were reunited and her whole issue with Tsuboi came along, I’ve come to change my mind about her a bit. The confrontation part, where she’s literally pushed against the wall while Hiiragi was screaming at her and she just stood there and cried, her silent acting was really good. Probably better than any of her dialogue parts. (I found a great picture of this scene on MyDramaList, so I’ll just add it for reference.) It was the first time I saw her so genuinely expressing emotion without adding something extra to it. I found it interesting to see her as part of this show as I’d taken her for more of a typical romantic comedy actress, but that in itself was enough to make her stand out. In the end, I have to say I saw a new side of her and it has made me realize that she might be a better actress than I initially gathered.

Finally, I just want to give a shoutout to a couple more students that were mostly side characters but still really touched me in a way. First, Mori Nana, who played Runa. She really hadn’t been featured as much before, but when the episode came with her and Soma in which they revealed that the video was fake, her acting was so realistic I almost forgot it was acting. It really felt like how someone in this situation would actually talk and express her emotions, as if it wasn’t scripted, so that was amazing.
And then there was Sakumoto Takara, who played Kota, Kai’s closest friend who felt so hurt when he found out his friend had been carrying all those burdens by himself and who just came to hug him after his whole involvement with the gang was revealed. That was true friendship right there, and I remember just feeling so grateful that this series allowed such sincere expressions of emotions and feelings between men without it becoming something ‘soft or feminine’. And I just generally really liked Kota’s vibe, and also how he kept trying to get with Runa and she kept brushing him off, lol. My guy was just going for it.
Finally, I want to give one final shoutout to my boy Fuwa Kodai who was a sobbing mess throughout the whole show. Seriously, in every scene he was crying and also during the graduation special. I just wanted to give him a big hug.
Here’s to crying men/men showing emotion in Asian dramas!! I’m all here for it!

I don’t think I’ve seen Shiina Kippei in anything before, but I liked that they made him so sympathetic to the case. He was really handling from personal feelings, he’d lost a promising student and decided to become a police officer to stop these things from happening again. I think that he, if he’d also been in the loop of Hiiragi’s plan, would’ve agreed to help him out as well. He may have looked like any grumpy old man, but he definitely had his heart in the right place and I liked that after hearing Hiiragi out, he just went to help the students get through the obstruction. He was a nice and dependable character and I wish he could’ve stayed on the case through the end (he was taken off it at some point, I believe after they gave the wrong answer to an assignment).

Otomo Kohei also looked familiar to me, but I’ve also not seen anything with him before. It was a nice surprise that Igarashi was Hiiragi’s accomplice, and he managed to keep it up for quite some time (I didn’t like the guy who replaced him, lol). It was also funny that they made him to be Fumika’s biological father, but I wonder if that was just to give him a reason to work along with the plan, otherwise they would’ve had to make up a different reason why Sagara Takahiko would’ve known him. Anyways, it was good as long as he stood behind Hiiragi’s intentions. I think he was a nice character as well.

I’ve seen Tanabe Seiichi in several things before, he also has a very familiar face. I know him from Kimi ha Petto, 11-nin mo Iru!, Higashino Keigo Mysteries, Dear Sister and Boku, Unmei no Hito desu. I feel like he always plays sympathetic characters, so it was funny to see him as a two-faced character for a change. Someone who would smile and honestly not admit to doing anything wrong while he was literally commiting a crime. It gave a new layer to him as an actor, in my opinion, it was interesting to see. I’m glad that even though it seemed so unlikely that he would realize his own mistake, he did come to Fumika in the end to apologize, and with that one of Hiiragi’s objectives was concluded, at least, to make Takechi realize the crime he’d committed.

I realize now that I’ve seen Tsuchimura Kaho before in Koi ga Heta demo Ikitemasu, and I remember watching this but it’s also as if I unlocked a new memory, lol. Anyways, Fumika looked familiar. I was really wondering what had happened to her, and it was funny how in the beginning we as the viewers were also being led to believe different things, because in the beginning it really felt as if Hiiragi himself had been some sort of crazy abusive boyfriend or something. Even her father initially told the police that Hiiragi was a terrible person. In the end, that was all part of the plan, of course, because Hiiragi needed to be made into an enemy in order to get the whole nation’s attention. Anyways, I liked that Fumika wasn’t just written to be a helpless woman stuck at home, she really wanted to help however she could, but her father wouldn’t let her talk to the police. She managed to get away relatively unscathed as in, she didn’t have to lose her life, but you could still see how much it scarred her nonetheless. You may not see it on someone from the outside, but sometimes wounds of the mind are even more serious than physical wounds. Physical wounds can heal with some time and ointment, but there’s no bandaid to paste on such an untouchable thing as the mind.

I’ve seen Yajima Kenichi in Sunao ni Narenakute and Tantei no Tantei, so that’s probably what I recognize him from. I found his character really enigmatic, for some reason. I guess it’s just because he also held his true feelings about the case a secret at first. He had been an accomplice from the start, he supported Hiiragi fully but he also wanted to keep his daughter out of it by telling the police he had nothing to do with Hiiragi. He was a good ally to have, he ended up posting several important videos to Mind Voice on the instruction of Hiiragi himself. From that point on, when it was all revealed to be part of a bigger plan in which multiple people were involved, I became really intrigued of how it would be concluded. I also found him a really good fit for the director of superhero franchise, I don’t know why but his face looks like he could be character in one of those things himself, haha.

Okay, so now that I’ve concluded my cast comments, let me just conclude my thoughts. As I’ve already mentioned several times before, I thought this show was really good all in all. I was intrigued from the start and the deeper it went, the better it got. I love how they still managed to keep it light in-between the tense parts, because those bits for me were a constant reminder of that everything would be okay in the end, that Hiiragi wasn’t going to really harm anyone, and that everything would play out fine. Also, it made it more enjoyable rather than keeping it angsty and intense from beginning to end. The balance of light and heavy was what kept me on the edge of my seat. I remember that part when all the students kind of let their guard down after realizing they weren’t in any actual danger and they got their phones back etc, but then Hiiragi still announced to the police that he would kill 10 students if they got the assignment wrong and it was like, ‘…wait, we’ve established that he’s kidding, right?’ Hiiragi was just so unpredictable. Even when it would feel safe one moment, he could still snap or lash out the next and that really kept everyone on their toes.
The structure was really good, and it also had some surprising elements in it. For example, when an episode suddenly started from Takechi’s perspective, or when episode 9 suddenly started with the reunion a year later, even though we were still in the middle of the hostage situation. I thought those were interesting choices, but the dots were always connected by the end of the episode or the next one. I liked how small references and foreshadowings were made to trivial things that would only start making sense later – like, the fact that they thought all these tiny details out and came back to explain them later was really clever writing.
I liked that every single character was highlighted, among the students I really felt like no one was less than the other. I’ve never seen a high school setting drama in which every single student was given a proper character and position within the class, not just as filler characters. I think that was a really original and challenging setup, to really create a class of 29 students who all had to get their moment of redemption in one way or another. There was a really good balance of character types, from loud to more quiet students, from fighters to observers. Hiiragi treated every single student equally, no matter whether it was a boy or a girl, he treated them like people, and this was sometimes really merciless but otherwise it really felt like he saw them as the proper human beings that they would turn out to be after truly understanding his lesson. The graduation special just felt like a cherry on top of the cake that was the main show.
I was really impressed, I had not expected such a deeply layered show with such a powerful message at the end. And I also appreciate how it didn’t idealize anything at the end, after everything was concluded. The truth is that no matter who preaches this, and we all know it’s true, it will probably never change. People will always keep hiding behind their screens, they will always keep commenting hateful things without thinking twice about it or feel any guilt towards the person they’re targeting. So I find it promising enough when it manages to reach at least one person. It all starts with one person.

So yeah, I stand behind my ranking of this series, it just got better and better and it really has been one of the best shows I’ve watched in a while, especially within this year. I would recommend it very much. It has a great balance of psychological drama and comedy, it fits right into my alley. And I’m definitely keeping an eye out for more Suda Masaki dramas because this guy is a flipping genius.

So now I’m going back to something lighter again, there’s a limit to how much psychological heavy stuff I can handle in a row, haha. Anyways, I hope I was able to make this another worthwhile review and I’ll try to finish a couple more reviews before the end of the year. In the meantime, let’s not forget to take with us the message that 3-A provided us with.
Let’s keep thinking clearly and critically, let’s use our imagination and not let ourselves be swept away with the Mind(less) Voice(s), both online and in our heads. Whenever we come across a situation that seems off, let’s not judge too quickly.
“Let’s Think!” 😉






The Sound of Magic

Standard

Disclaimer: this is a review, and as such it contains spoilers of the whole series. Please proceed to read at your own risk if you still plan on watching this show or if you haven’t finished it yet. You have been warned.

The Sound of Magic
(안나라수마나라 / Annara Sumanara)
MyDramaList rating: 7.0/10

Hello everyone! It’s getting colder, the festive holidays are approaching and this is the time of year that I always long for some warmth and wonder. Which made this series the ideal choice for an end-of-year show! My main reason for moving this one up on my list was because I really wanted to start watching Actor’s Meet, and this was the only one I hadn’t seen yet. Still, it definitely surprised me in many ways. I didn’t really know what to expect of it, apart that it was about magic, but the story itself turned out to have a much deeper theme and message than I’d anticipated. I’m excited to share my thoughts about this one. I actually forced myself to wait with finishing it – if I hadn’t I would’ve finished it in two days, probably. I thought I needed to take my time with it and not rush through it, as it deserved to be waited for.
Again, I don’t expect this to be a really long review as the show itself is so short. Overall, I liked it, especially when the darker themes came to light, but there’s also a couple of things I wish to point out which I thought could’ve been explained better or that I would’ve liked to get a clearer answer to. So let’s get to it, or should I first ask: “Do you… believe in magic?”

The Sound of Magic is a 6-episode Netflix K-Drama with each episode lasting about 1 hour and 10 minutes. In my experience, each episode felt like a short movie. The main story is about Yoon Ah Yi (played by Choi Sung Eun), a high school student with a very miserable life. She was forced to become an adult way too soon, as not only did her mother abandon her at a young age, but her father also left her and her younger sister to fend for themselves after he got himself into heaps of debt. Ah Yi now has to take care of herself and her younger sister Yoo Yi (played by Hong Jung Min). She has to take care of all the finances while she’s simultaneously trying to perform well at school. She has several part-time jobs, but of course none of those pay enough. At the moment the series starts, she has no idea where her father is as he barely contacts his children, and she’s trying to figure out her life as she goes, getting more and more exhausted every day. As a result, she also starts neglecting her appearance and this makes her an easy target at school for bullies who make fun of her obsession with money. It just seems like she’s a minority in all aspects, she doesn’t come from a wealthy background, even if she performs well in school she’ll always be pushed aside for students from better off families, she has to scrape the money from her part-time jobs together to even buy a bag of rice and a new set of stockings. Nothing seems to be going her way and it’s exhausting.
That is, until she meets a mysterious man at the abandoned theme park in town, who claims to be a real magician (Ji Chang Wook). There have been rumors going around at Ah Yi’s school about this ‘crazy’ magician, but no one had ever seen him in person. Ah Yi is initially very wary of him, as she’s wary of adults in general after being constantly let down by them. But the magician keeps appearing and even helps her out a few times. When her boss from the convenience store suddenly becomes touchy, he makes him disappear. When loan sharks come to her house to push her to pay back her father’s debts, he makes them go away. As she starts spending more time with him after school and even starts taking magic lessons from him, Ah Yi finds that even though his magic can’t take her sorrows or actual problems away, it does help her rediscover the joys that she hasn’t had the luxury of experiencing as a kid. It doesn’t even occur to her how suspicious it may look to others, or the fact that she doesn’t know anything about this man, not even his real name. When suspicious things start happening around Ah Yi’s neighborhood and the magician becomes a suspect for being involved with several muggings and the disappearance of one of Ah Yi’s classmates, the question of who this man actually is becomes more pressing. Ah Yi seems to be the only one who believes he’s a good person, but on the other hand she still doesn’t even know who he is, so it’s not very convincing to the police either.
Besides Ah Yi, there’s also her classmate Na Il Deung (played by Hwang In Yeop), a boy who always ranks 1st place in class except for math, as Ah Yi always manages to beat him in that. His interest in her starts out of curiosity of how she always ranks 1st in math, but it doesn’t take long for him to develop feelings for her, even though he tries to suppress them very much. Il Deung comes from a wealthy family and his parents have been pressing him since childhood to be the best in everything so he’s always been walking that road they laid out for him without question. But when he meets Ah Yi and discovers her relationship with this strange magician, he also starts getting involved in their meetings and the magician even manages to open Il Deung’s eyes to the reality of his own situation. When the truth about the magician comes to light and there seems to be even more reason to doubt his sanity, Ah Yi and Il Deung are the only ones willing to stand up for him.

I’ll start by saying that the originality of this show already gives it bonus points for me. It’s not a regular K-Drama at all, heck, it’s part musical! I believe I did hear somewhere before that there were songs in it but I must have forgotten because the minute they started singing in the 1st episode (which was like, 1 minute into the show), I immediately found myself pressing pause because ‘what the heck was happening’. It still came as a surprise. I have to admit throughout the series I still couldn’t get completely used to the fact they’d just start singing, it just felt so weird in a K-Drama! I did think it gave a nice additional layer to the fictional aspect of it, as the whole point was to make Ah Yi escape from her daily struggles for a moment, and I also believe the whole sequences that played out during the songs might not have actually happened (such as the flying merry-go-round horses etc.), but as the darker themes came to light later on it became harder for me to distinguish what was ‘real’ and what wasn’t. As in, what part of the magic that he showed her was real and what wasn’t. Especially after we find out that he didn’t actually make the store owner disappear but just pushed him over a railing, for example. He did make it snow and lit fireworks with a snap of his fingers, and also those blue sparkly butterflies… All these things were visible to everyone, not just Ah Yi and Il Deung, so that really made me wonder if he was really a magician or if these things happened by coincidence (doesn’t seem so) or if it was really only about opening people’s eyes to miracles, if not actual magic, just to make them feel better or restore a feeling that they should’ve gotten to explore more as kids.

It was interesting from the start to see the dynamic between Ri Eul (as he eventually introduces himself) and Ah Yi. Ah Yi is a kid who was forced to become an adult too soon, and Ri Eul is an adult who seems unable to let go of being a kid.

Let me go into a bit more depth in regard to the main characters.
Ah Yi is the kind of character that you just can’t help but feel for. She really has it tough and she really can’t catch a break. It’s like a domino of misfortune, Murphy’s Law, whatever you want to call it. Especially the fact that she doesn’t get any kind of support and doesn’t have any adults around her that she can lean on. She’s a teenager, but she can’t even afford the luxury to go to school and study and meet up with friends without worry. She’s constantly worrying about money, to the point of actually resorting to crawling through the dust for it. She even ends up accepting a deal with Il Deung to perform poorly on her math test just because he pays her for it. It was so sad to watch her resort to all these low ways of getting her hands on more money, but on the other hand – what choice did she have? There was no one who would help her, no one who even reached out to her out of the goodness of their heart. The convenience store owner starts out being super supportive and nice to her and then suddenly transforms into a monster when she asks him for an advance payment after her dad bails on her again. When she gets into trouble for making that deal with Il Deung about him paying her to flunk her test and she tells the teachers the truth about her situation, they twist it into making Il Deung the hero for being so generous with her. The moment she realizes that her obstacle in life isn’t money but immature grown-ups, it’s like something falls off her and I believe that’s also the moment that she starts opening up to Ri Eul more. At least he is an adult that allows her to be a kid and tells her it’s alright to do whatever she wants without worrying too much about what kind of adult she herself will become.
I really loved the part where she told him she wanted to meet her future self just to be ensured that she would turn out alright, and Ri Eul let her meet her younger self, so that her younger self could be assured. Even though I still don’t understand completely whether this was actual time travel magic or that it was just him somehow enabling her to come to terms with the doubts she’d had since she was a child, I found it a really beautiful scene. It was also really beautiful when she talked about how she never even felt like she had the luxury of waiting for Santa atChristmas since he never came to her, and how Ri Eul made her feel like she now finally got a kind of ‘Santa’ for herself too.
I liked that in the end, it was really about Ah Yi figuring out her path, it was about her finding her place in a society where she didn’t seem to fit in, and the focus wasn’t for example on her and Il Deung ending up together. It really was about Ah Yi’s journey to turn into a real responsible adult, not the version she was forced into. She ends up becoming the kind of adult she wants to become, one that can contribute to the imagination of children and encourage them to believe in magic/miracles while they still can.
Her struggle with society and how she feels like she can’t depend on any of the adults around her, her lack of a specific adult as a role model, even in regard to her own father, hits really hard. I can’t say I personally relate to every aspect of her struggles, but the part about not fitting in, feeling like you don’t really have a solid support system and just dream about things getting better without actually knowing how to get there, that I can very well understand. Ah Yi is in a terrifying position, she really has to find a solution all by herself and she also has her younger sister to take care of, who very much depends on her. Yoo Yi is the sole light in Ah Yi’s life, and Ah Yi never once thinks of her as a burden. She does very much blame their father for not taking responsibility for Yoo Yi, though. Yoo Yi is the reason she keeps going even though she is both physically and mentally exhausted. I think the bond between the two sisters was really beautiful, also because Yoo Yi, despite being able to really help her older sister with anything, never loses faith in her. I feel like Yoo Yi is more mature than her age and that she is definitely onto at least part of the situation, but she never pressures Ah Yi and she never makes anything harder than it already is. She also takes the responsibility to refrain from participating in certain school activities, for example, for the sake of saving money. She knows it’s not easy on her sister and wants to help her as much as she can, although Ah Yi tries as much as she can to still enable her sister at least to enjoy whatever activities she wants to participate in.
Honestly, that part where their dad (Jo Han Chul) suddenly shows up and then runs away with literally ALL the money that Ah Yi had saved up, even the money she was planning to return to Il Deung, that was awful. How could he be such a coward! And then he just called her from a pay phone to make a lame excuse like ‘sorry I’m such a bad father’. Seriously, if you’re already aware of it, if you already know exactly what you’re putting your kids through and how you’re making them suffer, why make it even harder for them by stealing what they barely scraped together?! That doesn’t make you any better than the crap adults they already have to deal with, such as those loan sharks. And it’s not like that’s going to solve any of your debt problems, either! That made me so mad. I’m glad that they manage to make up in the end and that he gets a job and starts visiting them every weekend, but in the beginning I really couldn’t not believe how much of a coward he was.
Also, I’m not sure if I just missed this but I don’t exactly understand what happened to their mother. I remember that they showed that she abandoned them and Ah Yi saw her leave, but the way Ah Yi was leaving messages to her mom made it seem like her mother had passed away. Or maybe that’s just how Ah Yi learned to accept it and what she made her younger sister believe? I’m not sure whether she actually died or just abandoned them. In her memories with her mom, it’s always just the two of them, so maybe it was before Yoo Yi was born or when she was still very little. In any case, even though it seemed like she was honoring her mother’s memory by leaving messages for her, at the same time it also felt like she still really yearned for her mother to come back home. When Ri Eul tries to comfort her by making all her KakaoTalk messages to her mom appear as ‘Read’ and she flips, he really seems startled that he misinterpreted the situation – he probably just thought that her mother wasn’t replying to her and it would make Ah Yi feel better to see that she was at least reading her messages – I couldn’t really blame him because I was also confused about the whole thing.

Na Il Deung’s story was of a different caliber than Ah Yi’s, but I can’t say which of them had it worse. Even though Il Deung has the support that Ah Yi lacks, ever since he was a child he was stripped completely of his own free will. He has been raised with the idea that he needs to make his parents (mostly his father) proud and his only form of acknowledgement comes from his father praising him, so he never even looks beyond that. As he finds himself getting attracted to Ah Yi, he also keeps trying to push it away or worse, he tries to use his newly established connection with her to get something out of it which will please his family. In a way, he is also still quite immature in the beginning. He is adorable when he manages to get closer to Ah Yi, and it becomes really clear for the viewers that he likes her a lot. Heck, when he blurted out that ‘okay, so that means we’re dating now’ and they both went ‘What?’ ‘What?’, that was hilarious. But then the next day he was all cold again and then suddenly asked her to flunk her math test so he could become #1 again. In my native language we have a saying that literally translates to ‘teasing girls is asking for kisses’. It refers to the typical behavior that young boys portray towards their girl crushes, if he teases her a lot, it means that he actually really likes her. That’s what it felt like to me at some point, all the more because he became blatantly suspicious and jealous of her relationship with Ri Eul and then he just started treating her badly at school as well. When he has his first personal encounter with Ri Eul, the magician shows him a nightmarish vision of how he’s been living his life, from study desk to study desk, exam to exam, trying to keep ahead of all his peers who all try to get to the next stage just as desperately. He sees students fall over and be trampled over by others on their way. All in all I found it a very creepy but also impactful scene (and song). After that, he can’t really get it out of his head and it becomes clear as day to him that he has only been following the ‘asphalt’ path that his parents laid out for him. But no flowers grow on asphalt paths, and that is exactly what he starts yearning for. He gets inspired by how Ah Yi opens up to Ri Eul and even starts learning magic from him, so much so that he starts longing to be in that same ‘field of flowers’ as them. I think the metaphors of the flower field and the asphalt road were really well thought of for Il Deung, because they represented two opposites: the asphalt road that didn’t allow any side tracks or distractions and only led him from desk to desk, and the endless field of flowers which he could run through as far as he wanted without limitations.
I really liked the scene in which Il Deung had his first solo song, when he offered his earphone to Ah Yi while they were studying in the library and then they were in that same flower field together and he was singing to her and playing his guitar. In that scene, he looked so happy and free of worry, he doesn’t appear like that in any other moment of the show. I think it just showed that, even though he’d never considered it before, he completely blossomed when being exposed to the possibility of going off the asphalt path and finding his own way. And the fact that both Ah Yi and Ri Eul keep showing him these possibilities only strengthens him in his tendency to stray from that asphalt path.
I have to say that his parents (played by Yoo Jae Myung and Kim Hye Eun) are really stereotypical examples of parents that didn’t allow their child to do anything but study. His mother literally tells him to his face that he’s not allowed to do ANYTHING except studying, that everything that’s not studying is a waste of time. I just can’t believe those kinds of parents. They claim to love their children and that they want the best for them, but they never even let them be children. They don’t even allow them to play or hang out with friends or develop social skills. Il Deung didn’t seem to have any friends, either inside or outside of school, he was always by himself, just like Ah Yi. I understand that this is a very real situation in many Asian societies, I’ve seen it in a lot of school-setting dramas before that some children are pushed so hard by their parents to study and get so little freedom in doing anything else while that’s equally (or even more) important to their social development. Il Deung was definitely someone who suffered, even though he grew up thinking it was normal as no one had ever confronted him with the reality before. Although he was suspicious of Ri Eul at first, I feel like he did come to respect him in some way, in the end enough to maintain on his side throughout all the suspicions that were raised against him.

And then there’s Ri Eul himself. We’re only given the full truth about him in the final episode, when he’s being pursued by the police for alleged involvement in the disappearance of one of Ah Yi and Il Deung’s classmates.
So when we meet him first through Ah Yi, he really seems like this mystery man who can make your worries disappear. He’s presented initially as an eccentric man who has the answers to everything, although it’s not exactly clear what his intentions are. I’d say Ah Yi was 100% right to be wary of him, although at some point I found myself urging her to just let him help her in whatever way. It just felt like finally someone was offering a legit helping hand and she kept swatting it away, although again, she had every reason to be suspicious after what she’d been through with literally every adult around her.
Ri Eul gets criticized a lot by different people that he’s a weirdo, a crazy person, an adult acting like a kid by hiding in an abandoned theme park like that, having seemingly lost sense of reality. He doesn’t seem to take any of these criticisms to heart, but one thing that he does get sensitive about is when people question his authenticity as a magician. He doesn’t like it when people tell him he’s fake and he loves to prove them wrong. However, throughout the series he does show some suspicious behavior. All in all he seems to have some sort of issue, although it remains vague for some time what exactly is going on with him. At some point I actually started believing that he was bipolar or schizophrenic or something. When a girl from Ah Yi and Il Deung’s class goes missing and Ah Yi asks him about it, he doesn’t really say anything but it feels like he knows something about it, when someone in his exact attire is spotted on several CCTV’s around the place where this girl went missing and after a mugging on an old lady, the police start asking around. Ri Eul never really gives a clear answer regarding whether he has anything to do with it. Or when he does say he has nothing to do with it, it’s still not sincere enough to fully believe it. We see footage of him attacking a guy in the place he stays at in the theme park with a knife, and we see him almost choke one of Ah Yi and Il Deung’s other classmates when she comes snooping (more about her later). It definitely seems like he’s not 100% sane, and that just raises more questions. Who is he really, and how did he end up in that theme park?
As I said before, we only find out about Ri Eul’s real identity and backstory in the final episode, through his former classmate Min Ji Soo (played by Park Ha Na). Ji Soo has appeared several times before, Ah Yi meets her a couple of times when she comes to deliver some food to Ri Eul in the theme park. Ah Yi is curious about her from the start, about how she knows him and what their relationship is (she initially thinks she’s his wife). While Ri Eul is being held in police custody, Ji Soo tells Ah Yi and Il Deung about Ri Eul as a teenager. Turns out, his real name is Ryu Min Hyuk. He was Ji Soo’s first love in high school, but he never really responded to her advances so they just stayed friends. At some point, Min Hyuk started to change, he seemingly became more anxious and stressed and his grades started dropping. At one point, he even jumped off the school roof and while he was saved, he then was taken into a mental hospital. As it turns out, Min Hyuk’s high school situation wasn’t that much different from Il Deung’s. He was also under a lot of pressure from his parents, who were both successful professors. He lived his life to please his parents and in that, he also became aware of the ‘asphalt path’ that he was being urged to follow. Once he became aware of that, his whole world started spinning and he ended up being branded a ‘crazy person’ just for not fitting into society’s set standards. As an adult, he deliberately chose to stay a child as much as he could, and most importantly, to help other youngsters in similar situations to recover the magic that they were being obstructed from experiencing in their childhood. Youngsters like Ah Yi and Il Deung, who were raised with their noses pointed towards their future before they could even really enjoy being kids.
In the end it’s revealed that Ri Eul (or Min Hyuk)’s alleged involvement with the disappeared girl and the muggings is all part of a plan to frame him. In truth, he was just hanging around the theme park trying to get Ah Yi and Il Deung to experience being a child again. He wasn’t completely sane, I’ll give you that, but I don’t believe he had any ill intentions. He only got mad at that girl when she started snooping because he didn’t like her poking her nose where it didn’t belong and, most importantly, she injured his parrot, and that bird meant the world to him. I’m not saying that he did right in assaulting her, but I do think that in his mind, he was just angry because of that and it’s not like he actually wanted to kill her.
But so yeah, I definitely found it interesting to see how similar Ri Eul’s own high school situation had been to Il Deung’s. He didn’t even approach Il Deung himself, they just happened to meet because of Ah Yi, but it was clear that Ri Eul immediately recognized Il Deung’s situation and that’s why he was able to immediately confront him with it. I like to think that once he recognized what Il Deung was going through, he wanted to help him get out of it as soon as possible because in his own time, there was no one around who recognized or acknowledged his situation. He was the one who needed to be reached out to, and because he himself suffered like that he made it his calling to be that kind of adult to youngsters going through similar realities. He knew as no other how harsh society could be on those people. Again, I don’t exactly get how he could hear these kids ‘call out for help in their minds’, if that was another real magic trick he possessed or if he just felt it after meeting Ah Yi and Il Deung once, but I can imagine how that would make him seem like a hero, or, according to Ah Yi’s analogy, a Santa figure.
I mentioned the bird before, but I want to say something more about it. Ri Eul keeps a beautiful red ara parrot in his lair at the theme park. He calls her Mi Nyeo (or ‘Bella’, as per the English Netflix subtitles) and she is the only living being that he seems to carry any personal attachment to. He has taught her how to speak and she regularly makes remarks to people that come to visit, not all of them equally friendly. She only utters friendly remarks to Ri Eul. How he came upon this beautiful bird is not revealed, we only see how desperate and sad he becomes when Mi Nyeo is hurt and from the way he flips out to the person responsible it’s clear that he has a deep emotional connection with the parrot. I would’ve liked to know a bit more about how he encountered her, like where did he get her from and how did they build up this bond? It was really sad that she didn’t make it after being injured like that.

By the way, I think the naming of the main characters is really interesting.
‘Ah Yi’, spelled 아이 in Korean, literally means ‘child’. When Ri Eul hears Ah Yi’s name for the first time, he comments, ‘Ah, so that means that even when you become an adult, you’ll always be a child’. At the moment he says this, Ah Yi is still very much struggling with her situation so I can understand that that wasn’t something she liked to hear. It just reminded her of the fact that she would always remain like that, a child that wouldn’t be taken seriously by adults, even after becoming one herself. But I believe that Ri Eul meant it as a good thing, as he thought that one should never lose the child within. In the end, though, it’s really fitting as Ah Yi takes over Ri Eul’s work in his honor and starts performing magic for children.
‘Il Deung’, spelled 일등, literally means ‘First Place’. It can also be seen as a kind of curse his parents laid on him. Naming your only child ‘First Place’, I mean sure, no pressure or anything.
‘Ri Eul’, spelled as 리을 is, I believe, the Korean pronunciation of the English word ‘real’. The magician only eventually introduces himself to Ah Yi as ‘for now, I’m Ri Eul’, but I think it’s safe to assume that him naming himself this has everything to with the fact that he is so bent on making everyone believe he is a real magician. I can’t really think of any other reason for this name, I just think he made it up from the English word ‘real’ even though that wasn’t explicitly stated as the reason.
The original Korean title of the series is ‘Annara Sumannara’, which is the magic spell that Ri Eul uses throughout the show. I think it would translate as something like ‘Abracadabra’? Anyways, it’s interesting to see they put this as the title, as if uttering the series’ title itself is already supposed to make you believe in magic.
On the other hand, I wonder about the choice for the English title ‘The Sound of Magic’, because it’s not really about sound as far as I gathered. Maybe it’s a reference to the musical aspect of the show? They might as well have called ‘Abracadabra’, IMO.

Let me move on to some significant supporting characters now.
First of all, Baek Ha Na (played by Ji Hye Won). She is a very confident girl in Ah Yi and Il Deung’s class. She’s a typical high school girl who cares about her appearance and social media ratings. Whenever she finds something interesting, she won’t let it go, even if that means relentlessly poking her nose into other people’s business. She’s one of the first people we see in the first episode telling other classmates about the rumor of the crazy magician in the theme park, and she’s also the person who consistently bothers Ah Yi at school by ‘accidentally’ bumping into her to make her fall down or drop her food in the cafeteria. Rather than feeling sorry for her and helping her out, she decides to make a joke out of the fact that Ah Yi is too poor to even buy herself a new pair of stockings. She indirectly humiliates her by first dropping a 50,000 yen note under Ah Yi’s desk and then, after confirming that she took it, coming into the classroom all ‘worried’ asking if anyone has seen her 50,000 yen note. Even though she already knows Ah Yi took it (she even recorded it on camera), she’s just doing it to see if Ah Yi will fold and admit that she took it. When Ah Yi doesn’t, she makes her feel even worse by just shrugging it off as that she’s made someone’s day and that she’ll led it slide because losing a 50,000 yen note doesn’t mean anything to her. It was really mean. It may have felt like a charity to her, but the intention of the joke was really mean, she could’ve just left the 50,000 yen there for Ah Yi to find and not said anything about it, that would’ve been kinder and it would’ve made Ah Yi feel less guilty about taking it.
All in all, I would call Ha Na gutsy if not a bit reckless. She kept going to the theme park by herself in the dark even after already encountering Ri Eul several times and she never made a good impression. She kept going there to snoop around and even plant hidden cameras while she knew that he wasn’t very fond of her. Again, I didn’t approve of how Ri Eul vented his anger on her because he really became scary dangerous there for a moment, but I also still thought that Ha Na was out of her depth by continuously provoking him. She kept saying she didn’t believe him to be a real magician and we all know how much he dislikes hearing that. In the end she was able to record some disturbing footage on one of the hidden cameras she’d installed (of which Ri Eul wasn’t aware), which showed him attacking someone with a knife. She then proceeds to relay this footage to Ah Yi and Il Deung to make them more suspicious of him as well. Either way, I didn’t really like her character simply because she got too caught up in other people’s business and I think she went a bit too far in provoking Ri Eul even though she should’ve been aware of the consequences of her actions. She should’ve known the danger of going in there all by herself in the night. Even when it wasn’t established yet whether Ri Eul was actually dangerous or not, it was still a big risk to take and I found it pretty reckless of her to keep going back there, especially all by herself.
At school, she always has this one friend that she drags everywhere with her, even though this friend usually tries to dissuade her from snooping too much. This girl, Kim So Hee (played by Kim Bo Yoon) seems to be a bit nicer than Ha Na. In any case, it seemed to me as if she actually wanted Ha Na to stop bothering Ah Yi as well, and she kept telling her not to keep bothering the magician as well. Maybe she was just scared, but I did agree with her. At least she was aware of the possible dangers Ha Na could be getting herself into. Still, she kept going along with her as if despite her doubts she just wasn’t able to say no to her friend. After Ha Na was attacked by Ri Eul, she even went on to spread that fact to her classmates, making sure Ah Yi heard it. That just made me go like, what are you giving Ah Yi the stink face for, it’s not like she had anything to do with that. Anyways, So Hee was a bit of a sheep but at least she seemed to have a bit more of a conscience than Ha Na.

Finally, I’ll address the case of the girl that goes missing from Ah Yi’s class. This girl, Seo Ha Yoon (played by Oh So Hyun) only appears in the first episode (I believe) and she goes missing around the same time that Ah Yi meets Ri Eul. Ha Yoon seems to also be a quiet girl without any friends in class, and we last see her when Ah Yi passes her on her way to her part-time job at the convenience store – Ha Yoon is just on her way out. I don’t believe Ah Yi actually sees her, by the way, they just pass each other without really acknowledging each other. Anyways, that’s the last time she appears on screen before she disappears. No one has an inkling of what could have happened, but throughout the series the police keep getting tiny pieces of information. One of those pieces of information is that Ri Eul was spotted on a CCTV in an alleyway that had shown Ha Yoon just some hours before. They also found some of her belongings in the theme park. In the beginning, I thought that maybe she’d also encountered Ri Eul and he may have done something. I didn’t think it would be anything bad, but I remember feeling like she was also a bit of an outcast at school so I thought that maybe he’d reached out to her too and she’d asked him to make her disappear or something. I don’t know what I was thinking, lol. Anyways, Ri Eul himself neither confirms nor denies anything when Ah Yi asks him about it. I kept thinking that even if he didn’t have anything to do with it, he may have at least known something about it. Either way, there’s a whole investigation and as ‘the magician’ keeps popping up in other cases in the same neighborhood, the police believe they have good reason to suspect him. An adult man living by himself in an abandoned theme park going around telling everyone he’s a magician… there’s reason to be suspicious of that in itself. I can imagine that they wouldn’t put it past him to be some sort of pervert altogether. In the final episode, Ha Yoon’s body is found in a reservoir in a park somewhere and Ri Eul is arrested. But what actually happened is a very different story.
Let me talk about the convenience store owner (played by Yoon Kyung Ho). So when we first meet him, he seems to be a very kind person. He’s the first adult we see treating Ah Yi nicely. When he busts her as she’s about to take a bite out of a perfectly good hamburger that a customer left behind, he doesn’t judge her. He even gives her 50,000 yen on her first day because she’s doing such a good job. It finally seems like Ah Yi can get some support after all. However, when emergency strikes again and Ah Yi musters up all her courage to ask for an advance payment even though she only just started working there, the owner suddenly changes. He reluctantly agrees, saying he feels sorry for her situation, but then he suddenly starts touching her and tells her she can think of him as a kind uncle and that’s when Ah Yi is AGAIN confronted by the fact that she just can’t seem to find a single decent grown-up in her life. Ri Eul appears and ‘disappears’ him – he makes Ah Yi believe that he magicked him away while we later find out he actually just pushed him over a railing and just flapped his cape to make sure Ah Yi didn’t see it. Either way, the owner does seem to disappear for a while, which only strengthens Ah Yi in her belief that Ri Eul can make people disappear. But then it’s even scarier when he suddenly appears again, when Ah Yi is being interrogated by her teachers about her involvement with Ri Eul by the police. There the owner states that Ri Eul is a fraud, that he injured him and that Ah Yi is in cahoots with him as well. In the end, we find out that he is the person responsible not only for the disappearance (and murder) of Ha Yoon, but also of the muggings as he started pulling stunts to frame Ri Eul after what he did to him.
Ha Yoon used to work at the same convenience store as Ah Yi, and she was caught trying to steal money from the cashier. The owner did the same thing to her he did to Ah Yi, he pretended to be all understanding about her situation before putting his hands on her, but Ha Yoon was one step ahead of him – she actually caught him on camera. She strikes up a deal with him to not publish the footage if he’ll help her out with more money and they agree to meet at the theme park to close the deal. But what happens then is that the owner ambushes Ha Yoon from behind in the dark and silences her… quite literally. While Ah Yi and Ri Eul were happily singing a song up in the ferris wheel nearby, Ha Yoon was murdered and disposed of by the convenience store owner. It’s later revealed that he bought a similar attire as Ri Eul usually wears, and went around in the dark to mug people – after all, who could see a face in the dark, people would only remember the attire and if he’d just use the catchphrase that Ri Eul always used (‘Do you… believe in magic?’), it would be a piece of cake to get him convicted of that. He eventually gets busted after Ah Yi reports him for sexual assault to the police and they find the attire when they search his house.

There’s one other major piece of evidence that suddenly finds its way to the police, and this is footage from one of the CCTVs in the theme park, even though none of these cameras work anymore. For some reason, this one camera came back on for exactly four minutes, just when the ambush on Ha Yoon took place. This, again, made me wonder about the authenticity of Ri Eul’s magic. Because we see that, while Ri Eul was showing Ah Yi fireworks (the fireworks’ lights also appeared in the camera footage, that was the link to when exactly it happened), one of his blue sparkly butterflies flew out and landed on that specific camera, turning it on. Just as before, one of these butterflies had turned on all the streetlights in Ah Yi’s street as she was walking home alone in the dark. So were these actual magical butterflies? I’m still not sure which parts of Ri Eul’s magic were real and which were more metaphorical. The butterflies seemed to have a special meaning, as one appeared to teen Min Hyuk as he was about to jump off the school roof, and to Il Deung when he succumbed to the pressure that one time as well. I can’t say for sure what they meant, exactly, because it also felt like the butterflies symbolized the youngsters’ signal to get off the asphalt path, but then how did Ri Eul come to control the butterflies as an adult? WHAT EXACTLY WERE THOSE BUTTERFLIES??

So yeah, I think I’ve now covered all the characters and the most important events that happened in the show. I still feel like I missed a lot of hidden meanings and metaphors/symbols, but I also think I got the essence of the message the story wanted to convey. I can say that it was definitely very different from what I’d expected, but I was positively surprised. For me, it honestly could’ve done without the musical numbers although I do understand where the idea came from. The point of musical numbers is to also take you away from the situation at hand to just let go and be free and sing and dance without looking weird. In this case, I just kept wondering whether the whole sequences of the sung numbers were something that happened in Ah Yi’s mind, or if a passerby, for example, would witness the exact same thing. I highly doubt that even within the fictional elements of the story, those horses actually flew off the merry-go-round. But there were some things that seemed to be Ri Eul’s magic’s doing, such as the butterflies and the magic mailbox for example. It wasn’t completely clear to me to which extent the magic tricks were real and to which extent they were exaggerated in the character’s minds.
But still, be that as it may, this series was definitely a gem in the way it conveyed such a deep and serious topic in such a fantastical way. Ri Eul exists purely to help teenagers connect with the child inside them, to enable them to still feel how they should’ve been allowed to feel when they were children before they were robbed of that luxury at a way too early age. Ri Eul of course still remains to be quite the ambiguous character as it’s still a fact that he’s not completely sane and possibly dangerous when he’s provoked, but his intentions have always been good – he went through it himself and chose to live the rest of his life in seclusion only to be the reaching helping hand to youngsters who, like him, aren’t aware of the toxicity of their situation or in any case, who are not able to get out of the situation by themselves. I definitely did not expect this sociological issue of pressured children to be included in this, so for that in itself the originality of the plot gets some bonus points.

On to the cast comments!

This is the third Ji Chang Wook drama I’ve watched this year and can I just say, this man has been surprising me consistently! Just when I thought I’d seen what he was capable of as an actor, seeing him both in Backstreet Rookie and this, it just surprised me. It feels like he keeps choosing dramas that aren’t exactly his mainstream kind of genre, but he still pulls it off! As Ri Eul I really got some very angsty and even dangerous vibes from him, something I never felt from him before. I was really positively surprised by his performance and also – he can even sing?! What can’t this man do?! I also know that he’s very acrobatic, so I would’ve liked to see some more of that in here as well, it would’ve been the perfect opportunity to showcase all those hidden skills! In any case, I liked him in this. He played a completely different character from what I was used to, so mysterious and enigmatic at first, and then suddenly so unpredictable and vulnerable as well. He was able to convey more sides to his acting to me in these 6 episodes than in all the dramas I’ve seen him in so far, so that was cool!

I didn’t know Choi Sung Eun from anything, I see this was only her third drama to date. She did however seem very familiar to me, but I guess then I may have confused her for someone else. In any case, to not even have done so many dramas yet and then already being cast for one like this with musical songs and everything seems a pretty big challenge! I wonder if maybe she’s a musical actress or something? Anyways, I think she should be very very proud of her performance of Ah Yi, she’s such a layered character and she got to show such a tormented and vulnerable side to her, only to balance it out with the happiness she managed to portray in her songs with the magician. I also really loved her chemistry with her younger sister. I hope we get to see more of her in the near future!

So this was actually the first show I got to see with Hwang In Yeop in it and MAN this guy is good. (I was going to say ‘kid’ instead of ‘guy’ but I just found out he’s older than me so can’t really do that, lol.) Anyways, I think he’s really making his breakthrough as he’s appearing in more and more stuff these days so I had some expectations but I really loved his performance. As what I said for Ji Chang Wook above, within just 6 episodes he showed so many sides to his acting. I think he was a really good casting choice for Il Deung. There are several dramas of his in my to watch list, so I know I’m going to see more of him, but I was really blown away by his performance here. He portrayed the struggles of a teenager stuck in the ways his parents paved for him really well and even though he did some questionable stuff in the beginning, I started feeling more and more empathic towards him when he was confronted with the struggles he wasn’t even fully aware of himself yet. I also thought he was really adorable when he started developing feelings for Ah Yi, I wish there would’ve been more of that. Although, as I mentioned in the beginning, I also respect that that’s not what the focus of the show was about. I really can’t wait to see more shows he appeared in!

I was wondering what I recognized Ji Hye Won from, and I realized she was one of patients in the hospital from It’s Okay to Not Be Okay! The girl who eloped with the alcoholic guy! She was SO different here, everything about her character was different. It was fun seeing her as such a brazen girl like Ha Na. As I said, I didn’t really like the character, but that didn’t have anything to do with the actress. I think she did a good job, overall! Even though her way of going about things was questionable, I do feel like she was looking out for Ah Yi when she told her to be more suspicious of Ri Eul. I do feel like she didn’t want anything to happen to her, or anyone for that matter, especially after experiencing Ri Eul’s anger first-hand. So in a way, I don’t feel like she was a bad person. She was just very young and immature, which is to be expected of a regular girl that age. After all, she wasn’t forced to become an adult before her time like Ah Yi.

So the little sister actually has more drama acting experience than her older sister? Hong Jung Min, what a precious little girl she was. Apparently I’ve seen her before in Cinderella and the Four Knights and I will see her again soon in some of my to watch series. I liked that even though Yoo Yi was more of a supporting character, she also got to sing a beautiful song and she even sang IU’s ‘Knees’ which was such a perfect song for their situation. I feel like Yoo Yi really was an indispensable part of Ah Yi’s story and character. Even though she was the angel little sister who never got angry or impatient or desperate with their situation, I do feel like she was more aware of the misery her sister was experiencing and that she must have felt very sorry she couldn’t do more to help her. She was the epitome of lightness in this series, I kept referring to her as Ah Yi’s light at the end of the dark tunnel, the light she always got to go home to. Also when the dad briefly returned, Yoo Yi never blamed him for anything. I think all she wanted was just to have her family together. I’m glad they got there in the end. Oh and that scene when Ah Yi thought she was missing and went all over to look for her and then got the call from one of Yoo Yi’s friend’s mom that she’d fallen asleep while playing there… if that didn’t emphasize how much Yoo Yi meant to Ah Yi, then I don’t even know anymore. That was heartbreaking.

I love Jo Han Chul! We don’t usually get to see him as a non-comical character, so I was happy to see this side of him as well. Although I’ve already voiced my dislike of the father’s behavior, Jo Han Chul can do little wrong in my eyes. He still portrayed the character really well. I think he was Ah Yi’s main example of how much you could screw up as an adult. Of course she loved him, but he was the kind of an adult she did not want to become. Of course it taught her what she needed to know, but it was still incredibly irresponsible of him to leave his kids like that, after their mother also already had left them all for the same reason (probably). The scene where he phoned Ah Yi and was just kind of smiling away his embarrassment and guilt really hit differently. There’s a difference between screwing up and owning up to it and realizing your mistake but still making up excuses because ‘after all, I’m just a terrible dad’. Ah Yi had all the reason in the world to be mad at him. Finally getting a job and visiting them more was the least he could do to make up for it.

Not me flinching when I realized Il Deung’s dad was played by the same guy who played the bad guy in Itaewon Class! He had such a different vibe around him here! I further know Yoo Jae Myung from Jealousy Incarnate, Hwarang and Strong Woman Do Bong Soon. I kept wanting him to be a better dad, one who would be more forgiving than the mom when it turned out his son was struggling, but he was just as bad. It felt like he managed to remain calmer about the situation, though, but he still only wanted his son to perform in line with his own reputation.

Il Deung’s mom’s actress was also in Itaewon Class! I further know Kim Hye Eun from Romantic Doctor Teacher Kim, Introverted Boss, Radio Romance, Are You Human Too?, Encounter and Clean With Passion For Now. She’s a very familiar face. As the mom, who is typically more emotional in dealing with her children’s struggles, I really expected more from her. The way she dealt with Il Deung’s ‘rebellion’ definitely was not the way to go. She only restricted him more rather than listen to what he had to say and see that the way she raised him was not okay. She gave a good performance of a relentless mom who didn’t see any fault in her own ways, though. It was also a different side of her acting that I saw here, as I feel like I’ve only seen her in more sympathetic characters so far, haha.

I had the same kind of issue with Yoon Kyung Ho. I’ve only ever seen him as sympathetic guys, so to suddenly see him explode off the screen like that, to suddenly see him as such a dangerous guy was really surprising! It isn’t until then that you realize what a big and potentially scary guy he can be, haha. I’ve seen him in a bunch of stuff like Goblin, Duel, Age of Youth, I’m Not a Robot and Itaewon Class as well. Big Itaewon Class family reunion happening, as I saw Ryu Kyung Soo also made a guest appearance! Anyways, it was nice also seeing a different side than usual from Yoon Kyung Ho. I still envision him as a very friendly ahjussi though, haha.

I also want to give a shoutout to Joo Ye Rim who played the young Ah Yi – she was fantastic. I really choked up during the scene where teenage Ah Yi came face to face with her younger self and managed to comfort her, that was so beautiful and well thought of, flipping it around a bit to current Ah Yi comforting her younger self rather than meeting her twenty-or thirtysomething self from the future.
And of course I cannot forget best boy Nam Da Reum who played teenage Ryu Min Hyuk – I don’t know how he does it but he seriously looked like a young Ji Chang Wook? This guy is such a genius actor, I can’t wait to see him turn old enough to finally get his own main roles rather than always being cast as the ML’s younger version. He deserves it all!

And with that, I’ve come to the end of my review. It’s been a really fun ride, a really unexpected ride and I’m glad I gave it a try. It definitely is not a typical K-Drama, but I think that’s also part of its charm because it’s exactly what sets it apart from the rest. It conveys a serious sociological issue through depictions of magic, imagination, hope and freedom. As I mentioned before, I couldn’t quite get used to the musical numbers, and I can imagine people finding it awkward or skipping through those, but for me, when they started singing I just paid extra close attention to the lyrics. I imagine it being Ah Yi’s hidden thoughts that she otherwise could not properly convey, and in accordance with the magical elements, it just made sense to make her sing them out as this is also how it goes in musicals – they sing out their true feelings and thoughts because they can’t simply say them. It really surprised me from the get-go when they all started to sing and dance but that’s also what immediately intrigued me about it.
I also really liked that they made an additional after-credit scene in which the cast takes their bows as if they’ve just finished performing the whole show as a stage performance in front of an audience. You could suddenly see all the actors as themselves, interacting and dancing with each other and it was just a really cheerful way to end the show.
All in all, it was unique, it was original, it was surprising and it was striking in its approach to convey such a serious message. I enjoyed it, it had been a while since I actually refrained from watching it in one go, I really would’ve gone straight through it if I wasn’t planning on writing a review. Otherwise this review would’ve been posted two days after the previous one and I wasn’t going to do that to myself, haha. I’m glad I spread it out a bit more so that I could take my time with writing a worthwhile review about it.
I’d say the only thing that it lacked for me was some more understanding of how exactly Ri Eul’s magic worked. I would’ve liked to know for sure where Ah Yi’s imagination started and where the actual magic tricks ended and vice versa. The few loose ends to make it an open ending weren’t necessarily a bad thing, but it still made me wonder about what happened to several other characters. For example, we don’t get to see Il Deung in the final ‘X years later’ part, which made me wonder whether he and Ah Yi still kept in touch. I wondered about the period in which Ri Eul started living in that theme park, I wondered how he met Mi Nyeo. But yeah, mostly I wondered about the magic tricks. Of course everything was fictional, but even within this series, I feel like there was a limit to what was actually happening and what was the experience of it happening. Like, Ri Eul turning on the merry-go-round was one thing, the horses flying off it another. One might have actually happened, the other may have been exaggerated in Ah Yi’s imagination. I would’ve liked to get a clearer distinction between the two. But apart from that, I really enjoyed the show.

So yeah, this was my last Netflix K-Drama of the year, the final ones on my 2022 list are all ‘regular’ dramas, but I’ll definitely keep watching K-Drama on Netflix as it’s such a comfortable platform to watch them on. I’ve now lined up all the dramas I plan on finishing within this year, so please look forward to a couple more soon! Without my intention I incidentally chose several short dramas in a row, that’s why I’m going through them so fast now, haha. Anyways, I’ll be back soon enough, so stay tuned and don’t forget: whenever you feel down and need to believe in a miracle, you know which magic words to use!

*\ Annara Sumannara /*

Bye-bee! ^^



The Silent Sea

Standard

Disclaimer: this is a review, and as such it contains spoilers of the whole series. Please proceed to read at your own risk if you still plan on watching this show or if you haven’t finished it yet. You have been warned.

The Silent Sea
(고요의 바다 / Goyoui Bada)
MyDramaList rating: 7.0/10

Hi everyone! It has only been a week since my last review, but I was able to finish this one surprisingly fast. I knew from the start that it was a short series, but the episodes also turned out to be very short for a Korean drama series, so I went through it very quickly. As it wasn’t the type of genre that I usually watch, I was really curious to this one as it had looked very thrilling to me from the trailer and I was also interested to see the chemistry/dynamic of the popular lead actors in a genre that I haven’t really seen them in before. Before I started on it, I felt like it would be a sort of Armaggedon-vibe show, a crew of multiple people going on a dangerous mission in space where they discover something even more dangerous than they’d anticipated, and they’re taken out one by one until only several (predictable) people remain. That’s what I imagined. Although it did follow along the first few expectations I had, it also still managed to surprise me and it really kept me on the edge of my seat until the end. The only thing keeping me back from giving it a higher rating is my dissatisfaction with the ending. Leggo.

The Silent Sea is an 8-episode K-Drama with episodes of each about 40-50 minutes, which is short for a Netflix K-Drama (in my experience, at least). The story is set on Earth in the future, and in a quite dystopian future at that. Earth is basically a barren wasteland, there’s barely any water left on the surface. Sea levels are dropping and there’s barely any rainfall. Contamination of the existing water has a big influence on health all over the world, and there’s a lot of research going on regarding artificial farming which doesn’t require much water usage. The water shortage in its turn causes global food shortage, and so the cycle goes on and on. In fact, in the current society, people’s allowed amount of water is determined by a regulation that links one’s rank to the amount of water they’re allowed to get. This regulation doesn’t just apply to water usage, but also to other privileges like better medical care. One needs to have a certain rank to be allowed better treatment. It really reminded me of an escalated version of Nosedive (Black Mirror), where ranks determine everything. Anyways, in this world where people are desperate for water and are actually lining up for hours to fill up their plastic water tanks, the SAA (Space and Aeronautics Administration) sends a special team of scientists and specialists to the Moon to fetch an important sample from the Balhae Lunar Research Station. This station is about to be shut down because of a terrible radiation leak accident that happened 5 years ago which killed all 117 crew members present at the station at the time. Whatever they were working on or what exactly happened is not known even to the SAA, and this also goes for the exact contents of the sample. The team is basically sent there with no concrete information on what they’re supposed to retrieve.
As a former esteemed astrobiologist turned ethologist, Dr. Song Ji An (played by Bae Doo Na) is the person that the SAA wants most to participate in this mission. They claim it’s because her skills will contribute greatly to the mission, and they give her the final decision on what’s to be done with the sample when they find it. However, for Ji An there’s another, more personal reason why she reluctantly decides to go on this mission – her older sister Song Won Kyung (played by Kang Mal Geum) was one of the researchers at Balhae Station.

From the start, I thought the whole mission seemed hella suspicious. They aren’t given any concrete information on what exactly they have to travel all the way to the Moon for, they literally only get a picture of what the capsule containing the sample looks like, and the information that the sample needs to be kept under extremely low temperatures. Why it needs to be kept under extremely low temperatures, no one knows. Also, they are told that they really only need to secure ONE single capsule of the sample, no need to go in for more. Why send a full 11-people team just to obtain ONE capsule? If there really was nothing going on in that station, they wouldn’t have felt the need to send so many people, right? In any case, I would’ve definitely wanted to know what I was getting into before risking my life in outer space, so I could very well understand Ji An’s suspicion.
Why did she still decide to go, then? As she already establishes in the beginning, she’s not an astrobiologist anymore, there’s nothing out there. The thing is, she used to be really close with her sister after their parents died. Her sister told her once about ‘the silent sea’, referring to the darker parts that are visible on the Moon, parts that were rumored to contain water. She said she wanted to show Ji An the ocean again, if possible. But then suddenly a few years later, her sister left without saying anything, and Ji An only finds out she’d been doing research in outer space when the SAA informs her of Won Kyung’s death. What she was doing up there, Ji An doesn’t know, as it was all kept under wraps and she didn’t keep in touch with her sister that much after she’d left. The final time that her sister contacted her was five years earlier, and Ji An didn’t pick up the phone. After realizing that her sister may have called her in her last moments when the accident took place, Ji An feels a sort of connection to finding out what happened to her, also maybe to suppress a little bit of guilt for not picking up her call that time. Furthermore, Ji An discovers an email from her sister with an encrypted message in it. After encrypting it, it gives her the message ‘FIND LUNA’. For Ji An, this feels like her sister is asking her to go to Balhae Station, and that’s why she decides to go.

Including Ji An, the whole crew consists of 11 people in total, 9 men and 2 women. Let me just list them all below.
Song Ji An, astrobiologist.
Captain Han Yoon Jae (played by Gong Yoo), the team leader.
Hong Ga Young (played by Kim Sun Young), the team doctor.
Pilot Kim Sun (played by Lee Sung Wook) and co-pilot Lee Gi Soo (Choi Young Woo). The co-pilot was originally supposed to be someone else, a woman, but she was suddenly and without explanation substituted for Gi Soo on the day of departure.
Engineers Gong Soo Chan (Jung Soon Won) and Ryu Tae Seok (Lee Joon).
Head of security Gong Soo Hyuk (played by Lee Moo Saeng), also Soo Chan’s older brother.
E1 and E2 (respectively played by Cha Rae Hyung and Yoo Hee Je).
Mr. Hwang (Yoo Jung Joo), an advisor who contributed to the construction of Balhae Station.

So yeah, the crew leaves and while the initial departure goes smoothly, they soon find themselves with a loose bracket (or something) on the outer surface of the ship and are forced to make an emergency landing at about 7,6 km distance from Balhae Station – they have to walk all the way there while their oxygen is slowly running out. Not only that, their entire space ship crashes into the abyss so they have no way back by themselves. It is in this dire beginning situation that they already lose their first crew member, Mr. Hwang. He punctures his ribs during the emergency landing and isn’t able to make it all the way to the station. With his last breaths, he does already give a strange warning. He mutters ‘Water’, and when Captain Han interprets it as that he wants water and moves to replenish his tank, Mr. Hwang urgently stops him and is only able to mutter ‘Not… The water… don’t’, before he passes away. So yeah, there’s something about the water. As a Whovian, this immediately screamed The Waters of Mars and it did not sit well with me from the start.
After arriving at Balhae, the crew quickly does several shocking and strange discoveries. They find out there’s actually nothing wrong with the radiation levels. They discover the bodies of all the 117 crew members that were left at Balhae after ‘the accident’ showing very strange symptoms – it looks like they’ve drowned. In outer space. Furthermore, when they find the storage rooms containing the capsules, it looks like they’ve all been wreckaged and they can’t find a single capsule that isn’t empty. Before they even get all the information to understand what’s going on (or what went on at the Station five years ago), the crew is faced with an increasingly alarming situation as the members are taken one by one, either by an invisible (supposed) virus that makes every liquid in their body turn into multiplying water and makes them drown from the inside, or (in a rather bloody manner) by a mysterious entity that seems to be lurking about the Station. Something that very much does NOT want them to take even a single sample away from it.
As they manage to get the comms working again, through Captain Han’s contact with the SAA back on Earth, more suspicions seem to rise as it seems that the SAA does have more knowledge than they initially claimed to have. Especially Director Choi (Gil Hae Yeon) starts acting more and more suspicious and Captain Han starts doubting the true goal of the mission.
To make things even worse, it’s revealed that both Gi Soo and Tae Seok are actually spies for the RX (Resource Exploration for Space Mining and Planetary Development), a transnational agency that wants to obtain the samples for themselves. Kim Sun even refers to them once as ‘the resource Mafia’. Tae Seok volunteered for this mission as he was actually also there five years earlier when he closed the door on those 117 people, disabling them from getting out alive. Gi Soo’s last minute appointment to the team is also explained through this. Both of them plan to obtain at least one sample by themselves before turning against the rest of the crew to try to get out by himself.

Okay, so let me just summarize the whole deal here before I find myself recapping the entire series, that’s not what we’re doing here. Basically, five years ago, the researchers sent to Balhae Station (including Won Kyung) discovered water on the Moon. They called it ‘lunar water’ and when they started researching it, they came to the major discovery that this water, when it came into contact with any sort of other liquid, would multiply. Thinking they may have found a potential solution to the water shortage on Earth, the researchers began to experiment, first on animals, fish… and then on human clones. They used a young girl clone code-named ‘Luna’ and kept experimenting on her until the 73rd attempt, when her body suddenly seemed to have become immune to the lunar water.
On the day of the accident, the system suddenly detects a ‘thermoregular anomaly’ and urges everyone to evacuate. No one knows what’s going on, and while all researchers desperately try to get to the exit, some of the lunar water leaks out of some capsules that were knocked over in the crowd rush. When the RX (I guess, they were also there?) starts closing the gates one by one and the people become more desperate to search for another way out, more and more people start succumbing after accidentally coming into contact with the escaping lunar water. In the end, being locked in with no way out and with a spreading water virus on the loose, no one survived the outbreak except Luna, as she’s immune to the lunar water now. Luna basically becomes a guard dog for the samples of lunar water since in her case, the water heals her and makes her harder, better, faster, stronger. So much so that she can move at incredible speed and is able to sever body parts with her bare hands without too much effort. She also has developed some fish-like elements to her body, like gills in her neck, and when she blinks it happens horizontally rather then vertically. So yeah, Luna is the mysterious entity roaming around and violently injuring and killing crew members that try to take samples away from her. She’s also the Luna from Won Kyung’s encrypted ‘FIND LUNA’ message, and for some reason, Ji An is the only one who can calm her down. She’s the only one that wants to believe she doesn’t hurt people because she wants to, but only because she’s scared. At some point while trying to capture Luna, the girl bites Ji An, and this bite ends up saving Ji An’s life – when she herself comes into contact with the lunar water, the traces of Luna’s DNA through the bite wound work as an antidote against the water.

To give a short summary of the order and manner of the crew member’s deaths:
Mr. Hwang dies of his injuries and lack of oxygen caused by the crash landing before making it to Balhae.
Soo Chan is exposed to the lunar water by getting into contact with one of the dead bodies while trying to obtain a sample capsule.
Gi Soo is killed by Luna when he tries to get away with a full sample capsule from one of the storage rooms.
E1 dies after being fatally injured by Luna when they discover the final hidden storage room filled with sample capsules.
E2 is shot by Tae Seok after overhearing him talk to the RX on the phone.
Kim Sun is shot by Tae Seok after confronting him and then killed by the lunar water the same way as Soo Chan.
Tae Seok himself is soaked by the lunar water released through the air vent and is also shot by both Soo Hyuk and Captain Han.
Soo Hyuk is shot by Tae Seok in his final moments and doesn’t make it in time to escape the Station.
Captain Han sacrifices himself when the air lock needs to be depressurized from the outside. He’s engulfed by the lunar water outbreak but ultimately dies after he’s catapulted out of the Station onto the Moon surface by the water.
The only people to make it out of the Station alive are the women of the company, Ji An, Dr. Hong, and Luna. A rescue ship arrives just at that moment and it’s suggested they’re brought to safety. The final words over the comms of the rescue ship are: ‘Survivors have been rescued and samples secured.’
‘What condition are they in?’ (The survivors or the samples?)
‘Yet to confirm.’
‘Have a safe flight back.’
‘Switching to autonomous navigation system.’
And that’s the end.

I want to comment on a couple of things that the show lacked in my opinion.
First of all, I found it a pity that there wasn’t an equal division of character development or even character background for each character. It took me at least 4 episodes to get an idea of who was who, and that was only after several people had already died. I actually went back to the first couple of episodes to rewatch certain parts with the knowledge I gained after finishing the whole thing, and only then it became a bit more clear to me. Also, the foreshadowing became much more apparent.
The only person we get a proper backstory from is Ji An. We learn about her sister and more about her motives. It was especially interesting to see Ji An’s emotional journey as she discovers the illegal experimenting that her sister had been doing – she really has to unravel some personal emotional baggage here, even though she’s one of the most stoic characters in the whole series.
On Captain Han’s side, we only find out that he has a young daughter who’s in the hospital because she can’t use her legs and his rank isn’t high enough to improve her medical care. Apart from that, we don’t learn anything about Captain Han’s life, only that he’s probably used to just doing as he’s told on SAA missions. He clashes the most with Ji An in the beginning, as he is determined to stick to the mission they were given even when Ji An is much more interested what exactly happened at the Station five years ago, if not radiation leakage. It isn’t until the crew members start dying one by one and they find out about Luna, that Captain Han also becomes more and more suspicious of the SAA’s intentions of sending them there. Also since the SAA director’s instructions suddenly change once he informs them of a possible ‘survivor’ or ‘intruder’ that’s in there with them. Suddenly the Director instructs them to grab as many samples as they can, and they can’t allow this intruder to get away with any of it. In fact, they will only send a backup ship after they’d secured the intruder. It was all very strange.
In any case, my point is that I had some trouble connecting with the characters in the beginning. People started falling away before I was even able to get an idea of who they were, which was a pity. I felt this specifically with Soo Chan, for some reason. I just felt like he’d be around for a while longer, but he really died already in the third episode, within a single hour of being exposed to the lunar water. He seemed to be a fun, comic relief kind of character together with Kim Sun, but he was killed off way too soon in my opinion. It did give Soo Hyuk a new layer though, as he was forced to watch his little brother die like that and I suddenly became very aware of the fact that they’d indeed been brothers, even though it was only mentioned briefly once before. Anyways, the exact links between all the characters hadn’t been fully established in my brain yet before people already started disappearing, so that made it a bit hard to get accustomed to everyone.
Also, who the heck were E1 and E2 and why didn’t they have normal names? I would’ve liked to know a bit more about them, especially E2, or Freckles as I called him until, you know, he died. In his case I really found it a pity because I felt like he was the youngest of the group but he got the least action and he was killed so needlessly after already being unconscious for an entire episode. He just had to wake up in the same room as Tae Seok as he was doing his spy thing. It really was a pity.
So yeah, while I understand that 8 episodes is limited time to establish all of the characters equally, I really would’ve liked to get some more personal information besides their initial short self introductions.
Even in the way they died, sometimes I wished they’d given it a bit more meaning. Like for example, Kim Sun dying the exact same way as his best friend Soo Chan. He was forced to watch his buddy die like that and then it was happening to him and it was over even quicker than before. They could’ve used the bracelets more as well, the bracelets Soo Chan, Soo Hyuk and Kim Sun were all wearing as a promise to get out together alive. There were so many possibilities of adding a little more personal depth to the characters, but in the end they all just died alone without mercy – which on the other hand, is also very realistic and symbolic of the mercilessness of their situation and environment. But still, I had mixed feelings about it. I think there could’ve been more personal connections established, that would’ve added even more weight to the situation of losing the people around them. Now, except for a few people, everyone was basically unrelated to one another, so even when people died, there was always a sort of awkward tension around it, because even though it was horrible, there wasn’t a personal connection with the person to be shared.
The same went for the memorial thing. In the first episode, it’s shown that the memorial of the 117 crew members of Balhae Station doesn’t even mention their names, it’s a quite unpersonal memorial. I get that they’d kept it a secret just as that Ji An never knew her sister was part of that research, but the SAA did still reveal to Ji An that her sister was part of it after she died. They must’ve known the identities of all those people, they must informed told more families (I hope), so why still not put their names on the memorial? And it just made me wonder what they would do about this mission? Would they also make a memorial for the 9 people that didn’t come back this time?
That’s the thing that bothers me the most about the ending. I would’ve liked to get a kind of closure. Any kind of closure, really. Because it just feels like nothing was solved. What happened after Ji An and Dr. Hong got back to Earth? What happened to Luna? Did they again leave all the bodies up there? Did they again not make an effort to commemorate the brave people that went on that mission? What happened to Captain Han’s daughter after he didn’t return? What happened to the SAA, did Ji An and Dr. Hong reveal the truth about the whole thing? Honestly, I have more questions now than I had at the beginning of the series. It just doesn’t feel complete, and that’s a real pity.

I felt like this show had so much potential. It started out so great, I really was pulled into it from the start. The imagery of the moon and the shadowed parts that just make it seem like a sea of nothingness was properly haunting. I find The Silent Sea a very appropriate title, not just because of the association with Won Kyung’s referral to the dark parts of the moon, but because it really felt like they were trapped in an ocean of silence, the Moon itself. It also refers to the more literal association of the lunar water becoming a sea that made people drown from the inside – Soo Chan and Kim Sun are literally depicted going down under a water surface as they succumb to it. I also thought the opening sequence was beautiful and after paying close attention, I found that it actually tells the full story of the show in very simple images. We see water that takes on several shapes of people until it bursts out into a multitude of single drops, we see an astronaut in a forest that goes through three stages of draught until it burns, we see the rocket launch into space and an astronaut drowning until there’s a zoomout to a single astronaut sitting (seemingly dead or at least unconscious) leaned against some rocks on the Moon surface when the words ‘The Silent Sea’ appear in the night-black sky. It basically sums up the whole show.
It’s just that they left too many things open and it frustrates me. I wanted to connect more to the characters, I wanted to know where they came from, what they wanted to get back to. How they got into this mission, or into this line of work, even. I wanted Director Choi and the SAA to be busted for covering up the whole ordeal, I wanted justice. I wanted everyone to at least get a proper memorial and burial. I still rated it as I did because the things that WERE there were really good and I can’t really say anything bad about it. What bugs me here are the things that WEREN’T shown, and I can’t remember ever being so frustrated about an open ending before. I need more than this.

I will move on to my cast comments now before concluding this review.

Honestly, I’ve only seen a couple of things from Bae Doo Na, and all of them were foreign projects. I’ve seen her in Sense8 and the Japanese movie Air Doll. This is the first actual Korean drama that I’ve seen her in. In my opinion, she always has the same kind of appearance and I’ve also ever seen her play really stoic characters. Maybe it’s type casting, but anyways, I’m not mentioning it as a bad thing. I thought she was really good in The Silent Sea. I loved that at least from her side we got some character story and development and while she initially kept a firm distance from the rest of the crew and stuck to her own interests, she did gradually open up more as the situation grew more dire. I don’t know you’d have a choice in such a situation, because you just have to start sticking together, but still, I think she went through an interesting personal journey. She never wanted to be there, she was fine being oblivious about the true nature of her sister’s disappearance and death. But because she was pushed into this, she became more invested in it again. I liked to see a more vulnerable side of her in the end, and also her compassion towards Luna. At the beginning her stoicness made it a bit hard for me to empathize with her, but in the end, as is fitting with the main character, I really sympathized with her and rooted for her to get out of there and go back to the safety of the Earth surface. I think she did a really good job portraying the layers of Ji An’s personality, all the more because Ji An held back her emotions so much.

Once again I can say that I’ve seen Gong Yoo in a serious acting role that wasn’t about his appearance or popularity. I like that he’s doing these series that seem to lay outside of his usual genre. Then again, I haven’t seen Train to Busan, apparently he’s really good in that one, as well. Anyways, I know him from The 1st Shop of Coffee Prince to Big to Goblin, and I always seem to like his performances. He’s a good actor and it really felt like I was seeing a new side of him in this show. As I mentioned, I would’ve liked to get more backstory from his side, I don’t know how they would’ve had to insert that somewhere, but in the end it still felt like I knew next to nothing about him. He was such a just Captain, he really cared about his crew members and you could see how much it killed him to go against Tae Seok because he felt so betrayed by him. It was a nice kind of development to see him adapt more to the situation and consequently, Ji An’s views on what the mission should be. In his own way, he changed his mindset for the better and he had a radar for certain things as well. At some point he suddenly randomly commented about the fact that Tae Seok had voluntarily signed up for the mission, as if he just had a feeling about him. I would’ve liked to get a bit more insight into his personal life apart from his daughter, but I still liked his character enough as it was. I really do wonder what would happen to his daughter now, though…

Lee Joon was one of the faces that looked familiar to me, and then I realized he’s the main from Drama Special: What’s The Ghost Doing? !!! No wonder I didn’t immediately make the connection, haha! He’s also a former member of K-Pop group MBLAQ, apparently. But yeah, he definitely showed a very new side to his acting from what I saw in the other one. He didn’t really stand out to me much in the beginning, but I started getting suspicious about him because there was just something about the way he sometimes looked at people, like a glance that lasted just a little too long to be a regular look. When it was revealed that besides Gi Soo, he too was working for the RX and that he actually started killing the crew members upon confrontation rather than trying to maintain his cover, he suddenly became all dangerous and that was scary but interesting. I think this must have been a pretty challenging role, also because for the first half of the series he really had to work hard not to seem suspicious.

I already announced this in my previous review, but I knew that Kim Sun Young was in this and I was really excited to see her in a more serious role again. Usually, her serious acting really gives me goosebumps. To sum up again what I know her from: Shopping King Louie, Legend of the Blue Sea, Lookout, Because This is My First LifeRomance is a Bonus BookCrash Landing on You and Backstreet Rookie and, most recently, Her Private Life. Dr. Hong was one of the characters that I felt was really established clearly from the beginning, the kind of person she was. But then as soon as they arrived at the Station, there wasn’t really a lot to do with the traits she’d been given as emergency struck right away and she was mostly just freaking out about the things happening around her. I liked that she was another strong and dependable female character, and that she managed to get out alive, but I also felt like she remained mostly in the background. Of course, without a doctor everyone is screwed, so they must have deliberately tried to keep her away from the danger as much as possible, but for me it felt like this obstructed her character in expressing herself as she did best. Her first introduction to Ji An, how casual and confident she seemed, and how she would comment on the people idly chatting on the spacecraft, I would’ve liked to see more snarky moments of her like that. With her it felt like her personality was suppressed a little by the events that happened, there was no room for her to be her calm and collected self the way she was when she first introduced herself. Anyways, this didn’t have anything to do with her acting of course, she was still very good. It was just another example of the lack of distinguishable personality traits of each of the characters.

Lee Moo Saeng also looked familiar to me, and I guess it’s because I remember him from Melting Me Softly. It also took me a while to get familiar with his character, although it got better -however weird this is to say- after Soo Chan died. The scene in which he was watching him, muttering ‘Hang in there’ to his younger brother hit me quite hard, as it was the first time I saw any of the male characters really soften. After that he recollected himself very quickly, but from that point on there was always that hurt in him that somehow made it easier for me to feel for him. It was kind of predictable that he was also going to die before the end, but still I found it a pity. It would’ve been nice if more people managed to get out alive. Despite his tendency to quickly aim his gun at things (like Luna), I still couldn’t dislike him because he was Soo Chan’s brother and that made him a good person. He also just accepted that he wouldn’t make it as soon as he got shot. In the end, I did like his character.

KIM SUN DESERVED BETTER. Honestly, as soon as he was making his way towards the command center where Tae Seok was and in the meantime they were all informed that Tae Seok was the spy, I just knew what was waiting for him, but I still had hoped that he wouldn’t die. Seriously, the guy just wanted to go home T^T He’d already had to watch his best friend die, he’d watched as Luna tore E1’s forearm off just to get the sample out of his hand, he’d already lost all the faith he’d put in his friendship bracelet to get out alive, but still he just wanted to go home and his death really killed me. He was just crying to Tae Seok that he wanted them all to go home while the water was starting to mingle with his blood. Kim Sun was the best of them and I stand by that.
I’ve seen Lee Sung Wook before in Duel (apparently) and most recently in Extraordinary Attorney Woo, he was in the ATM copyright case. He’s also in a couple of dramas that are still on my list, so looking forward to that. I really liked Kim Sun, he was the fun and carefree character that you just need in a story full of darkness. Although I already knew he wouldn’t stand a chance on his own, either to the virus or to something else, it just killed me that he ended up exactly like Soo Chan. When it was shown how he drowned inside, I kind of hoped Soo Chan to pop up to reach for his hand, at least they would’ve been together. T^T

Apparently I know Jung Soon Won from Fight For My Way, but I don’t remember him from there. In any case, I’ve already mentioned what I thought about what happened to Soo Chan. I just felt really bad for him since he’d just barely got in there alive – he was struggling with the access codes while everyone was running out of oxygen which was a really intense moment and I’d just expected him to be around for longer than he did. Although it was sad that he died first, he did immediately point them in the direction of the lunar water, so it did speed things up with regards to finding out stuff. I just wished, again, that I’d learned more about him, even got more scenes of him with his brother, because now I wouldn’t have known they were related if it weren’t for that single mention of their father. He also deserved better. See, here I start struggling with commenting on the actor’s performance because he actually wasn’t in the story for that long, I just got enough from the character to like him sufficiently to mention him here. I can imagine the scene where he was puking out all that water and Dr. Hong stuck all these tubes in him in the hope of making it easier for him to breathe must have been pretty intense to film, so just for his performance in that scene alone, I was impressed.

As I mentioned before, two of the most enigmatic members of the crew to me were E1 and E2. I don’t even know why they had these similar code names or nicknames, their real names weren’t even revealed. E1 got slightly more screentime than E2, I feel, because he also spent some time exploring with Ji An in the beginning. But there was just so little personal information about their characters. I wish there had been more to go on. I also don’t know this actor apart from (apparently) a cameo in Room No. 9.
I was a little more attached to E2 because he was cute (ehem), and his death just felt really unfair to me. I haven’t seen him in anything before, but when I check his Insta (purely for research purposes) it looks like he’s a stage actor. Anyways, especially since he seemed to be the youngest crew member and didn’t get any kind of individual highlight, I was all the more curious if he was still going to have a moment to shine, but that moment turned out to be his death. Also, when Dr. Hong found his body in the fridge… that was the moment I decided Tae Seok could rot in hell for all I cared. Also, apparently his freckles aren’t real?? I feel betrayed, lol.

I’m just going through the rest of the crew quickly as I’m already halfway through. I really thought I recognized Choi Young Woo from somewhere but checking DramaWiki I don’t see anything that I’d know him from? He gave me the creeps as soon as he entered the spacecraft and everyone was like, “Who the hell is this guy?” Also, when he made a very inappropriate joke when they found the first body that showed the symptoms of drowning, he was like, “I’m jealous. I know he’s a dead man, but at least he had as much water as he wanted, haha” and everyone just looked at him like, “What is wrong with you?” From the start, it just seemed like he didn’t fit in, he was the type to laugh manically in tense situation. I have to say I also didn’t expect him to die so soon, I thought there’d be more time for him to explore and gradually it would become clear that he wasn’t to be trusted. But yeah, he brought it onto himself, going in to fetch a sample by himself in a storage room where Luna was lurking around.

There was barely any time to get to know Mr. Hwang as he died as soon as they landed, but I’m glad at least they gave a couple of flashbacks to show that Ji An had talked with him before. He also seemed to know more about the Balhae accident then he let on, and as soon as Ji An asked him about ‘Luna’, he said he doubted the Director brought that topic up with her and just left. But hey, at least he did give them the initial warning about the water! It was a shame he was the first to die because he was the only person of the crew who’d been at Balhae before, heck, who’d contributed to its construction so he would’ve known much more about the structure of the Station and where all the shafts led and stuff. I like to think that he had prior knowledge of the lunar water and would’ve been able to contribute to the mission very well, but he just got unlucky. Poor guy.

I haven’t seen Kang Mal Geum in anything before either, but I liked that we were still given some insight in Won Kyung’s side of the story in the end. Instead of keeping her intentions with the experimenting a secret for Ji An to ponder for eternity, we actually were provided with some flashbacks of Won Kyung’s researching days, and how she ended up in the pile of people after getting locked in by the RX. It was a nice change to have someone actually leave a memory in regret rather than pride, however weird that may sound. But Won Kyung definitely reflected on herself and realized that what she was doing was wrong, but she still had a goal to work towards – she wanted to show Ji An the ocean. She wanted to bring water back to Earth for her younger sister to see, and that was worth more to her than anything else. Her conflicted feelings about this just made her more human to me, even though she only appeared in flashbacks. They didn’t actually find her body, I kind of expected that to happen and to be a defining moment for Ji An as well. At first I thought somehow her body wasn’t there, but I guess she was just amongst those bodies somewhere and they just didn’t really search for her specifically. Anyways, I thought that, even though Won Kyung only existed in Ji An’s memories, she was still an interesting character.

When it was revealed that Luna was a child, she immediately became less scary to me, despite her exorcist-reminiscent movements and speed. I really wonder what happened to Luna as soon as she was brought to Earth. Would the SAA have just stuck to their plan to continue experimenting on her or would Ji An have taken her in to keep her away from that? I guess we’ll never know. Anyways, I couldn’t help but notice that this girl is so pretty! Kim Shi Ah, she’s only 14 years old and she already gave such a performance without even speaking! Her glares were more than enough to convey what she was feeling to me, and that’s pretty impressive. She’s only just starting out acting in movies and dramas, so who knows what we’ll see of her in the future!

Let’s move on to the final significant characters, the people from the SAA. Director Choi, played by Gil Hae Yeon, for example. I’ve mentioned this before in my earlier reviews of Gil Hae Yeon’s characters but once again, she impressed me. From the loving mother in Melting Me Softly to the unbearable one in Something in the Rain, here she was a director with a lot of blood on her hands, but she wasn’t completely heartless, I felt. She had recurring flashbacks of what happened and it was clear that it didn’t sit right with her, no matter how cool she played it opposite the crew members. I really would’ve liked to know more about her actual involvement in the Balhae accident. It was revealed only through photographs that she personally knew Won Kyung, so what exactly was their relationship? It seemed pretty heartless of her to send Ji An on this mission just because she knew she wouldn’t reveal her sister’s wrongdoings after she came back. I just really would’ve liked to see Director Choi’s reaction after the rescue ship brought the survivors back to Earth, I wanted to know what happened to her. I just have the feeling Ji An wouldn’t sit still – she would protect Luna, all the way.

I know Heo Sung Tae from God’s Gift – 14 Days and Tunnel… and I feel like I know him from much more, but I guess not. In any case, he’s also quite a familiar face. I thought his duality was interesting. At first I just assumed he was Director Choi’s puppet, he knew exactly what was going on but pretended not to. But then he was shown checking up on Captain Han’s daughter in the hospital frequently and keeping in touch with him, and then I felt like he might have a good relationship with Captain Han, which would make him less bad. Maybe he would take over the care for the daughter? I don’t really know, but I guess he also just went along with what he was told by Director Choi. He was also there with her when they went to inform Ji An of her sister’s passing. I’m not entirely sure what his role was other than that, that’s also something I would’ve liked to get more intel on.

I may have been a little critical overall, but I did enjoy watching this show. For me it really helped that the cause of the danger, the lunar water and Luna both, were revealed quite quickly – this immediately took one level of anxiety away from me, haha. I really was on the edge of my seat for the most part, as I was really scared but also interested to see what would happen. In the end, I think it’s safe to say that the most damage was done by the people themselves, not the water or Luna. If they’d let it be, neither of them would’ve hurt anyone. It’s because the water was released by human hands that it started effecting people. As I saw someone mention in a comment somewhere, water in a desolated and Silent place is even more treacherous, all the more because it hasn’t been touched by human hands and therefore it’s more unpredictable and out of control. The water on Earth has been ‘tamed’ by humans so much that we now decide in what way it’s being used, we literally shape water the way we need it. The water on the Moon is unshaped, untouched, and therefore all the more unruly. I think this drama also shows that once humans start meddling with things that lay beyond their control, they only make things worse. They may have good intentions with it, like how they thought the lunar water might save the water shortage on Earth, but at the end of the day it really is just better to leave it alone. I truly wish no one will ever try to get water from outer space, whether it’s the Moon or Mars… Just leave the extraterrestial water alone, please. It’s not meant for us.
I guess my expectations for this series were pretty high and I was a bit disappointed by the openness of the ending and the lack of equal character building, but apart from that I still thought it was a good show. It was very well-acted, the cinematography was stunning (seriously, the shots of the moon with all those pitch-black parts that made it look like complete void really gave me goosebumps), and the tension build-up was very well done, as well as the overall construction of the story. At some point it felt to me like they were starting to rush a bit in killing all the remaining characters off as they were headed toward the ending, and that made me go ‘I don’t like this’, especially when it was Kim Sun’s time to go. I’m glad to say that despite my initial struggle to relate to the characters, I did start to feel for several throughout the story, and when they died it really did hurt. I just would’ve preferred to have a bit more overall closure at the end, but maybe it’s also realistic in a way, not to show a concrete solution to the problem. We’ll never know if they ended up utilizing the samples of lunar water for good, just like we’ll never know what will become of our own Earth until it gets there.

So yeah, there we are. It may not have been a very long review, but it did feel long as I was typing it, haha. I spent another full day on this review, so I hope it’s worthwhile to read. I didn’t expect to finish it so quickly, but this format of shorter episodes and shorter length drama really helped. I hope to see more of these hidden gems appear, because this is certainly very promising stuff. It felt more like watching a movie than a drama, to be honest, and writing this review therefore also felt different, I guess just because the genre is so unusual for me to write about. I do think this story has a lot of things we can learn from, where it’s about exploring outer space or just heeding climate change – we don’t want our world to end up the way it has in this show, but it’s definitely heading somewhere unpleasant, as far as I can tell. Let me just end this review with two requests: 1. to be mindful of our water usage, and 2. to never, EVER, get any kind of untested substance from outer space to Earth. Let’s not let The Waters of Mars or The Silent Sea become a reality, please.

I’ll be back soon with a new review, so until then, bye-bee!